Skip to main content

Report: Twins pitcher Ervin Santana takes loss in jewelry lawsuit

  • Author:
  • Updated:

Twins pitcher Ervin Santana has reportedly paid a Florida jeweler, who claimed the right-hander defaulted on a September 2014 purchase.

Major League Jewelers Inc. sued Santana in Miami for civil theft and defamation after he allegedly refused to finish paying for customized gems he claimed were phony.

The story was first reported last spring – around the same time Santana was suspended by Major League Baseball for 80 games for violating the league's policy on performance-enhancing drugs.

According to court records, Santana made the initial $2,150 payment on his jewelry purchase, but he refused to pay the balance because he claimed the jeweler failed to satisfy his specifications for the necklaces, bracelets, pendants and earnings.

The Pioneer Press reports Santana compensated a Florida jeweler $58,000 for the gems valued at just over $42,000.

"To prove the jewels were fake, Santana hired a gemologist to examine them, a tactic that backfired. The appraiser determined the jewels were not only legitimate but actually worth $2,760 more than the pitcher agreed to pay, court records show."

While Santana's settlement will cover the value of the jewels, plus additional fees and attorney's fees, the newspaper notes that Major League Jewelers will continue with its defamation claim.

Santana has since returned from his suspension. According to 1500 ESPN, the court proceedings shouldn't affect him on the field. He'll start on Friday night in Oakland when the Twins return from the All Star break.

Next Up

Screen Shot 2022-05-24 at 5.21.04 PM

Ex-South St. Paul coach dies by suicide 2 days before sentencing

Matthew McCollister was to be sentenced for fraud in federal court on Wednesday.


Minnesota 'glampground' named one of 10 best in U.S.

In Nevis, Minnesota, campers can stay in a refurbished 1905 train car.

Screen Shot 2022-01-28 at 9.04.12 AM

Two men charged over terrifying armed robbery at Newport apartment

They shot the woman who lives in the apartment in the abdomen, and put a gun to a man's head.

Minneapolis police

Minneapolis 2-year-old identified in suspicious death case

The cause of death has not yet been revealed due to an ongoing investigation.

Arianna Vos

Victim of wrong-way driver crash ID'd as Hutchinson 19-year-old

Three women, ages 19, 20 and 20, were in the vehicle struck by a wrong-way driver early Sunday morning.

Julissa Thaler

Eli Hart killing: Police investigating multiple crime scenes

An announcement Tuesday confirmed potential crime scenes in Mound and Minnetrista.

SEIU Healthcare Minnesota strike.

Twin Cities mental health workers gather for 1-day strike

More than 400 mental health workers are participating in the unionized strike on Tuesday.

Bloomington Fire

HAZMAT team at Bloomington hotel following chemical spill in pool

The fire department said two hotel employees are being evaluated by paramedics.

Screen Shot 2022-03-24 at 9.21.32 AM

Big Brothers Big Sisters Twin Cities gets $6M of Mackenzie Scott donation

The donation is the largest the organization has ever seen from a single individual.

Hennepin Avenue S.

Minneapolis accused of backtracking on 24/7 bus lanes for Hennepin Ave.

The Minneapolis City Council is set to vote on Thursday.

Pexels - face mask covid holding

Duluth brings back masking in city buildings amid COVID surge

Duluth, in one of the state's current COVID hotspots, has brought back a mask requirement in city buildings.