Making the case for the Twins to be sellers at the MLB trade deadline

After going all-in for 2020, is it time to look ahead to 2021?
Publish date:
Rocco Baldelli

The Minnesota Twins came into the 2020 season with major expectations and this past offseason, they acted like it. They shelled out the largest free-agent contract in franchise history to Josh Donaldson. They sent top prospect Brusdar Graterol to the Dodgers to get Kenta Maeda. Long story short, they went all-in.

But as Monday's MLB trade deadline approaches, the dreams of a World Series title may have gone out the window. With the Twins on a five-game losing streak, the Twins should sell at the deadline and shift their focus toward 2021.

This sounds insane considering the Twins are 1.5 games out of the lead in the American League Central and are in prime position to get a playoff spot. With the anticipated returns of Donaldson, Michael Pineda, and Byron Buxton in the coming days, you could also argue it's just like making a trade and they'll be fine. But that's only part of the story.

At the top of the list of concerns is (surprise!) the starting rotation. While Maeda has been a pleasant surprise, Jose Berrios has struggled to live up to his de facto "ace" status and as Twins Daily's Matthew Lenz pointed out, Randy Dobnak has been successful on a smoke and mirrors basis.

With fans fearing if Rich Hill will be able to make his next start and Jake Odorizzi struggling to stay off the injured list, the Twins have been in the hunt for a starting pitcher and have been connected to Dylan Bundy and Lance Lynn.

But that brings up the Twins' recent history at the trade deadline. With the front office clutching their prospects with a death grip, the odds of deciding that the cost is too rich will likely override improving the team, which in this case is the correct decision.

Think about it this way. The Twins have played 35 games this season. At that point last year, Martin Perez was 5-0 with a 2.83 ERA. From that point on, he reverted back to his old form, going 5-7 with a 5.88 ERA. 

Imagine if the Twins coughed up several prospects to land Bundy, whose current 2.47 ERA is nearly two runs lower than his career mark of 4.53. The Twins would not only have given up a ransom to win in a gimmick-laden season but also could also wind up being stuck with an average pitcher heading into 2021.

That brings up the season that the Twins are currently stuck in. The 60-game season was bad enough, but MLB has turned it into an ever-adapting mess. With seven-inning doubleheaders, runners on second during extra innings and a playoff format that would assuredly see the Yankees gleefully pick the Twins as their first-round opponent if they don't win the AL Central, is it worth betting the farm on this?

The best move may be for the Twins to follow what their nemesis, the Yankees, did back in 2016. As the Bombers were fading from the playoff picture, they sent Aroldis Chapman to the Cubs in exchange for a haul of prospects that included Gleyber Torres and fueled their current run as the team to beat in the American League.

While the Twins don't have a highly coveted piece such as Chapman, they could dangle Eddie Rosario or even Nelson Cruz to pave the way for an even bigger move to load up for 2021 when there aren't as many gimmicks.

By looking toward the future, the Twins could also play some of their prospects including Alex Kirilloff, Jhoan Duran, and others to get some major league experience under their belt prior to next season.

This seems harsh and a complete knee-jerk decision after the Twins' first five-game losing streak in two years, but it feels like going all-in for this season just isn't worth it for where this team needs to be.

Next Up

Tim Walz

Walz to hold press conference on MN State Capitol safety concerns

This comes amid ongoing threats to state Capitols across the country.

Screen Shot 2020-08-14 at 6.45.53 PM

Brooklyn Park standoff: Suspect kills himself, child taken hostage is safe

The standoff ended Thursday night when the suspect shot himself.

police tape, crime scene

Man dies in alley after report of shooting in Minneapolis

Police were sent to the scene by ShotSpotter activation.


COVID-19 shines a light on the struggles facing Minnesota's working mothers

Daycare and school closures have put working families under pressure, with mothers bearing the brunt.

Prada Purse2

Border patrol in Minneapolis intercepts shipment of 173 counterfeit designer bags

If they were authentic, they would have been worth about $405,975.

Minneapolis City Hall

Minneapolis councilors propose replacing police department, rent stabilization

Council members are also proposing two charter amendments to help renters in Minneapolis.

Vaccine COVID

MDH expands COVID guidance, urges providers to vaccinate the 65+

More vaccine guidance will be provided in the coming days.

Tom Brady

Coller: Which remaining teams should the Vikings emulate?

Matthew Coller writes a weekly Vikings column for BMTN, with more of his work found at Purple Insider.

Screen Shot 2019-04-16 at 3.33.57 PM

Serious crime was up 15% in St. Paul in 2020

“This was an incredibly hard year for all of us,” Police Chief Todd Axtell said, citing riots and the pandemic.


Here is Minnesota's COVID update for January 14

Hospitalizations are the lowest in Minnesota since October 26.


Nelson Cruz

5 Twins storylines to watch this offseason

2020's disappointment could lead to a new look in 2021.

Jose Berrios

Twins win fifth straight by routing Pirates

The Twins jumped on Pittsburgh early in a 7-3 victory on Tuesday.

Rocco Baldelli

It's time for the Twins to make a splash in the American League

The Twins are part of baseball's problem in avoiding the hot stove.

Devin Smeltzer

Who steps up if Twins don't make a move to improve rotation?

The Twins have some depth, but they should really add a pitcher.

Nelson Cruz

Cruz homers twice; Twins get swept in doubleheader with Tigers

The Twins fell further back in the AL Central standings on Saturday.

Nelson Cruz

Twins split doubleheader with Cardinals

Twins split doubleheader with Cardinals

Willians Astudillo, Nelson Cruz

Nelson Cruz blasts two bombs as Twins split doubleheader

The Twins took Game 1, but the Royals bounced back in the nightcap.

Trevor May

Twins' bullpen steps up to take series from Cleveland

After Homer Bailey was placed on the IL, the Twins bullpen led the way on Sunday.