Skip to main content

What government shouldn't be doing in order to improve the economy

In as much as politicians would like us to believe that the economy has turned around, those of us building a business, earning a paycheck, or just attempting to make ends meet know this is a dismal economy. President Calvin Coolidge once said, “The business of America is business." So, why is this recession so bad and what do we do to fix it?
  • Author:
  • Updated:

In as much as politicians would like us to believe that the economy has turned around, those of us building a business, earning a paycheck, or just attempting to make ends meet know this is a dismal economy. President Calvin Coolidge once said, “The business of America is business." Business has been the engine that created and made the United States the most productive and creative society in the history of mankind. So, why is this recession so bad and what do we do to fix it?

According to Stanford University Economics Professor John Taylor, this economic recession is the “worst ever.” Four years into this recession, here is where we are:

* Long term unemployment (this includes those no longer able to file for unemployment, the under-employed, and recent graduates still looking for work) is 15.1 percent nationally (June 2012) according to bureau of labor statistics; Minnesota is 12.1 percent through this 2nd quarter. This is far beyond the politically correct and incomplete 8.2% reported for federal and 5.6 percent for Minnesota for June 2012 (U3= includes those able to file). We know how bad it is even if the reporting is not forthright.

* The Dow Jones is still trying to get back to its 2007, pre-crash high of over 14,000. Nasdaq is at about 60 percent of its 2000 high. The market doesn’t believe we’ve turned the corner.

* As of this writing, every major sector of the stock market has reported lower revenue growth for the 2nd quarter (Bloomberg quote). Customers aren’t buying.

* 30 year fixed rate mortgages are at over 20 year lows and still the housing market and building industry remain depressed. Home buyers just aren’t buying despite the incentives of low cost of money and low prices.

* Small business lending peaked at 2008 and struggles to get back to those levels. Whether new regulations impede borrowing or the fear of an unknown future, business owners are cautious about borrowing and investing.

* The U.S. economy’s growth rate is only 1.5 percent. Many economists believe twice that to be a healthy rate. People aren’t spending if they don’t have to.

* Manufacturing rates are down or flat in major markets – they don’t see demand.

Government efforts over the last 4 years have not helped. But since it’s hard to prove what would have happened if action had not been taken, I won’t argue here whether TARP and Stimulus made matters worse or better. Although, Professor Taylor and other economists strongly believe that these actions made the economy worse.

This brings me to the point of this piece.

In my humble opinion, it is time to discuss not what government should do … but what government should not do.

Americans are good hearted people. We give more to charity than any of the 153 countries surveyed last year - between $212B and nearly $300B depending on the measurement method. Americans also volunteer and help strangers more than any other country. Midwesterners and Minnesotans even more so.

Since the new deal, we have increasingly looked to government to do more and more of the things we used to do as individuals, through our churches, through volunteer organizations, and through our communities.

As a result of looking to government to do what we did, government is much larger, bureaucracies once created never die – and they need to be fed with our tax dollars. While one could argue that big isn’t necessarily bad:

* Government is by it’s nature very inefficient – after all, they spend other people’s money, which always spends more easily than one’s own;

* Government bureaucrats are easily disconnected from those they serve;

* Measures of their success tends to be based upon how many more people they help (rather than how many people get off the government dole).

U.S. business taxes are unreasonably high. According to CNN Money (hardly a conservative organization) when Japan lowered its tax rate earlier this year, we became the nation with the highest combined federal and state tax rate in the world at 39.2 percent.

In a world of limited resources there may be much we'd like to do, but only so much we can afford.

Because government has taken on so much, we have become dependent upon it far beyond its ability to provide, beyond what those contributing taxes can afford. So much so that we risk killing the golden goose and this is why:

We live in a world where capital, people, and information move freely. Businesses have bought into the concept of sunk cost … said another way, a bad investment doesn’t justify putting more good money after bad – to compound metaphors.

So as costs and regulations become less favorable in one market, a smart business makes incremental investments and hires in a less expensive one. Actions our government has/is chasing away what made us great.

Now is the time for frank discussion.

We need our representatives in Washington D.C. as well St. Paul, MN to apply discipline to law making and spending. They need to preserve and protect our way of life and encourage businesses to stay in the U.S. (or Minnesota), eliminate wasteful and value-destroying regulations and, like businesses and families, cut out luxuries to balance their budgets, reduce debt and live within our means.

Here are a few guidelines as they consider this important work:

* Good parents create independent offspring capable of taking care of themselves. Government should not foster the reverse or protect us from our own stupidity. Tough love makes for good citizens.

* Everyone needs to pay some taxes. People don’t value what they get for free.

* Reverse those government actions which disincentive individuals and organizations from helping one another.

* Government shouldn’t pick winners and losers, subsidize anyone for activities with no demand, or protect us from our own dumb decisions or not buying our own insurance (rebuilding in a floodzone for example).

* In a tough economy we can not afford luxuries – its time to economize

* Debt saddles our children and restricts our future – government can’t do what it should if a large percentage of taxes go just to interest and principle payments. Fix this now.

* Citizens can’t expect to only work to 50 or 55 and have enough money to live into their 90s – encourage saving, discourage labor contracts which pass the retirement buck to the next guy to pay.

* Representatives need to be unafraid to say "this is not what government is for" no matter how much we’d like to be able to do something.

There is much work to do to protect our economy, remove what’s been done to make it ill, nurse it back to health, and ultimately protect our way of life.

John J. Alexander is President of Business Development Advisors, Founder and Chair of the Twin Cities Angels, and business author of the Angel Investment Tax Credit. Email him at:

Next Up

Screen Shot 2022-08-05 at 7.55.41 AM

Minneapolis police trying to ID pair in connection to fatal shooting

Police say the two people pictured are connected to the fatal shooting of Ivan Redday last month.


17-year-old girl killed in southern Minnesota crash

The crash happened early Thursday morning near Lake Crystal.

Tim Gannon

Ex-Brooklyn Center police chief sues city over resignation

Tim Gannon alleges he was forced to resign following the fatal shooting of Daunte Wright.

boat, boating, lake

Men injured after boat crash sends propeller spinning onto craft

The motor reportedly flew out of the water and severely injured two men on the boat.


Officials investigating possible spill near Enbridge pipeline in Wisconsin

It comes as another water spill is being reported at Enbridge's Line 3 pipeline in Minnesota.


Lightning strike outside White House kills Wisconsin couple

The bolt of lightning was captured on video by a local TV camera.


NASCAR star Kyle Busch flees Mall of America after shooting

Busch was at the megamall with his wife and son when a gunman opened fire Thursday.


Triple-fatal crash involving car full of Missourians in Minnesota

Four people from Missouri were in a vehicle that collided with a semi.

Screen Shot 2022-08-03 at 7.58.19 AM

Teen charged with murder of 15-year-old at light rail station

The victim died from a gunshot wound to the chest following the shooting Tuesday.

Depressaria depressana

Invasive moth flying around Minnesota for first time

The little bugger was confirmed in Wisconsin in 2018 and Iowa in 2020.


More business owners see improvement in Minnesota economy

31 percent of Minnesota business owners and managers surveyed by the state chamber of commerce and a public relations firm see the state's economy improving. That's up from just 13 percent in last year's Business Barometer survey. As for what obstacles they face, high taxes was the most common concern followed by health care costs and finding qualified workers.

Clear choice for a strong America, a vibrant and healthy economy

President Calvin Coolidge famously said, “The business of America is business.” There was a President who understood the linkage between a healthy economy, a favorable business environment, and jobs. For those of us starting, building, or growing businesses, the choice of who to elect for our (next) President has never been more clear and the contrast between the candidates has never been more striking.

Don't get too excited about economic bright spots

Sure, there are certain parts of the economy that are perking up, but, overall there are many hurdles in Washington preventing full economic says business contributor John Alexander.

Romney's wealth shouldn't matter

So, Romney's got a lot of money. Our business contributor Glenn Dorfman says that is the wrong thing to look at when selecting a leader...

Survey: farming helps economy grow in rural states

The economy remains strong in rural areas of 10 Midwest and Plains states because of the health of agricultural businesses there. The overall economic index on the new monthly Rural Mainstreet survey rose to 58.5 in May from April's already healthy 57.1. Any score above 50 on the index suggests growth in the months ahead.