What is and isn't a penalty? Vikings worried new rules will come with huge costs

They think the new rules could change outcomes of games, or worse.
Publish date:

Two new safety measures in the NFL have coaches and players around the league worried they will determine wins and losses, in addition to costing some people their jobs. 

The rule changes are simple to explain, but very difficult for the players to follow. 

One new rule doesn't allow players to lead with their helmets when making a tackle or a block. The other rule makes it illegal to drive a player to the ground with full body weight behind the hit. 

Two outstanding examples of the rules occurred during the Vikings-Jaguars preseason game on Saturday. The first was a call against Jaguars safety A.J. Bouye for leading with his helmet when tackling fullback C.J. Ham, although the replay clearly shows Bouye getting trucked by Ham. 

Even though the penalty turned a 2nd-and-21 into a first down for the Vikings, Zimmer sent the replay to the league office to find out why it was a called. 

"The guy is tackling him around his legs, and he had his head to the side for the most part," Zimmer said Monday, via Vikings.com. "I actually sent that in, to ask them, 'Why was this called?'"

It was one of many plays Zimmer had questions about. One that he agreed with, however, was the roughing the passer penalty on linebacker Antwione Williams.

Zimmer was angry at first, but after watching it back on video he agreed that Williams used his body weight to slam the quarterback to the ground. 

Regardless, the lack of clarity about what a penalty is has safety Harrison Smith convinced that the new rules will determine wins and losses.

“It is going to happen. Without a doubt, that is going to happen,” Smith said Monday. “If you get a big sack, that changes field position, that changes, maybe getting a guy out of field goal range, get them on third-and-long or something like that, or get off the field on third down. Then it’s a whole new set of downs. It is going to change games.”

Follow Bring Me The Sports on Facebook.

Defensive tackle Linval Joseph agrees. 

"A big play at a critical time of a game can cost a game," Joseph said. "A sack that is miscalled or overcalled and give up that sack and give them a first down, it could be a critical play of a game – and any team can lose a game with that."

There's a growing fear that the rules will lead to even bigger costs.

"Yeah, it’s going to cost some people some jobs," Zimmer said. "Playoffs, jobs, the whole bit, I’m guessing."

Zimmer noted that officials tend to call penalties on new rules extensively in the preseason before backing off a bit during the regular season, but he's not sure that'll be the case this season.

"No one has ever said to me, 'Hey, don’t worry, we’re going to call less,' or 'We’re going to straighten out in the regular season,' or 'We’re going to come up with a revised rule.' No one has ever said that." 

Next Up

soda pop

MDH finds 'troubling' trend in how many sugary drinks students are consuming

Nearly half of students have a sugary drink a day. Health officials recommend limiting it to one per week or fewer.

Rent, mortgage, house, key, door

Minnesotans have till Dec. 7 to apply for housing assistance

Gov. Tim Walz and Lt. Gov. Penny Flanagan issued a press release urging Minnesotans behind on bills to apply


Dec. 4 COVID-19 update: 61 deaths, hospitalizations drop day-over-day

The update includes new data on cases, deaths, positivity rates and hospitalizations.

Kevin Nokels

Mystery over Duluth hospital CEO's sudden departure

Kevin Nokels stepped down this week, after less than 18 months in the role.

lola missing dog

1 dog still missing after woman's vehicle was stolen in Minneapolis

The woman was dropping her daughter off at daycare when someone stole her car with her two dogs inside.

Zachary Robinson

St. Paul man pleads guilty to murder of woman pregnant with his child

The 27-year-old will spend the next five decades in prison.

fire, firefighter

Fire at southern Minnesota farm kills 2,000 pigs

The fire started around 8 a.m. Thursday.

Minnesota Sex Offender Program Moose Lake

Man at Moose Lake sex offender facility dies from COVID-19

It's the first COVID-related death of anyone in Minnesota's sex offender program.

Chris Hovan

Charges: Ex-Viking Chris Hovan drove drunk with child in the vehicle

His blood-alcohol concentration was more than three times the legal limit, charges say.

Gov. Tim Walz

Gov. Tim Walz to address Minnesotans about COVID-19 on Friday

The number of COVID-19 cases at long-term care facilities have been increasing after outbreaks at the facilities slowed 'significantly' over the summer.