Publish date:

Should the Twins offer top prospects for Mets pitcher Noah Syndergaard?

The price would be high, but one ESPN writer argues Minnesota should do it.

We've gone down the Noah Syndergaard before, but it's even more relevant now that an ESPN baseball writer thinks the Twins would be wise to do whatever they can to get the Mets right-hander. 

Syndergaard, better known as Thor to many baseball fans, is a flame-throwing starting pitcher who would almost immediately give the Twins one of the best 1-2 punches in the big leagues when paired with All-Star Jose Berrios. 

No disrespect to Jake Odorizzi, who was also an All-Star, but Syndegaard's track record is a bit better, and ESPN's David Schoenfield thinks Minnesota should offer New York top prospects to get him before the July 31 trade deadline. 

"Derek Falvey and Thad Levine have focused on small, cost-efficient moves during their tenure running the Twins. Now it's time to think big. If the Mets make Syndergaard available, he's a great fit for Minnesota -- for 2019 and beyond, since starters Jake Odorizzi, Kyle Gibson and Michael Pineda are all free agents at season's end. They'd probably have to part with top prospect Royce Lewis or outfielder Alex Kirilloff and a pitcher like Brusdar Graterol or Jordan Balazovic, but Syndergaard could be a beast away from the circus in Queens. Plus, as they say, flags fly forever."

Syndergaard vitals:

  • Age: 26
  • Height: 6'6''
  • Weight: 240
  • Record: 7-4
  • ERA: 4.55
  • WHIP: 1.24
  • Innings: 112.2
  • Strikeouts: 110
  • Walks: 30

Nothing pops off the page with those numbers, but we are in the new juiced ball era and he's pitching with one of the worst defenses in baseball behind him. It's damn near a guarantee that his ERA and WHIP would be lower with the Twins' defense behind him. 

Plus, he's throws big-time heat. Syndergaard's fastball averages 98.2 mph while his sinker is just as hard at 98.0 mph. Then he mixes in a changeup (91.3 mph), slider (89.1 mph) and a big curveball that comes in at an average of 80.3 mph. 

Is he actually available? According to the New York Post, Mets GM Brodie Van Wagenen recently said that he expects Syndegaard to remain a Met this season. It makes sense because they'd be selling low on a dominating pitcher who is young and under team control through 2021. 

But it's that team control that is likely attractive to the Twins and any other team interested in Syndegaard. And that team control drives up the price, possibly to the level of a Royce Lewis or Alex Kirilloff, the top two prospects in Minnesota's deep farm system, plus other prospects. 

Minnesota could definitely use another high-end starter for the playoffs, but it's arguably more pressing that they add a high-end right-handed reliever to the back of the bullpen to pair with Taylor Rogers. 

The MLB trade deadline strikes the afternoon of July 31. 

Next Up

Dalvin Cook

Vikings: Dalvin Cook is OUT of Seahawks game

The star running back hasn't recovered from an ankle injury.


Boy arrested after making threats towards school in Anoka

An image shared on Snapchat warned of the "best school shooting yet."

Ambulance hospital emergency

Four killed in crashes after deadly start to weekend on MN roads

The latest figures show there have been 349 road deaths in Minnesota this year.


In crackdown on unruly passengers, Delta urges other airlines to share no-fly lists

The airline says it's a bid to "further protect airline employees across the industry."

Screen Shot 2020-06-15 at 7.11.05 AM

St. Cloud State student-athlete suspended from team following alleged assault

The incident reportedly took place off campus on Sep. 18.

Gopher Football

U of M-barrassed: Gophers shocked by Bowling Green

The Falcons snapped a 21-game non-conference winning streak in front of a homecoming crowd.

Andrew Wiggins

Andrew Wiggins applies for exemption to COVID vaccine, is rejected

Wiggins could miss a large chunk of the season without the vaccine.

CJ Ham

Vikings-Seahawks: 5 things you can count on happening

Can the Vikings finally beat Russell Wilson?

Flickr - police lights squad siren - Edward Kimmel

Residents asked to be on the lookout for at-large suspect in Sauk Rapids

The suspect was last seen near the intersection of Garden Brook Drive Northeast and Strawberry Court Northeast.


Noah Syndergaard

Report: Mets want top Twins prospects for Noah Syndergaard

The report says the Mets want Royce Lewis and Alex Kirilloff.


Why the Twins should target Syndergaard or deGrom

Either ace would improve the rotation dramatically.

Byron Buxton

Mets reportedly wanted Buxton in trade talks for Syndergaard

The MLB trade deadline hits at 3 p.m. Wednesday.

Noah Syndergaard

Twins about to face 2 of MLB's best in deGrom, Syndergaard

The duo can be as dominant as any in the big leagues.

Noah Syndergaard

Noah Syndergaard trolls clueless Cleveland Indians tweet

It's funny when a fringe playoff team calls an opponent a fringe playoff team.


Report: Twins scouts watching Bumgarner and Syndergaard

Both pitchers squared off against one another on Thursday.

Alex Kirilloff

Twins Daily: Comparing Twins' top prospects to MLB stars

What time does the World Series parade start?