Skip to main content

Former Gophers QB 'did not cause' attack victim's brain injury, doctor says

  • Author:
  • Updated:

A forensic expert has said that a kick delivered by former Gophers quarterback Philip Nelson probably did not cause the brain injury suffered by college footballer Isaac Kolstad following a fight in May.

A second opinion from a doctor hired by prosecutors in the case against Nelson has said that the injury inflicted on former Minnesota State-Mankato player Kolstad, which left him in a coma for weeks, is more likely to have been caused by a punch thrown by another defendant, Trevor Shelley, FOX 9 reports.

The analysis by Dr. Michael McGee will now form a major part of a motion from the defense to get charges against Nelson reduced, the news station says.

"My overall impression of this case is that the majority and possibly all of the injuries described in Mr. Kolstad are related to the initial punch to the street surface," McGee concluded, according to the Pioneer Press.

"While Mr. Nelson may be responsible for some of the above-described injuries, based on the information provided, I am unable to state to a medical certainty that this is the case."

Kolstad was injured following a fight in downtown Mankato on May 11, which is alleged to have started when Nelson mistook him for a bouncer who had flirted with his girlfriend earlier that night, the newspaper says.

During the altercation, Kolstad was punched and fell to the ground, hitting his head, after which Nelson is alleged to have kicked him in the head.

Kolstad, now 25, in December spoke out for the first time of his recovery from the attack, which left him in a coma and has since seen him require physical and speech therapy.

Nelson and Shelley have been charged with first and third degree assault, while Nelson was kicked off the Rutgers football team, to which he had transferred from the University of Minnesota, the Star Tribune notes.

The evidence from Dr. McGee follows a report by a doctor caused as a defense expert in August, which also concluded that the punch from Shelley is likely to have caused much of the injuries, the newspaper says.

Nelson's attorney, Jim Fleming, told the Mankato Free Press Dr. McGee's report should result in charges against the quarterback being reduced as soon as possible.

Next Up

Screen Shot 2022-06-21 at 9.10.22 PM

Arizonan ID'd as man killed by falling tree at Minnesota resort

A tree came crashing down on a camper during a severe storm Monday night.

Screen Shot 2022-06-21 at 3.47.02 PM

Attempted kidnapping of toddler at Brooklyn Park McDonald's

The incident happened Tuesday afternoon inside McDonald's.

minneapolis police

Court finds Minneapolis 100+ cops short of mandatory minimum

The Minnesota Supreme Court ruled Mayor Jacob Frey failed to meet his legal duty to hire more officers or demonstrate why he hasn't done so.

Two Harbors City Council meeting on June 20, 2022.

Scrutinized mayor asked to resign by city council, again

Swanson has already said he won't resign before a recall election takes place later this summer.


Expired tabs lead to arrest of murder suspect in Hopkins

The 24-year-old has been charged with the murder of a man in Uptown.

Shan Fiorenza

Charges: Rochester football players assaulted opposing coach

The opposing coach was knocked unconscious, according to charges.


Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Tuesday, June 21

The subvariant BA.5 is expected to replace BA.2.12.1 as the dominant strain in the coming weeks.


1 dead after semi blows tire, collides with truck on I-35

A 22-year-old man was killed in the crash that happened near the Iowa-Minnesota border.

Pelican Bay in Nisswa, MN

Minnesota man dies while swimming in Pelican Lake

The 49-year-old Merrifield man was reportedly swimming from a pontoon.

Screen Shot 2022-06-21 at 9.11.58 AM

Severe storm blows down tree, killing Minnesota man in camper

The tree came crashing down from a passing storm in central Minnesota Monday night.