Wisconsin man charged with killing 79-year-old in Menards parking lot altercation

The altercation stemmed from how the victim parked.
Publish date:
Russell Paulson

Russell Paulson

A Wisconsin man accused of fatally beating a 79-year-old man in the parking lot of Menards has been charged with first-degree reckless homicide in connection to the May 1 incident. 

Matthew L. Kinstler, 50, is accused of getting into an altercation with Russell Paulson over how he parked at around 2:19 p.m. on May 1 at the Menards at 223 Lang Drive in La Crosse, Wisconsin, according to the criminal complaint. 

Court documents state Kinstler was parked near the front of the store and when he was returning to his car, he saw Paulson nearly hit his vehicle while he was parking. Witnesses said Kinstler walked up to Paulson and accused him of dinging his vehicle and began yelling at him, while Paulson denied hitting the vehicle. 

Witnesses said Kinstler then got into Paulson's face and Paulson slapped him, the complaint says. Kinstler then took Paulson's cane and hit him, causing him to fall to the ground. 

Sign up for our BREAKING NEWS newsletters

Paulson was brought to the hospital. He suffered multiple skull fractures and bleeding around his brain, the complaint said. Investigators had a difficult time interviewing Paulson because he's hard of hearing, but when asked if he gave permission for Kinstler to hit him, he said "Hell no. Hell no."

Paulson died on May 4, the complaint says. A Go Fund Me page set up for him is raising money to place a memorial bench and plaque at his favorite birding spot. 

Kinstler said he acted in self-defense, the complaint says. If convicted, Kinstler could face up to 60 years in prison. 

Next Up

police lights

Wisconsin father suspected of killing his 6-week-old son

The father was arrested Monday in connection to the infant's Feb. 19 death.


Minnesota saw record gun permit applications in 2020

The trend in Minnesota aligns with national spikes.


St. Paul police ask for help solving 2 hit-and-run cases

A man is still hospitalized after being hit by a car in mid-February, while a woman is on a "long road to recovery" after being hit by a van in December.

duluth ship fire

Duluth fire crews battle blaze on 118-year-old lake freighter

The J.B. Ford, which is the oldest intact lake freighter still floating, has been housed at a scrapyard since 2015.


Target sales grew by $15B in 2020, more than past 11 years combined

The pandemic led to a historic year for the Minneapolis retailer.


Eagan-based Villaume Industries pays $90K fine in gender discrimination case

After the Minnesota Department of Human Rights found the company refused to hire women, Villaume committed to reforms


11 more people charged in massive magazine scam plead guilty

In total, 63 people from across the U.S. were charged in what prosecutors called the "largest elder fraud scheme in the nation."

Alex Stalock

Wild goalie Alex Stalock claimed off waivers by Oilers

The South St. Paul native will be heading to Edmonton.

Mortensen becker-finn

Shakopee GOPer posts DFL lawmaker's personal cell number on Facebook

Rep. Erik Mortensen has been accused of 'doxxing' Twin Cities lawmaker Rep. Jamie Becker-Finn.

derek chauvin

Minneapolis scraps plan to pay 'influencers' to share information during Chauvin trial

The plan to pay influencers to share city-approved messages during the trials of the officers charged in George Floyd's death drew criticism.


21-year-old man charged with running over 6 people in Mankato parking lot

The charges say the hit-and-run started as a fight over drugs.

Screen Shot 2020-07-13 at 12.48.52 PM

Charges: Man chased victim, killed him using brass knuckles with knives

The suspect is accused of using brass knuckles with knives attached to stab the victim.

Carjacking at WI Menards leads to chase into Minnesota

The suspect in the armed-vehicle theft is still at large.

Robert Lee Baker III

Charges: St. Paul man shot victim 11 times, killing him outside Eagan hotel

The 29-year-old man says the victim robbed him prior to the shooting.


Charges: Mounds View man gave Tinder date a drug that killed her

He's accused of giving the victim GHB, a date-rape drug, which killed her.

27-year-old charged in killing of innocent man while fleeing police

The incident unfolded the afternoon of Wednesday, May 1.

police lights

Wisconsin father suspected of killing his 6-week-old son

The father was arrested Monday in connection to the infant's Feb. 19 death.

Andrew Endres

MN man charged for 2014 hit-and-run that killed 2 in Wisconsin

The now-32-year-old man was arrested in Dakota County.