What is Minnesota's provider tax and what happens if it's not renewed?

The tax is due to sunset, and Democrats want to keep it, but Republicans don't.
Publish date:

One of the major sticking points in the budget negotiations between DFLers in the governor's office and House and the GOPers in the Senate is the future of the "provider tax."

The provider tax has existed since 1992, created by the Legislature and then Gov. Arne Carlson to provide funding for MinnesotaCare, though it's now also used for other healthcare programs for low-income Minnesotans.

MinnesotaCare offers health coverage for those who either can't afford private insurance or don't get it from their employer, but earn too much to qualify for Medicaid or Medical Assistance.

The tax itself is a 2 percent levy on medical services provided by Minnesota's doctors, hospitals, opticians, psychologists, physical therapists, ambulance services and wholesale drug distributors, and more, with the taxes applied to the bills they charge patients for treatment/hospital stays etc.

MinnPost notes that 1.5 million Minnesotans benefit from the services the provider tax helps to pay for, and says that both Democrats and Republicans in the Legislature want to continue funding these programs.

They do however disagree over using the provider tax – which generates $600 million a year – to fund these programs, with state Republicans wanting to allow the tax to expire as scheduled at the end of 2019.

Democrats however want to renew it, with Gov. Tim Walz having pledged to sign its renewal if such a bill reaches his desk.

So what are the arguments?

Republicans, among them House Minority Leader, Rep. Kurt Daudt, dub the provider tax the "sick tax." They see renewing the planned sunset as a tax increase on Minnesotans who have private or employer-provided health insurance, who see the 2 percent tax tacked onto their medical bills.

They believe that with Minnesota continuing to produce budget surpluses, there is space within existing state coffers to cover the cost of the programs the provider tax pays for.

Republicans have suggested an alternative: taxing insurance claims paid by health plans and third-party administrators, so the tax would be levied on insurers rather than coming direct from Minnesotans' medical bills.

But if the tax does expire, there are no guarantees that the 2 percent tax reduction would be reflected in the prices charged by medical service providers.

Democrats, on the other hand, argue that renewing the tax isn't a tax increase given that it's been in place for 27 years, and that failing to renew it would leave a huge hole in Minnesota's finances in a few years' time.

"If this fund was to go away, we know that by the end of 2022 we would be in deficit," said Rep. Tina Liebling, the chair of the House health and human services finance committee, per MPR. "The problem there is that big expenses that are now being paid for would then have to be paid for by the general fund."

MPR also notes that Gov. Walz and Democrats see the loss of the provider tax as a potential blow for their hopes of offering a MinnesotaCare buy-in, which would see MinnesotaCare compete with other health insurers by offering a "public option" health plan.

Both the provider tax renewal and the proposed 20-cent gas tax hike are proving to be the major sticking points at least on the Republican side as both parties try to reach an accord before the end of the legislative session on Monday.

If no deal is reached by then, a special session would have to be called to figure out the next budget.

Next Up

Mayor Brad Wiersum

'Please, please, please get vaccinated,' Minnetonka mayor pleads

This comes as the local state of emergency officially ends.

YouTube - Jeopardy screengrab minneapolis

Can you answer all the Minneapolis questions from this week's 'Jeopardy?'

KARE personalities including Randy Shaver and Rena Sarigianopoulos presented the clues.

Pexels - woman shop mask covid CROP

35 counties, including most of Twin Cities, now COVID hotspots

The CDC recommends everyone wear a mask in public, indoor places in these counties.

covid, coronavirus

CDC document: Delta variant as contagious as chickenpox

Vaccines remain very effective at preventing severe illness from the delta variant, however.

Flickr - smoke McGregor minnesota wildfire July 29 2021 - Lorie Shaull

'Unprecedented': The wildfire smoke isn't going anywhere this weekend

The air quality alert that was supposed to end Friday is now in effect into early next week.

Alexis Saborit

Charges: Woman killed in horrific Shakopee attack was trying to leave suspect

The shocking incident happened at an intersection Wednesday afternoon.

3M Open, Tony Finau

Multiple injuries after pickup crashes into shuttle bus at 3M Open

Blaine police listed 25 people as being involved in the collision.

Screen Shot 2020-06-15 at 7.11.05 AM

Teen arrested in connection to recent St. Cloud shootings

The shootings, which occurred on Tuesday and Wednesday, did not result in injury or property damage.


What happens if a missile is heading toward Minnesota?

How you'd be warned, and what you should do afterward.

What happened at the Minnesota Capitol last night?

The legislative session came to an end – here's how things stand.

Screen Shot 2019-03-29 at 10.54.48 AM

What's in the Minnesota Senate GOP's budget proposal?

The GOPers have proposed a smaller budget than Gov. Tim Walz and the House DFL.

Screen Shot 2019-02-14 at 10.51.28 AM

New report reveals what went wrong with MNLARS

The state's licensing and vehicle registration system has been beset by problems.

What happened to Minnesota's $500M infrastructure bill?

There wasn't enough time to get a bonding bill over the line, amid pushback from Republicans.

Republicans propose alternative to Gov. Walz's gas tax plan

They want to cut the tax, and make additional taxation optional.

What's in the tax reform bill just passed by the House?

Also, find out how your Minnesota representative voted on it.