Skip to main content

NFLPA: Goodell lacks authority to force Peterson into counseling

  • Author:
  • Updated:

The NFL Players Association is disputing a portion of the punishment commissioner Roger Goodell imposed on Vikings running back Adrian Peterson, when he suspended Peterson for the remainder of the 2014 season.

As part of the suspension of Peterson following his no contest plea to a misdemeanor assault charge, Goodell set conditions for Peterson's reinstatement – including meeting with a league-assigned psychiatrist to design a counseling and therapy program.

But according to ESPN, a brief filed on behalf of Peterson by the players' union argues Goodell lacks the power to attach such terms to Peterson's suspension. The union argues that under the Collective Bargaining Agreement, the commissioner is only allowed to fine, suspend or terminate the contracts of players and therefore lacks the power to administer additional forms of discipline.

"The collectively-bargained NFL Player Contract could not be clearer in expressly limiting the Commissioner's disciplinary authority 'to fine Players(s) in a reasonable amount, to suspend Player(s) for a certain period or indefinitely; and/or terminate th(eir) contracts (s). The NFL does not deny that the Commissioner's imposed counseling requirement is neither a fine, suspension, or contract termination, nor would there be any other 'plausible' interpretation of this CBA provision permitting such a requirement."

"Instead, the NFL – like the [suspension] itself – entirely ignores the Player Contract's CBA disciplinary limitation. As the NFL highlights, Arbitrator [Harold] Henderson sustained the counseling requirement of Mr. Peterson's discipline not on the basis of any provision in the CBA, but by relying upon Commissioner Goodell's unilaterally promulgated Personal Conduct Policies."

A hearing on the union's lawsuit on behalf of Peterson is expected to go before U.S. District Judge David Doty in Minneapolis on Feb. 6.

That issue could play a key part in determining how quickly Peterson can return to the NFL.

CBS Sports points out that Goodell's letter announcing Peterson's punishment hints that the suspension is open-ended, since April 15 is actually the earliest date that Goodell will review Peterson's progress.

"At that time, I will meet with you and your representatives and the NFLPA to review the extend to which you have complied with your program of counseling and therapy and both made and lived up to an affirmative commitment to change such that this conduct will not occur again. A failure to cooperate and follow your plan will result in a lengthier suspension without pay."

If Peterson's suspension appears that it may extend beyond April 15, it could make things tough for the Vikings – or any team – to plan their future around the nearly 30-year-old running back.

Next Up

police lights

Man arrested after abduction attempt in Bemidji

The incident occurred in Cameron Park on June 25.

betty danger's

Betty Danger's in NE Minneapolis for sale for $4.2 million

The asking price includes the restaurant's ferris wheel, as well as a nearby single-family home.


Minnesota health officials warn monkeypox cases could grow rapidly

The state has so far confirmed only six cases of monkeypox virus.


Bodies of woman, three young children recovered from Vadnais Lake

Authorities say the bodies recovered were those of two boys, one girl and their mother.

Pixabay laptop keyboard phone dark

Charges: Duluth man had hundreds of child porn images, videos

The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children found nearly 330 images on the man's electronic devices.

hennepin county sheriff water patrol lake minnetonka

Scuba diver found dead in Lake Minnetonka identified as 20-year-old

The Hennepin County Medical Examiner's Office said 20-year-old Brady Alan Aune, from Elko New Market, died of freshwater drowning on June 3.

Screen Shot 2022-06-30 at 11.18.35 AM

Felony charges filed after authorities search 'Peacebunny Cottage'

The president of the rabbit rescue non-profit faces multiple animal cruelty charges after over 40 rabbits were found dead inside the organization's barn.

monkeypox virus

Minnesota up to 6 confirmed cases of monkeypox virus

Most people recover at home within 2-4 weeks.

thc edibles

Did Minnesota just accidentally legalize THC?

A Republican lawmaker who voted to approve the new law in May is already talking about rolling it back.

Screen Shot 2022-06-30 at 3.19.42 PM

Gasoline may be cause of sewer explosion on U of M campus

An all-clear was given around 9 p.m. Thursday, with residents in the area allowed to return to their homes.


Overwhelming demand for THC products on first day of new law in MN

One shop owner said his Chaska store broke the online sales record before they opened Friday morning.