Twins retaliate against White Sox over unwritten rule; Baldelli denies it

Baldelli claims Tyler Duffey was simply trying to throw a pitch inside.
Publish date:
Screen Shot 2021-05-19 at 7.38.26 AM

Baseball's unwritten rules have brewed up some bad blood between the first placed White Sox and last placed Twins. 

The drama began in the ninth inning of Chicago's 16-4 win over the Twins Monday night when utility man Willians Astudillo entered the game as a pitcher and lobbed a 47 mph pitch that White Sox rookie Yermin Mercedes slugged to the moon for a mammoth home run. 

Mercedes swung away on a 3-0 pitch with his team up 11 runs, which is a no-no in the unwritten baseball rulebook. White Sox manager Tony La Russa called Mercedes "clueless" about the "big mistake." 

But the outdated reaction from the 76-year-old manager has been met with rejection from White Sox players, though the Twins apparently agreed that swinging at the 3-0 pitch while up big was against the rules.

That's because Tyler Duffey threw a fastball behind Mercedes on Tuesday night while the Sox were up 4-2 in the seventh inning.

Duffey was immediately ejected, as was manager Rocco Baldelli, who came out of the dugout to argue the ejection. 

"I don't have a problem with how the Twins handled it," La Russa said after the game.

Baldelli claimed Duffey wasn't trying to throw at Mercedes. 

"We were going out there to pitch him in," Baldelli said. "That’s going to be part of what we do with him ... that being said, again, we have to live with that. We have to live with the umpires’ decision. There was no issue after that pitch. It’s not like we were going out there and trying to hit him or trying to do that again, in any way."

To recap:

  • Twins use a non-pitcher to pitch to an MLB hitter
  • MLB hitter launches a massive homer off the non-pitcher
  • Twins don't like that their non-pitcher got embarrassed
  • Twins pitcher throws at the guy who did his job
  • White Sox manager has no problem with that
  • Twins claim they weren't retaliating

Trevor Bauer, the reigning Cy Young winner who has publicly lobbied for baseball to get with the times, tweeted that anyone who has a problem with a batter swinging at at a 3-0 pitch should "get out of the game." 

We'll see if any tension boils over into Wednesday afternoon's series finale at Target Field. Pending the rain the forecast, the game is scheduled to start at 12:10 p.m. 

Next Up

Seimone Augustus

Lynx to retire jerseys of Seimone Augustus, Rebekkah Brunson next season

The former Lynx stars were a key piece of their four WNBA titles.

police tape, crime scene

Rushford police officer fires gun during report of a restraining order violation

The incident occurred on Highway 30 near the Rushford Municipal Airport.

lake water

18-year-old dies from drowning in Quarry Park

The incident is one of several drownings to occur in Minnesota in recent weeks.

Screen Shot 2021-06-13 at 8.28.44 AM

College pitcher from MN gets new prosthetic arm after his was stolen

A tough luck story turned out very positive for the Hawley native.

vaccine, covid

MN saw decline in routine child vaccinations amid pandemic

The CDC study looked at Minnesota and nine other states.


Child hospitalized after drowning in Ham Like

Their current condition is not known.


Man dies after falling from pontoon, being swept under boat

Friends believe he struck the motor while under the boat.


Man drowns in St. Croix River at William O'Brien State Park

It's not clear what caused the 46-year-old to go under.


Man, 66, dies after his ATV was hit by a minivan on highway

It happened in Renville County Friday evening.


Screen Shot 2021-05-19 at 7.38.26 AM

Twins' Duffey, Baldelli suspended for unwritten rule incident

MLB clearly didn't buy Baldelli's claim that it was unintentional.

Willians Astudillo

Twins broadcasters upset with White Sox over unwritten rule

Yermin Mercedes' ninth-inning bomb drew criticism on Monday night.

Jonathan Schoop

Twins tie another MLB record in win over White Sox

Jonathan Schoop homered twice and Mitch Garver also went deep.

Rocco Baldelli named new manager of the Twins

Baldelli is 37 years old and this will be his first time as a manager.

Jose Berrios

Twins slug trio of homers to sweep White Sox in Chicago

The Twins still lead the division by 3.5 games.

Baldelli unveils possible Opening Day batting order

Max Kepler is leading off in Baldelli's lineup.

Baldelli believes giving players freedom brings out their best

One of the first people Rocco Baldelli called was Joe Mauer.