Skip to main content

Why the Twins shouldn't fear the Yankees

I am here to tell you that there is nothing to fear when it comes to the Yankees.
Rocco Baldelli

The Minnesota Twins will be heading to the American League Divisional Series for the first time since the 2010 season next week and excitement is in the air as to what this team can do in a five-game series. As opposed to the one-game wild card playoff that the Twins were in after the 2017 season, there will be many ebbs and flows and Target Field will host a playoff game for just the third time in its existence.

All of this is great, but the Twins opponent in the ALDS was finalized on Friday night and it's understandable if some fans have some PTSD because of it.

That opponent is the New York Yankees, who have played a large role in the Twins' previous postseason failures. Entering the five-game series which is slated to start on Oct. 4, Minnesota has lost an MLB record 13 straight postseason games. Ten of those losses have come against the Bronx Bombers, including a meeting in the 2017 AL Wild Card game.

That history is enough to give flashbacks of Joe Nathan nervously flapping his lips at Yankee Stadium or Phil Cuzzi daydreaming while Joe Mauer laced a ball about 10 feet fair during a Game 2 meeting in the 2009 ALDS. Heck, ESPN will probably get in on the fun wondering how the Twins can come out of this series alive. But I am here to tell you that there is nothing to fear when it comes to the Yankees.

Yes, the Yankees do have an incredibly powerful lineup spearheaded by Aaron Judge. New York also has enjoyed breakout seasons from several young players including Gleybar Torres and Luke Voit, and they're also getting Giancarlo Stanton back after he missed a majority of the 2019 season.

But, this Twins team isn't much different from the Yankees this time around. The Yankees may have eclipsed the Twins in home runs at 305, but the 303 home runs Minnesota has hit out of the park isn't much to laugh at. In fact, the Twins have more depth than the Yankees do with an MLB record eight players with 20 or more home runs. 

That means the Yankees will have more threats to deal with going through the Twins lineup and that's bad news for a pitching staff that's just as banged up as the Twins. Only one of the Yankees' five starters this year has an ERA under 4.00 (James Paxton) and another, Domingo German, was just lost for the season after violating the MLB's domestic violence policy.

While the Twins have similar issues in their playoff rotation hoping that Jake Odorizzi, Jose Berrios, Randy Dobnak and Johnny Bullpen can handle the load, the real advantage (as crazy as this would have sounded in June) is their bullpen.

Tyler Duffey hasn't allowed an earned run in his last 23.2 innings and Taylor Rogers, with 29 saves in hand, has emerged as one of baseball's best relievers. Trevor May, Zack Littell and others have also stepped up in a big way, and Sergio Romo was a great addition at the trade deadline.

Meanwhile, the Yankees still have the best closer in the game in Aroldis Chapman and a great set-up combination with Zach Britton and Adam Ottavino, but the rest of their 'pen is falling apart. Dylan Betances hasn't pitched all year and is now dealing with a partially ruptured Achilles, and Tommy Kahnle and Chad Green haven't been as unhittable as they have in the past.

All of this is why the Twins should be able to stack up with New York despite holding a 2-4 record against the Yankees this season. That record could have easily have been .500 had Aaron Hicks not made a highlight-reel catch to end a 14-12 masterpiece at Target Field last July, and if the Twins can get to their bullpen with a lead, there is no reason that the Twins can't "shock the world" and reach the ALCS for the first time since 2002.

Next Up

10.6 Tempest Weather Thumbnail

Drought tightens grip as Twin Cities reaches 'extreme' level

By this time last year, drought was fading fast in Minnesota.

Screen Shot 2022-10-06 at 11.23.49 AM

Police looking for woman missing since car crash near lake

The 49-year-old is believed to have been driving when the crash happened.

COVID-19 vaccine testing Mall of America

Minnesota's COVID-19 update for the week ending Tuesday, Oct. 4

The 7-day average number of cases has been dropping.

Life Link

Man airlifted after being pinned under truck in northern MN

The incident happened near Nisswa, Minnesota.

Screen Shot 2022-10-06 at 8.37.44 AM

St. Paul company ends corrugated manufacturing, cutting 130 jobs

The facility produces around 200,000 tons of corrugated packaging every year.

police lights squad car dark - Unsplash

Sartell woman, 94, killed in collision with semi-truck

The crash happened in Haven Township near St. Cloud.

fire truck

Explosion reported near Hastings; man airlifted to hospital

Authorities say the victim has serious injuries.


Aaron Judge

We want New York, Twins postseason edition

Twins Daily looks at why the Yankees make for a better playoff opponent.

Rocco Baldelli

The Yankees see failure in their season, and so should the Twins

What's been dubbed a "great season" in Minnesota would be a total failure in New York.

Rocco Baldelli

Baldelli not convinced of intimidation factor at Yankee Stadium

The Yankees have knocked the Twins out of the playoff 5 times since 2004.

Eddie Rosario

If Twins don't catch the White Sox, the Yankees likely wait in the playoffs

One week to determine the MLB's Wild Card round matchups.

Miguel Sano

Better playoff matchup for Twins: Astros or Yankees?

Barring a collapse in the Central Division, the Twins are headed to New York or Houston.

Giancarlo Stanton

Attacking the heart of the Yankees' order: Part 1

Twins Daily breaks down the big bats in New York's batting order.

Target Field

Is Target Field really a home-field advantage for Twins?

The one hope for Twins fans is that a return trip home could help their favorite team take a deep breath.