Skip to main content

What the big mining and environment meeting in Duluth was all about

This all centers around more than 234,000 acres in the Superior National Forest.

Should more than 230,000 acres of Superior National Forest land be off limits to any new mining projects for the foreseeable future?

Or should that land remain open to possible projects that could bring jobs to northeastern Minnesota?

This is the big dispute that brought hundreds of people to the Duluth Entertainment Convention Center Thursday evening, for a public input meeting that will help shape which side ultimately wins the debate.

The meeting, held by the U.S. Forest Service and Bureau of Land Management, was about a proposal to withdraw 234,328 acres of land in the Superior National Forest from any possible mining projects. (More on this below.)

The arguments came down to the same points they always have.

One side argues the mine is too big of a threat to the environment (specifically the nearby Boundary Waters Canoe Area), and there's no way to 100 percent ensure nearby land and water is protected.

The other side counters that mining has been done safely and within the rules for decades in Minnesota, and that new mining projects would create jobs for a region that's really hurting economically.

There are also write-ups in the Duluth News Tribune, WDIO, Star Tribune, MPR and elsewhere.

More on the withdrawal proposal

This goes back to December of 2016, and a decision made by federal agencies while still under control of the Barack Obama administration.

The mining company Twin Metals Minnesota had been exploring a possible new project on some of the Superior National Forest Land that it held a lease on for decades.

The company had asked the federal government to renew those leases. But the U.S. Forest Service and Bureau of Land Management rejected their requests in December, saying they were concerned about the environmental impact on the Boundary Waters.

At that same time, the federal agencies took steps to block any mining work on the land for years into the future.

They submitted a withdrawal request, which essentially put those 234,328 acres in a time-out zone for two years so an environmental review could be done. Meanwhile, the agencies are doing a study to determine if the land should be off-limits to mining projects completely for 20 years (the maximum allowed by law)

The withdrawal notice says it would be done for the "protection of the natural resources and waters" there.

What's next?

Thursday's meeting in Duluth wasn't about coming up with an answer. It was part of the larger process to consider the withdrawal request, which is currently in the middle of a public comment period.

You can submit comments by going here, or by emailing

Anything submitted before the deadline of Aug. 17, 2017, will be given full consideration. You can still send in your thoughts after that, but there's no guarantee they'll get read.

The environmental review will be put together, then sent to the Secretary of the Interior for a final decision.

A decision on whether to actually withdraw the lands, or reject the withdrawal request, isn't expected for months, and quite possibly a couple years.

Next Up

Brandon Gardas

St. Michael standoff suspect charged, bail set at $10 million

A judge on Monday set the high bail due to "very significant concerns of public safety" regarding Brandon Gardas.


Minnesota's premier trauma center housed at HCMC

The Minneapolis center is nationally recognized in pediatric trauma

Crisp & Green

Crisp & Green opening 13th store in Twin Cities in July

The fast-casual salad and grains restaurant has exploded onto the food scene.

FLickr - Target Field 2019 - mark grabe

Twins to host post-game concert with country star at Target Field

Country singer Cole Swindell is expected to perform for up to 75 minutes after the conclusion of the Blue Jays-Twins contest.


Canton Restaurant closes after nearly 40 years in Burnsville

It's the end of an era in the Twin Cities restaurant world.

Screen Shot 2022-06-27 at 12.47.20 PM

Luck strikes in Minnesota: lottery winners in Duluth, Grand Marais

The North Shore just so happened to be a lucky place to be this past weekend.


Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Monday, June 27

BA.5 is expected to become the dominant subvariant in Minnesota.

police lights squad car

60-year-old woman arrested after firing shots inside Spicer home

SWAT evacuated nearby residents during the incident.

Florida Georgia Line

Florida Georgia Line booked to play at the Minnesota State Fair

The band is the second country music act to be booked this year.


First case of monkeypox confirmed in Minnesota

The Minnesota Department of Health says the risk to the public is "considered low" at this time.


Mining, the forest, and Trump: Why two MN Democrats are in a public fight

It's all over possible mining projects in 234,328 acres of the Superior National Forest.

What that daredevil protest at the Vikings game was all about

How U.S. Bank and the Dakota Access Pipeline are connected.

PolyMet gets the forest land it wanted for that copper-nickel mine

PolyMet got the land. But what else has to happen before the mine gets approved?

Let's talk about that Standing Rock check-in post getting shared on Facebook

A Facebook post is telling people to check in at Standing Rock to "confuse" law enforcement.

PolyMet mine land swap would hurt threatened wolves and lynx, lawsuit argues

Two groups are saying the copper-nickel mine – which would be enabled by the land swap – could hurt two federally threatened species.

Sorting out which Minnesota agencies are helping at ND pipeline protests – and why

One of the big questions: Why are Minnesota law enforcement agencies at the scene of the North Dakota protest?

The protested North Dakota pipeline will be blocked for (at least) a bit longer

The possibility of letting the pipeline company drill underneath Lake Oahe has been under review.

Franken wants 'excessive and unnecessary' spraying of pipeline protesters investigated

"We're just not going to let people, protesters in large groups, come in and threaten officers," the sheriff said.