The courts, not lawmakers, will decide if Minnesota is guilty of segregating students

The significant Minnesota Supreme Court ruling was announced on Wednesday.
Publish date:

Whether the State of Minnesota has been denying minority students an adequate education by segregating them into lower-performing schools will be the matter of the courts to decide, not state legislators.

The landmark Minnesota Supreme Court ruling on Wednesday is the latest development in a three-year-long battle waged by a number of Twin Cities parents, who accuse the state of enabling a school system that segregates students of color and from low-income families into worse schools.

This, they argue, violates their constitutional rights to an "adequate education," but the state had responded by saying determining what an "adequate education" is should be a matter for the Minnesota Legislature, not the courts.

The Supreme Court agreed with the parents, reversing an earlier Appeals Court decision that sided with the state, which means the case can proceed in the courts.

The court's opinion said that "separation-of-powers principles do not prevent the judiciary from ruling on whether the Legislature has violated its duty under the Education Clause," or violated equal protection clauses in the Minnesota Constitution.

The initial lawsuit was brought in 2015 by parents of students in the Minneapolis and St. Paul school districts.

Get more Bring Me The News stories by following us on Flipboard.

They argued that the schools that their children and other school-age children attend are "disproportionately comprised of students of color and students living in poverty, as compared with a number of neighboring and surrounding schools and districts."

These schools are "racially and socioeconomically segregated," they argued, making them unequal to the "neighboring and surrounding whiter and more affluent suburban schools."

They cited examples boundary decisions and school attendance areas, the formation of segregated charter schools and the decision to exempt them from desegregation plans, and the use of federal and state desegregation funds as contributing to segregation within city schools.

The Supreme Court has not made any judgment on whether the state has contributed to segregation in schools. It only ruled that the courts is equipped to make such a decision in the future.

Next Up

George Floyd protest

Activist groups release 'The People's Budget,' call for $53M Minneapolis police cuts

The People's Budget, spearheaded by Black Visions Collective and Reclaim the Block, would cut more than $53 million from MPD's budget.

Ambulance hospital emergency

Man dies weeks after November mini bike crash in Lakeville

The crash involved in mini bike and a van in Lakeville on Nov. 9.

gov. tim walz

Walz to be joined by first responders at COVID press conference Wednesday

Some departments have been forced to shift staffing or suspend service due to COVID-19.

Eddie Rosario

Report: Twins place Eddie Rosario on outright waivers

The outfielder's time with the team appears to be coming to an end.

radio station, microphone

Christian music broadcaster revealed as buyers of Go Radio

Educational Media Foundation. operates the K-Love brand, which has a presence already in the Twin Cities.

Screen Shot 2020-12-01 at 5.04.39 PM

St. Paul police chief reportedly fires officer who shot naked, unarmed man

Chief Todd Axtell said the officer's use of force was not reasonable.

Trevor May

Report: Trevor May leaving Twins to sign with Mets

The right-hander will sign a two-year deal to head to New York

Car crash

'Grim' milestone: Minnesota's traffic deaths reach 364, tying 2019 total

“With fewer vehicles on the road during the 2020 pandemic, the loss of life on Minnesota roads is beyond disappointing."

Devin Weiland

Charges: Albert Lea man, 21, fired around 90 shots at police, residents

Weiland was arrested after a standoff that lasted more than eight hours.



List of fall restart plans chosen by Minnesota school districts

This list will be updated as more school districts announce their plans.

Screen Shot 2020-11-01 at 7.29.23 AM

Police group issues complaint about book read to students in south metro

The Minnesota Police and Peace Officers Association wants the book removed.

school, classroom, students

Osterholm: School districts should decide if they return to school or not

A decision is supposed to be announced "by the week of July 27."

Everyone is talking about this Klobuchar-Kavanaugh moment

The Supreme Court nominee apologized to the Minnesota senator.

Vice report takes a look at segregation in Twin Cities charter schools

Vice has found that Twin Cities charter schools have a higher rate of segregation than public schools.