Skip to main content

Why the Vikings should have traded for Gardner Minshew

The Vikings have basically left the fate of their season up to a sixth-round pick.

Watching the second quarter of the Minnesota Vikings' preseason finale, you had to know Mike Zimmer was dying inside.

With his job presumably on the line, Zimmer has been stuck with a roster that's been lacking depth. While the offensive line, safeties and linebackers are a concern, his biggest issue has to be the quarterback position.

Kirk Cousins has proven to be a top-10 quarterback during his time in Minnesota but this isn't about his performance on the field. With his normal risk of injury amplified by his unwillingness to get the COVID-19 vaccine, Cousins has left the Vikings in a precarious situation.

With Jake Browning and Kellen Mond behind Cousins, the Vikings need to improve at backup quarterback and Gardner Minshew would have been a perfect solution.

Minshew is more known for his epic mustache and cult following than his performance on the field but in his two seasons with the Jacksonville Jaguars, Minshew threw for 37 touchdowns and 11 interceptions.

The Jaguars went 1-7 in Minshew's eight career starts but that could have been by design to tank for Trevor Lawrence. For a team like the Vikings, it would have provided a solid insurance plan in case Cousins needed to miss time.

The best part is that it wouldn't have cost the Vikings much to acquire Minshew. With a cap number of $850,000, he would have fit under the Vikings' salary cap woes. At 25 years old, Minshew also has the upside to be a cheap bridge quarterback next season if the Vikings decide to move on from Cousins.

But that's where the Vikings' interest may have stopped. The Philadelphia Eagles swooped in on Saturday morning and acquired Minshew for a conditional sixth-round pick. 

While there hasn't been confirmed interest in Minshew, the Vikings should have pounced if that were the asking price.

The Vikings have built a reputation for finding late-round gems but the reality is that many of them haven't panned out. Looking at their sixth-round picks from 2015, only Oli Udoh has a chance to be a contributor and the others have been distant backups or relegated to the practice squad.

Minshew wasn't the only option for the Vikings with final cuts coming on Tuesday. The Vikings could easily jump into the free-agent market to sign Blake Bortles or just wait for C.J. Beathard to become available but they don't carry the same cost and benefits that Minshew would have.

In a season where jobs could be on the line, Spielman and Zimmer have left theirs to be hinged on a sixth-round pick. If Cousins can't stay on the field, it's an interesting hill to die on.

Next Up

Screen Shot 2022-05-23 at 9.58.36 PM

Eric Perkins, Miss Minnesota, Paul Fletcher create new podcast

The podcast is released Tuesdays at 8 a.m. and is available wherever you find podcasts.

Mock aircraft cabin.

MSP Airport debuts mock aircraft to help ease flying anxiety

The pre-flight experiences cover the TSA screening procedure, exploring a terminal, boarding a plane and meeting a pilot, and preparing for takeoff.

Scripps National Spelling Bee

These Minnesota kids will be competing at National Spelling Bee

The upcoming event in Maryland will be the first fully in-person Scripps National Spelling Bee since 2019.

covid, kids

New data shows how omicron has impacted kids in Minnesota

The new data shows breakthrough data during the omicron period, which began Dec. 19, 2021.

Javen Juan Moreno

Albert Lea shooting suspect arrested after 3 weeks on the run

He is accused of shooting a man in the upper thigh on May 1.


Motorcyclist, 59, killed after losing control on right curve

The Harley Davidson rider was thrown from his bike.

state capitol Minnesota

Minnesota's 2022 legislative session: What's happening?

A list of items agreed upon and yet to reach any bipartisan agreement in the latest legislative session.

water drain

Water main break floods 40-45 homes in St. Louis Park

The city says the rupture happened on Minnetonka Boulevard.

Eli Hart

Charges: 6-year-old Eli Hart shot up to 9 times by his mother

The 28-year-old is facing 2nd-degree murder charges.

dave lee wcco radio

Former WCCO Radio host Dave Lee moves into podcasts

His new podcast, called 'My First Concert,' launched last week.

Tow Boat

Tow boat collides with Mississippi River lock and dam in Alma, WI

The crash remains under investigation by the United States Coast Guard.

unsplash school bus

Police: Man in minivan approached kids, claimed he was former principal

Investigators say children were approached by a man in a white minivan who falsely claimed he'd been a local school principal.


Anthony Barr

5 takeaways from the Vikings preseason loss to the Colts

The Vikings looked better on Saturday but still have a ways to go.

Kirk Cousins

Vikings quarterbacks struggle in preseason loss to Colts

The Vikings fell to 0-2 on the preseason with a 12-10 loss to Indianapolis.

Mike Zimmer

Frustrated Zimmer sounds off after Vikings' positive COVID test

"I’m frustrated, not just with my football players who didn’t get vaccinated, but I’m frustrated with everybody [who didn't]."

Kris Boyd

5 takeaways from the Vikings' preseason opener vs. Denver

What can the Vikings take away from their loss to the Broncos?

Kirk Cousins

Report: Kellen Mond has COVID, Cousins among players out of practice

The team is scheduled to practice on Saturday night.

Kirk Cousins

Offseason preview: What will the Vikings do with Kirk Cousins?

Will the Vikings extend Cousins or put an eye to the future?

Mike Zimmer

Vikings rest starters, get pounded by Broncos in preseason opener

Depth is a major issue after the Vikings' 33-6 loss.