Skip to main content

Why signing Josh Donaldson would salvage the Twins' offseason

He's not a pitcher, but he would help improve the Twins.

Throughout the early stages of the offseason, Minnesota Twins fans have been obsessed with acquiring pitching. In fact, who could blame them? After getting the most out of Kyle Gibson and Martin Perez in the opening months of 2019, the rotation fell apart as the season went along and ended with a thud against the New York Yankees in the ALDS.

Even the Twins front office declared their pursuit of "impact pitching" to be a priority, but it seems like even the second and third tier of starting pitchers on the market have no interest in coming to Minnesota. This has put everyone in a full-blown panic, but there is one option that can help salvage hopes for the 2020 season.

Sign Josh Donaldson.

No, Donaldson is not in the process of transitioning from third base to starting pitcher. He is, however, one of the top infielders on the market and with the Twins moving on from first baseman C.J. Cron, there is a gaping hole in the infield needing to be filled.

As the Twins have reportedly offered the 34-year-old a four-year contract, it's easy for Minnesota fans to wonder: "What the heck are they doing?" But getting Donaldson's signature on the dotted line could have a similar impact to what Nelson Cruz brought to the Twins a year ago.

An offensive powerhouse

The Twins' pursuit of starting pitching was pushed to the forefront with a miserable performance against the Yankees, but do you know what else faltered in the postseason? The Twins bats.

In true Minnesota sports fashion, a team that hit an MLB record 307 home runs during the regular season couldn't find a way to put a rally together against New York. In fact, the Twins struck out 36 times in the three-game series. That's 44% of their recorded outs in the three games.

Add in that the Twins lost C.J. Cron and his 25 home runs last season to a nagging thumb injury, and a Twins offense that couldn't cut it in the spotlight took a bigger blow than most people realize.

This is where Donaldson would come in. By adding Donaldson, the Twins would actually become more potent on offense. Throwing out his injury-marred 2018 season, Donaldson has averaged 37 home runs over his past four healthy seasons and has an OPS over .900 in all four of those campaigns. This means that Donaldson not only can hit the ball a mile but also draw a walk if needed.

While it's likely the baseballs won't be as reactive in 2020 as they were in 2019 – like the super ball you bought for your kid at the arcade last week – Donaldson is another professional hitter to add to the lineup, which was already good to begin with.

Improving the defense in the infield

You may also say that the Twins already have a pretty good third baseman in Miguel Sano. Offensively, it's hard to argue with that point. The 26-year-old crushed a career-high 34 home runs even after missing the first two months of the season, making an already potent lineup into a full-blown Bomba Squad.

The part that wasn't so appealing about Sano at third base was his defense. Although he has been an average defender over the past couple of seasons according to his UZR (fancy stat to suggest how good a player is defensively), the wheels came off last season with Sano posting a UZR of -6.7. FanGraphs extrapolated this number to costing the Twins 19.9 runs over 150 games, which means the Twins are having the right train of thought if they're looking to move Sano off the hot corner.

Even if you go by more traditional numbers, Sano was tied for second in the MLB with 17 errors at third base. Again, Sano only played 91 games (86 starts), which is another reason to sound the alarm.

Not only is Donaldson a machine with his bat, but he would also represent an instant upgrade for the Twins at third base. While his UZR isn't off the charts, saving 2.4 runs per game at third base (per FanGraphs) would help whoever is on the mound for the Twins and help fans not worry about being pelted with an errant throw.

There's also the matter of his age, which has scared some people off when thinking about adding Donaldson. Truth is that Donaldson only had one injury-plagued season in 2018 and rebounded to play 155 games for the Atlanta Braves last season, who do not have the benefit of the designated hitter spot playing in the National League.

The Twins would actually be doing something

The pitching staff still needs to be upgraded before the Twins report to spring training, but this would at least signal a start. Donaldson is 34 but the Twins also forked out $14 million to then 38-year old Nelson Cruz last offseason and that worked out wonderfully. 

With Donaldson, you know what you're getting. The combination of upgrading the offense and defense with one signing would be appealing and moving Sano to first base seems like something that was eventually going to happen anyway. If the Twins can get him to come to Minnesota, it will at least be a step in the right direction heading into 2020.

Next Up

Anthony Edwards

Ant ejected, Wolves blow huge lead and lose to slumping Hawks

The Timberwolves missed another opportunity to get over .500.

Xcel Energy Center

NHL announces make-up dates for Wild postponements

The Wild will play 40 games in the final 77 days of the regular season.

the mayo clinic - edit

Group says Mayo should be 'severely punished' over research puppy's death

The puppy died two days after undergoing a procedure at a Mayo research facility.

FLickr - minneapolis police - Tony Webster - Feb 2020 - crop

Charges: Man kidnapped woman, sexually assaulted her at gunpoint

The suspect faces three separate felony charges.

mn state capitol january 17 2021

St. Cloud 'Boogaloo Boi' who discussed attack on MN Capitol gets 2 years

He was charged with illegally possessing a machine gun.

Chris Smith

Gophers add All-Ivy League D-tackle from Harvard

Chris Smith will be eligible immediately as a graduate transfer.

school bus

High school basketball team returns from game to find bus driver dead

Members of the girls team returned to the bus to find the driver unresponsive.

covid-19 testing site sign

Minnesota AG sues COVID testing site, alleging it sent false results

Sometimes the company didn't send people their results at all, the lawsuit alleges.

optum headquarters chad davis wikimedia commons

UnitedHealth Group says it made $287B last year, $24B of it profit

The corporation's Optum business represented a significant chunk of that total.


Omicron may have already peaked in Minnesota

Reported cases lag what's happening in real time, so the newly reported cases over the next week or so will still be very high.

MnDot snow plow cam I-35 12-10-21

MnDOT reveals 50 snowplow name finalists

Voting is open through Wednesday, Jan. 26.


Josh Donaldson

Report: Twins may be out of Josh Donaldson sweepstakes

The Twins reportedly offered a deal in excess of $20 million per season.

Josh Donaldson

Make it Rain: Josh Donaldson signs four-year deal with Twins

"The Bringer of Rain" adds more offense (and some defense) to the Bomba Squad.

Josh Donaldson

Twins among AL's biggest spenders this offseason

The Twins ranked fourth in spending while adding quality talent to an 101-win team.

Josh Donaldson

Josh Donaldson returns as Twins crush White Sox

The Twins offense came alive with Donaldson's return to the lineup.

Josh Donaldson

Twins place Josh Donaldson on IL with hamstring strain

Donaldson was injured during his first at-bat of the season.

Madison Bumgarner

A Christmas wish list for the Minnesota Twins

Twins fans have been awfully nice this year, but will they get anything for it?

Josh Donaldson

Twins beat Indians, but Josh Donaldson leaves early with injury

Donaldson left in the third inning with right calf tightness.

Josh Donaldson

Josh Donaldson says MLB umpires 'have no accountability'

The Twins third baseman has no regrets about his recent ejection.