Skip to main content

The 3 reasons why the Twins lost to the Yankees in the Wild Card Game

Here's why the Twins bowed out from the playoffs.
  • Author:
  • Updated:

The Twins had every opportunity to defeat the New York Yankees in the American League Wild Card Game on Tuesday evening. 

When Minnesota jumped out to a 3-0 lead in the top of the first, they had a 74 percent chance to win the game, according to Baseball Reference's expected winning percentage

However, the Twins couldn't hold on and the following events doomed them in their loss to the Bronx Bombers.

1. Disappointing pitching

Ervin Santana had a three-run lead to work with. He was Minnesota's ace this season, but although he was the best pitcher on the staff, Santana's performance was furthest thing from what baseball would call an "ace."

He couldn't find the strike zone and he eventually grooved one to Didi Gregorius for a three-run bomb in the first inning. He chalked up another blast to Brett Gardner in the second and was pulled from the game by the time the frame was over.

However it didn't matter who was the mound, Jose Berrios and Trevor Hildenberger didn't fare better either, each of them surrendering runs. 

They were arguably Minnesota's three best pitchers all season and when the team needed them the most, they didn't come through

Meanwhile, the Yankees pitchers were throwing darts.

2. Castro didn't come through

Jason Castro was signed during the offseason as a defensive-minded catcher and he lived up to that during the regular season.

Inheriting nearly the same pitching staff from a 103-loss campaign, Castro's pitch framing abilities paid dividends. Plus, his defensive runs saved ranked fifth among catchers this season.

But right before Gregorius' home run, Castro uncharacteristically did a poor job framing what would have been strike three, according to ESPN's K Zone.

His offense has never been anything to write home about, but he struck out twice when his team needed a clutch hit. 

He was punched out with the bases loaded in the second inning and was also fanned in sixth when Buxton was in scoring position. If Castro comes through, we're possibly talking about a different outcome.

3. Losing Buxton 

Byron Buxton wowed us with his defense in the second inning, securing an unbelievable catch, slamming against the center field wall.

Related: Watch: Byron Buxton's insane catch in the American League Wild Card Game.

Unfortunately, Buxton tweaked his back, which forced him from the game and Minnesota replaced him with rookie Zack Granite.

Granite appeared in just 40 games but was tasked with replacing the best defensive center fielder in the game.

He fared decently in the field, but he had an embarrassing miscue during the eighth inning when he completely missed the first base bag after a poor throw and was still tagged out.

Yes it was late in the game and the Twins were down four runs, but it was the icing on the cake in the loss.

Everything is going to be hyper-analyzed in a winner-take-all playoff game.

But this game does not define the Twins' 2017 season in which they bounced back from a 103-loss campaign the year before.

The players – many of them playing in their first playoff game – can take this loss and learn from it. While the front office will be tasked with making them a better team during the offseason.

Next Up


Animal Humane Society plans trailblazing new campus

Take a look inside the plans for a first-of-its-kind adoption center and animal care campus.


Minnesota reports 'concerning level' of syphilis cases

The Minnesota Department of Health says most of the cases are being discovered in the northern part of the state.

Flickr - police lights squad siren - Edward Kimmel

Airport police intercept 5,600 fentanyl pills headed to St. Cloud

Three were arrested following a police raid in St. Cloud.


Minnesota switches to weekly COVID updates

The weekly updates will be provided on Thursdays.

Screen Shot 2022-06-29 at 12.22.08 PM

Man shot inside Oakdale movie theater expected to survive

The 23-year-old victim underwent surgery and is recovering at the hospital.


Minnesota confirms second case of monkeypox virus

More cases are expected in the coming days and weeks, the health department says.


Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Wednesday, June 29

One of the newly reported deaths was a person aged 15-19 from Yellow Medicine County.

Screen Shot 2022-06-29 at 10.19.37 AM

Drone drops bag of candy near kids fishing

A black SUV quickly left the area afterwards.

FLickr - AL Franken 2016 - Lorie Shaull

Al Franken to bring comedy tour to Minneapolis

Acme Comedy is hosting the former senator in late August.


Alabama replaces Toby Keith as headliner at MN music festival

The Lakefront Music Festival is set to take place in Prior Lake on July 8-9.


Here's the Twins lineup for the American League Wild Card Game

First pitch between the Twins and Yankees is at 7:09 p.m.

Screen Shot 2019-05-04 at 2.25.15 PM

Twins pull off a rare win against the Yankees

Saturday's win snaps an eight-game losing streak at Yankee Stadium.