Skip to main content

For both Nienstedt and the archdiocese, the question is: 'What's next?'

  • Author:
  • Updated:

One day after the sudden resignation of Archbishop John Nienstedt, Minnesota's Catholic community is talking about the way forward.

Nienstedt resigned from the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis Monday, just 10 days after the archdiocese was charged with failing to protect children as part of a sex abuse case.

Jennifer Haselberger is among those who say the move is a first step for the church. She herself resigned as the archdiocese's top canon lawyer in 2013, and told authorities about how superiors had mishandled and delayed reporting clergy sex abuse.

"I think the change is greater than these two men," Haselberger told KSTP. “I think we need to have faith in the leadership of the archdiocese and I don't think many people have faith in the leadership that existed."

Nienstedt's critics

Reports say Nienstedt was known for his strict adherence to orthodox doctrine and was one of the most outspoken supporters of banning same-sex marriage in Minnesota.

“He was a warrior bishop waging a cultural war,” Charles Reid, a professor of canon and civil law at the University of St. Thomas, told the Star Tribune.

MinnPost noted he had little support among Catholics since taking the role as archbishop in 2008, with some calling him controversial.

Even some Catholic leaders were dubious of the archbishop.

Rev. Michael Tegeder of St. Frances Cabrini Church in Minneapolis, told the Associated Press that Nienstedt "came into this diocese without really any empathy" and "undermined so many of the good things that were going on here."

His critics only got louder when the accusations of a coverup arose in the fall of 2013 (accusations Nienstedt has denied).

But even as lawsuits mounted (eventually forcing the archdiocese to file for bankruptcy) Nienstedt declared he wouldn't resign.

That was until Monday, when the Vatican announced it had accepted the archbishop's resignation in the wake of the most recent charges. (See a timeline events leading up to Nienstedt's resignation here.)

Some say Nienstedt's resignation will define his legacy, but many agree the church can now move forward.

Moving forward

"I think this is an opportunity for us to move forward, but I would hate for people to look at this situation and see this is the way the church generally operates," Haselberger told KARE 11.

She told the National Catholic Reporter it's important for the archdiocese to move quickly through bankruptcy and to resolve the charges filed against it, adding, "Then the real business of renewal can begin."

Other church leaders agree.

"I think it's the most positive thing that could happen," Denny Farrell, parish administrator at Guardian Angels Catholic Church in Oakdale, told the Pioneer Press. "It's a giant step into the path for healing. Regardless of what Nienstedt did or didn't do, there is a strong feeling in the pews that a leadership change is needed."

MPR News says new leadership will likely bring in more donations to the archdiocese, which had been lacking in recent years as parishioners lost confidence in the archbishop in the wake of clergy abuse allegations.

"People are just reluctant even to support the parishes they love, knowing that some of the money was going to go to the diocese," Rev. Tim Power, a retired priest, told MPR News.

What's next for Nienstedt

Resigning from the role as archbishop does not mean he is defrocked. In fact, some are calling for more explanation from the Vatican as to whether he resigned on his own, or if he was forced out.

Nienstedt is completely done as an administrator and archbishop, Reid explained to FOX 9, but he is still able to act as a priest – saying mass and performing confirmations.

As for what is in Nienstedt's immediate future, Reid isn't sure.

Haselberger, speaking to KARE 11, notes the former archbishop will still continue to receive financial support from the Twin Cities archdiocese until he dies – unless he is given an appointment somewhere else.

Next Up

hennepin county medical center

Boy, 7, dies after being pulled from pool in south Minneapolis

The boy was pulled from a pool at a home in south Minneapolis.

Screen Shot 2022-06-28 at 8.32.18 AM

Nashville man leaving wedding shot in the face in Minneapolis

He was leaving a wedding when gunfire erupted near the Stone Arch Bridge Saturday night.


Abogados Café in St. Paul is the first law-themed coffee shop in America

The new business is Minnesota's first Latina-owned coffee shop.


Man dies after being run over by his Clydesdale in St. Cloud

The accident happened Sunday afternoon at the St. Cloud MAC.

Brandon Gardas

St. Michael standoff suspect charged, bail set at $10 million

A judge on Monday set the high bail due to "very significant concerns of public safety" regarding Brandon Gardas.


Minnesota's premier trauma center housed at HCMC

The Minneapolis center is nationally recognized in pediatric trauma

Crisp & Green

Crisp & Green opening 13th store in Twin Cities in July

The fast-casual salad and grains restaurant has exploded onto the food scene.

FLickr - Target Field 2019 - mark grabe

Twins to host post-game concert with country star at Target Field

Country singer Cole Swindell is expected to perform for up to 75 minutes after the conclusion of the Blue Jays-Twins contest.


Canton Restaurant closes after nearly 40 years in Burnsville

It's the end of an era in the Twin Cities restaurant world.

Screen Shot 2022-06-27 at 12.47.20 PM

Luck strikes in Minnesota: lottery winners in Duluth, Grand Marais

The North Shore just so happened to be a lucky place to be this past weekend.