The Yankees see failure in their season, and so should the Twins

What's been dubbed a "great season" in Minnesota would be a total failure in New York.
Publish date:
Rocco Baldelli

There are no participation ribbons in professional sports. Just winners and losers. 

After being swept by the Yankees in the American League Divisional Series, the Twins packed up the clubhouse at Target Field and entered the offseason as one of what will eventually be 31 losing teams. 

Same goes for the Yankees, who were walked off by Jose Altuve's ninth-inning homer in Game 6 of the American League Championship Series against the Astros on Saturday. 

This is where the different mindsets of the Twins and Yankees becomes evident: What's great for the Twins is a failure for the Yankees. 

"It's a failure," Judge said Saturday night, via ESPN. "In spring training, we talked about winning the division and putting ourselves in a good spot in the postseason to win a World Series. We came up short. No matter how many games we won in the regular season or what else we did, this season is a failure."

Asked a similar question after the Yankees sent the Twins to their 14th, 15th and 16th consecutive playoff losses, Twins manager Rocco Baldelli took Judge's glass half-empty and called it half-full. 

“It was a great year,” Baldelli said, via the Twins. “I got to be a part of something that I consider very special, and I think we have a very unique, special group of people. We got a chance to watch some players reach new heights in their careers. We got a chance to go out there. We won 101 games. It was a group that meshed and came together exceptionally well.”

Good enough exists in Minnesota. It's all-or-nothing in New York. 

Celebrating history is fine. Just ask the 1998 Minnesota Vikings, who provided one of the most memorable seasons in Minnesota sports history. Everyone remembers the exciting offense led by Randy Moss and Cris Carter making highlight-reel catches, but none of that overshadows the pain of taking a knee and then Gary Anderson missing wide left. 

But hey, all those memories are good enough in Minnesota. 

The same goes for the numerous home run records the Twins set this season. Great memories that you'll find in Minnesota's very full filing cabinet of loser seasons. 

Imagine how excited the Twins and fans alike would be if the Twins took the Astros to Game 6 of the ALCS. The loss would be devastating, but the chance would've been good enough. 

Because, you know, Minnesota's glass if half-full. 

Imagine what Judge would say if he played for a Twins team that got swept and hasn't won a playoff game since 2004. "Failure" would be preceded by another F-word. 

103 victories, a division title, a postseason series victory and 306 homers – just one fewer than the Twins – garnered a "tough, tough year" response from veteran Yankees outfielder Brett Gardner. 

In Minnesota: "It was definitely fun,” said Nelson Cruz. 

You know what would be a lot more fun? Winning a World Series. 

The Yankees haven't won a World Series in a decade (2009 their last) and it's panic mode. The Twins haven't won a playoff game in 15 years and everything is fine. 

Remember the 2001 Seattle Mariners? They won an MLB record 116 games but got bounced in the ALCS by the team that's always looking for more: The Yankees. 

The Mariners haven't been to the playoffs since, but hey, all those memories... 

Next Up

milk bar cake crop

Famous Milk Bar bakery hosts pop-up in Twin Cities

The virtual event only lasts for a few days, with limited quantities available.

Flickr - police barricades dismantle uptown - Chad Davis

MN National Guard soldiers 'standing by' to respond in Minneapolis

Mayor Jacob Frey asked Gov. Tim Walz for National Guard support Wednesday.

tom burke

Charges: Wisconsin star, former NFL player sexually assaulted a child

The child told her mother about the assaults in February, charges say.

Screen Shot 2021-06-14 at 8.45.06 AM

Charges: Drunk driver accelerated 'to jump barricade' in crash that killed protester

Prosecutors say it was "an extreme and violent intentional act."

Screen Shot 2021-06-16 at 9.29.50 AM

Through little fault of its own, Minnesota BBQ joint goes viral

A picture of its ribs was enough to attract the attention of the culinary world.

Flickr - COVID vaccine Joint Base San Antonio

More than 3 million Minnesotans have had at least 1 vaccine dose

The milestone comes almost 6 months to the day since the first vaccine was given in the state.


Didi Gregorius

Yankees hammer Twins into 0-2 series hole

New York has backed Minnesota into an all too familiar corner.

Rocco Baldelli

Baldelli not convinced of intimidation factor at Yankee Stadium

The Yankees have knocked the Twins out of the playoff 5 times since 2004.

Miguel Sano

Better playoff matchup for Twins: Astros or Yankees?

Barring a collapse in the Central Division, the Twins are headed to New York or Houston.

Rocco Baldelli

Why the Twins shouldn't fear the Yankees

The Twins have a terrifying postseason past with the Yankees, but this time around there is nothing to fear in the ALDS.

Giancarlo Stanton

Attacking the heart of the Yankees' order: Part 1

Twins Daily breaks down the big bats in New York's batting order.

Willians Astudillo

Twins' magic number at 2, matchup with Yankees looking likely

Houston has a 1.5-game lead over New York for the AL's best record.

Nelson Cruz

Vegas odds favor Yankees, Astros over Twins in AL

Minnesota leads the AL with 50 wins, but bettors are buying it.