Skip to main content

What's going on with St. Paul's trash collection?

Residents have scored a victory in their lawsuit against the city's new organized collection system.

Mayor Melvin Carter has promised that St. Paul residents will still get their garbage taken away, even though a court ordered the city to suspend its organized collections as of June 30.

A judge found in favor of a lawsuit brought by a group of citizens who want to revert back to the old system of trash collection, which had residents contract private vendors to take away their garbage.

The court ordered that the decision to move to organized collection – which charges citizens standardized rates for citywide garbage pickup – should be put to a public referendum this November.

The ruling has put a question mark over what would happen to collections between July and then.

But on Friday, Mayor Carter has said the city will appeal the decision, and in the meantime will honor its contract with the private haulers it had hired to carry out the organized collections.

That's expected to cost the city $13 million, with Carter saying he might have to tap budget reserves, or increase property taxes, to cover it.

How did we get here?

The city transitioned to a centralized collection system in October, giving haulers designated routes to collect trash across the city.

The move was not without controversy. Opponents of centralized collection have said the privatized system is better for recycling and composting, and have emphasized the importance of personal choice.

A group of concerned residents, who have deemed themselves St. Paul Trash, then petitioned the St. Paul City Council to leave the decision up to citizens in the form of a referendum. The petition had more than 6,469 signatures, which the council found to satisfy requirements for a referendum.

But the council also stated it has the authority to make such decisions without a vote, rejecting the petition in November.

St. Paul Trash responded by suing the city in February. With three residents listed as plaintiffs, the organization states its petition and number of signatures means the city must put the referendum on the November ballot.

A Thursday decision by Ramsey County District Court Judge Leonardo Castro agreed with the plaintiffs. In a memo released Thursday, Castro states the council did not properly exercise its authority in blocking the petition.

“... it was improper exercise of power for the Council to refuse to place the Referendum on the November 2019 ballot,” the memo reads.

Sign up: Subscribe to our daily newsletters

Supporters of organized collection include Ward 2 City Council Member Rebecca Noecker, who said the following on Facebook Friday.

“I support organized collection. While it is far from perfect, our new system is providing quality service at consistent rates citywide, reducing illegal dumping, and decreasing the number of trucks on our streets and the wear and tear and pollution that come along with them."

The Star Tribune reports that the organized collection system has reduced traffic and confusion over pricing, making it cheaper for some, albeit not all residents.

But at the same time, the city has seen half of its trash haulers leave town, while the new system has faced problems — including some residents refusing to pay their bills. 

Next Up

money hundred dollar bills

Chanhassen psychologist pleads guilty to $550K billing fraud

Charles Howard Jorenby, 57, pleaded guilty to one count of healthcare fraud in U.S. District Court late last month.

police lights squad car

Charges: Coon Rapids man had 25 pounds of cocaine from Mexico

Luis Javier Avila-Lopez, 38, was arrested after law enforcement seized the cocaine earlier this year.

Screen Shot 2022-12-04 at 9.16.52 AM

Responding to Twitter release, former Minnesota GOP candidate calls for 'bullets'

It was in response to a thread on Twitter concerning the social media giant's moderation efforts regarding political issues.

snow

NWS: 'Safe to say' more active weather is ahead

Three rounds of light snow around Minnesota before more substantial precipitation becomes a possibility.

7F060B54-5776-4E1A-A42C-F36C22FAF493

Hero dad who stopped carjacker who fled with his kids identified

A GoFundMe has been set up to support Derek Gotchie and his family following the incident.

Screen Shot 2022-12-03 at 4.35.18 PM

Watch: New London-Spicer wins 3A championship on incredible walk-off TD

New London-Spicer defeated the unbeaten Dilworth-Glyndon-Felton in remarkable circumstances.

MoorheadMurderSuspect

Suspect in woman's killing in Moorhead is arrested

James Kollie Jr. was arrested Friday evening.

Jennifer Carnahan

Former chair Jennifer Carnahan sues Minnesota GOP, which is suing her back

Carnahan stepped down under a cloud of controversy in August 2021.

Minneapolis Fire Department

One injured after leaping from burning vacant building in Minneapolis

Authorities say the building is known to be used by squatters.

ambulance

Head-on crash leaves two drivers dead in southeastern Minnesota

The crash happened in Houston County just before 4 p.m. Friday.

Related

St. Paul trash collection must go on ballot, MN Supreme Court rules

St. Paul Mayor Melvin Carter said decentralizing trash collection could lead to a property tax increase.

MN Supreme Court hears arguments for St. Paul trash collection lawsuit

Residents have sued the city over a centralized trash collection system.

St. Paul mayor receives racist threats over trash collection vote

The mayor has been forced to increase security in the wake of the threats.

St. Paul votes to keep organized trash collection

It was the hot button issue on Election Day 2019.

garbage truck

Trash collection questions will be on the ballot in Bloomington

The City of Bloomington switched to an organized collection system in 2016, sparking a petition and lawsuit from residents.

Screen Shot 2021-08-14 at 9.48.22 AM

Here's what's in the budgets proposed by Minneapolis, St. Paul mayors

Both budgets will leverage increased property tax levies and funds from the American Rescue Plan Act to support spending.

Melvin Carter

St. Paul mayor joins coalition to look into guaranteed income

Guaranteed income would mean recurring cash payments to residents, with no strings attached.

melvin carter public works

St. Paul replaces 10 public works vehicles with cleaner alternatives

The city says the change is equal to taking more than 20,000 cars off the road.