Updated:
Original:

Why didn't a plan to expand takeout alcohol sales for bars, restaurants pass the Senate?

Restaurants and breweries have said allowing cocktails and growlers to-go would help their bottom line.
Bar beer

Allowing bars and restaurants to sell takeaway cocktails and increase the amount of beer and wine people can buy with to-go orders is a way to help the industry hit hard by the pandemic and COVID-related shutdowns

But it was a no-go at the state Capitol on Monday during the Minnesota Legislature's seventh special session of the year, during which lawmakers passed a $242 million COVID relief bill to help small businesses and extend unemployment.

State leaders previously passed a bill that allows establishments to sell a limited amount of beer and wine with takeout orders.

But proposals that would allow for more flexibility in liquor sales – something the industry has said would help their bottom line – were voted down despite Gov. Tim Walz saying he would sign such a bill.

In the Republican-controlled Senate on Monday, Sen. Sandy Pappas, DFL-St. Paul, offered an amendment to the relief bill that would have doubled the amount of wine and beer someone can buy with a takeout order, allow takeaway cocktails and allow all of the state's craft breweries to sell growlers (under state law, craft breweries are prohibited from selling growlers once they reach a certain size). 

"We're saying we want to help small businesses ... but actually what they really want to be able to do is they want to be able to sell their products. They want to be able to sell to a public that wants to buy the product." Pappas said. "And this costs the state absolutely nothing to allow them to do that."

Although the state has provided some limited options for establishments to sell their product, larger craft breweries aren't allowed to sell growlers and microdistilleries aren't allowed to do off-sale, she said. Meanwhile, takeaway cocktails "would really save some of our small restaurants" that are only open for to-go orders, which is "just not enough income for them."

Despite House Republicans being supportive of allowing takeaway cocktails and other temporary changes to the state's liquor laws during the pandemic, Republicans in the Senate opposed the idea. 

"We really don't know what the hidden consequences are" if this amendment were to be approved, Senate Commerce and Consumer Protection Finance and Policy Chair Sen. Gary Dahms, R-Redwood Falls, said, noting they haven't had any hearings on this and he knows law enforcement isn't supportive of the proposal.

This proposal is billed as the do-all that's going to salvage a lot of things, and "it's not going to do that," Dahms said. 

"These changes are drastic changes to the way we currently do our liquor situations," he added. "So, when we start talking about breweries, 'all breweries should have the opportunity to sell growlers,' I'm hardpressed to think that a brewery that ... manufactures maybe 100,000 barrels a year needs to be selling growlers with the system they have through the distribution system they have."

Dahms said breweries' priorities were to get financial help and get relief on some fees, which is provided in the current relief bill. Prior to the special session, the Minnesota Craft Brewers Guild encouraged craft beer fans to contact their legislators to ask them to support the relief bill and the amendment that would allow all breweries in the state to sell to-go beer in containers up to 64 ounces. 

Dahms said the proposal means a "whole new way of doing business" that's going to "change the liquor industry drastically," adding, "I don't think this is something we should be doing on the floor at the last minute."

Sign up for our BREAKING NEWS newsletters

Senate Majority Leader Paul Gazelka, R-East Gull Lake, also opposed the amendment because caucus leaders agreed to not add anything to the relief bill they all agreed to prior to the special session.

Senate Minority Leader Susan Kent, DFL-Woodbury, took the same stance as Gazelka, but said she supports the spirit of the amendment but because of the deal caucus leaders made "I'm going to keep my word." 

Kent questioned why the proposal was never given a hearing, which was a possibility, saying some people don't want to have a conversation about it, "they don't want to deal with it in a transparent and accountable manner," which has led to a proposal like this being introduced on the Senate floor. 

"This is a way that we could support their businesses that would not cost taxpayer money," Kent said. "This would be just supporting their normal business activity."

She hoped that they'll have open discussions about issues like this, that matter to the people of Minnesota, in the future.

Pappas' amendment failed on a 35-31 vote. 

This isn't that surprising though seeing as the state has a long history of moving slowly when updated the state's antiquated liquor laws – remember the years-long battle to allow liquor stores to sell alcohol on Sundays?

Next Up

Yia Vang - media photo - crop 2

Union Hmong Kitchen will move into Mpls. food hall

Chef Yia Vang said they're "so excited to settle in and have a home."

ISSAboveYou - Duluth North Shore - Oct 18 2021

Watch: Mille Lacs, Duluth captured in stunning video from ISS

The space station provides a vantage point 260 miles above the Earth's surface.

2048px-The_Weeknd_with_hand_in_the_air_performing_live_in_Hong_Kong_in_November_2018

Ladies and gentlemen, The Weeknd has canceled his St. Paul show

He's made changes to his 2022 tour that involves scrapping his Xcel Energy Center gig.

Pixabay - police lights, tape

Man released from custody after admitting to fatal shooting in ND

Authorities said there is no threat to the public.

rochester-water-tower

MN water tower in the running for Tank of the Year

It was the only water tank to receive more than 5,000 votes.

first snow

Any sign of snow in the forecast for Minnesota?

The stars could align for some flurries in northern Minnesota this week, but that's about it.

Flickr - 14 year old vaccine shot - Navy Medicine

Walz announces $200 reward for kids 12-17 who get COVID shots

Those ages have the lowest vaccination rates among all eligible age groups.

Related

Pizza & Beer Wide

Lawmakers introduce bill to expand takeout for breweries, distilleries

Breweries and distilleries were not included in a recent alcohol takeout bill for bars and restaurants.

senate mask

Republicans vote down mask mandate for MN Senate floor

Instead, they want to "strongly encourage" that people wear masks.

Screen Shot 2019-09-27 at 10.40.44 PM

GOP lawmaker slams Teamsters for meme about 'free the growler' bill

The bill would remove the cap that prohibits five breweries from selling growlers and beer to go.

Pizza & Beer Wide

MN lawmakers set to vote on alcohol takeout bill for restaurants

The bill would be in effect until the end of the state's stay-at-home order.

The Senate passed a Sunday liquor sales bill

This is the closest Minnesota has come to having Sunday liquor sales. But there's still work that needs to be done before it's official

Screen Shot 2019-07-03 at 10.55.46 PM

6 Minnesota breweries form alliance, push for change in state growler cap

Several Minnesota breweries are too big to sell growlers. They're again seeking to change that.

Screen Shot 2019-07-03 at 10.55.46 PM

'Free the growler': Bill would allow all Minnesota breweries to sell growlers

Only five breweries in Minnesota are prohibited from selling growlers and beer to go because they're "too big."