Skip to main content

What Klobuchar and Franken asked Supreme Court nominee Neil Gorsuch

Both of Minnesota's U.S. senators are on the committee that is questioning Gorsuch.

For 10 hours Tuesday, a group of senators – including Amy Klobuchar and Al Franken – continued to question Supreme Court nominee Neil Gorsuch.

Gorsuch was President Donald Trump's pick to fill the open seat on the U.S. Supreme Court, which has been vacant since former Justice Antonin Scalia’s death in February of 2016. Former President Barack Obama nominated Merrick Garland for the seat, but the Senate, controlled by Republicans, never held hearings or a vote.

Gorsuch's confirmation hearings will continue Wednesday – but here's a look at what Minnesota's senators asked the judge during Tuesday.

Franken on politics, and the case of the frozen trucker

Senator Franken's Questioning of Judge Neil Gorsuch in Confirm...

WATCH ➝ My questioning of Judge Neil Gorsuch during his confirmation hearing before the Senate Judiciary Committee.

Posted by U.S. Senator Al Franken on Tuesday, March 21, 2017

Franken's questions frequently centered around the politics of Gorsuch's nomination. Franken asked the current nominee how he felt about the treatment of Garland, fished for his thoughts on other cases, and also used quotes from Trump advisors and colleagues that describe Gorsuch as a means to an end – not as an impartial judge of the law.

Each time Gorsuch rebuffed Franken, keeping his words short (and sometimes being cut off by an impatient Franken) and not sharing much.

Late in Franken's questioning, Gorsuch said he'd been "trying to faithfully answer your questions as best I can, consistent with the constraints I have as a sitting judge. Here to answer questions about my qualifications and my record."

Maybe the most direct questioning of Gorsuch's record came right off the bat, when Franken detailed the case of the frozen trucker. You can read the details from CNN here, but basically the breaks on the driver's truck froze in sub-zero temps in Illinois. He began showing signs of hypothermia while waiting, and relayed that to dispatch, who for hours kept telling him to just wait.

He was fired after unhitching his truck and driving it around to warm up. When it went to Gorsuch's court, the judges agreed he shouldn't have been fired – Gorsuch however wrote this dissenting opinion.

Franken said that dissent worried him, and told Gorsuch: "I had a career in identifying absurdity, and I know it when I see it. And it makes me question your judgment."

You can watch Franken's 30 minutes of questioning here.

Klobuchar

Klobuchar started off with easier questions about cameras in the courtroom and disclosure rules, before getting to what she termed the "harder stuff."

She went back to something Gorsuch has previously said, that if a judge likes every outcome they reach, they're probably not a very good judge, then asked Gorsuch about continuing to confirm rulings because of strong precedent, regardless of his own personal feelings.

For context, she mentioned two current Supreme Court justices that, during confirmation hearings said they'd adhere to precedent, but then broke from precedent during Citizens United.

"To us up here, it was a major overturning of precedent, so that's why we're so concerned when people say 'Oh we're going to respect precedent,' and then they come in and do that," Klobuchar said. "And you've suggested that you would actually go further than Citizens United."

They got into a back-and-forth about campaign finance regulations and the Hobby Lobby case, then Klobuchar asks about the philosophy of originalism – that the words on the Constitution should be taken to mean what the writers and people at that time meant.

Klobuchar specifically asks about the Constitution referring only to "him" or "he" in regards to a president, implying a woman could not be president if taken literally. And that the Constitution says Congress has authority over land forces, so would the modern Air Force then not be part of that?

Gorsuch, to both of those points, said of course that wasn't the case.

Klobuchar's questioning starts at about the 5-hour, 30-minute mark here.

Next Up

Pixabay laptop keyboard phone dark

Charges: Duluth man had hundreds of child porn images, videos

The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children found nearly 330 images on the man's electronic devices.

hennepin county sheriff water patrol lake minnetonka

Scuba diver found dead in Lake Minnetonka identified as 20-year-old

The Hennepin County Medical Examiner's Office said 20-year-old Brady Alan Aune, from Elko New Market, died of freshwater drowning on June 3.

Screen Shot 2022-06-30 at 11.18.35 AM

Felony charges filed after authorities search 'Peacebunny Cottage'

The president of the rabbit rescue non-profit faces multiple animal cruelty charges after over 40 rabbits were found dead inside the organization's barn.

monkeypox virus

Minnesota up to 6 confirmed cases of monkeypox virus

Most people recover at home within 2-4 weeks.

thc edibles

Did Minnesota just accidentally legalize THC?

A Republican lawmaker who voted to approve the new law in May is already talking about rolling it back.

Screen Shot 2022-06-30 at 3.19.42 PM

Gasoline may be cause of sewer explosion on U of M campus

An all-clear was given around 9 p.m. Thursday, with residents in the area allowed to return to their homes.

image

Overwhelming demand for THC products on first day of new law in MN

One shop owner said his Chaska store broke the online sales record before they opened Friday morning.

Flickr - Lake Minnetonka boat - Greg Gjerdingen

Increased drunk boating enforcement over 4th of July weekend

The increased enforcement is part of the Operation Dry Water initiative.

Kayak

Four kayakers stranded, rescued in Chisholm park

The kayakers became stranded at Redhead Mountain Bike Park Thursday afternoon.

SherburneCoJailDrugArrests

Duo charged after 10-pound meth package sent to wrong address

More than 10 pounds of meth are off the street thanks to a delivery error.

Screen Shot 2022-07-01 at 11.01.32 AM

Bird Rides' suburban expansion continues in Minnesota

Its scooter season in Minnesota. The latest on where you can find Bird e-scooters:

Flickr - police lights squad siren - Edward Kimmel

Man found dead with 'trauma to his face' in St. Paul

A man was found dead with "trauma to his face" in St. Paul after 3 a.m.

Related

Klobuchar and Franken question Neil Gorsuch, pt. 2

What Minnesota's senators asked about on their final day in front of the SCOTUS nominee.

Franken's a definite 'No' on Neil Gorsuch

Al Franken, not a fan of Neil Gorsuch as a Supreme Court justice.

Franken and Klobuchar will support a Neil Gorsuch filibuster

Here's how Democrats will try to block Neil Gorsuch – and how Republicans could get around it.

Klobuchar is also a 'No' on Neil Gorsuch

The senator officially announced she'll vote against the Supreme Court Justice nominee.

What Franken and Klobuchar asked during the Sally Yates hearing

Both of Minnesotas senators were part of the big Russia/2016 election/Mike Flynn hearing Monday.

Klobuchar asks what steps were taken to protect 2016 election from cyber threats

Sen. Amy Klobuchar – with 25 other supporters in the Senate – wants a detailed explanation.