Skip to main content

Minnesota's winter forecast winner: Old Farmer's Almanac vs. Farmers' Almanac

One was quite a bit more accurate than the other.
snow, blowing snow

Winter is over, hopefully.

In retrospect, what publication forecast a more accurate winter for Minnesota: The Old Farmer's Almanac or the Farmers' Almanac?

The Old Farmer's Almanac called for a mild and dry winter for nearly all of Minnesota, with the exception for a mild and wet winter being extreme southern Minnesota south of Interstate 90. It cited less solar activity and a weak El Niño that would "prevent cold air masses from lingering in the North."

The Farmers' Almanac, meanwhile, called for a "teeth-chattering cold" winter in Minnesota with "plentiful snow." 

Before we get to the results, you need to know the monthly averages, of which we'll use Minneapolis as the point of reference. Minneapolis' average high/low temps in November, December, January, February and March are as follows: 

  • November: 41/26
  • December: 27/12
  • January: 24/8
  • February: 29/13
  • March: 41/24

In terms of snowfall, Minneapolis averages 9 inches of snow in November, 12 in December, 12 in January, 8 in February and 10 in March.

As you can see in the table below, November was colder and drier than normal, December was warmer and drier, January was colder and drier, February was colder with record-setting snow, and March was slightly cooler than normal with 10.5 inches falling at MSP Airport being right on average. 

MonthAverage high tempAverage low tempSnow (inches)

November

34.1

22.3

4.0

December

31.7

20.0

6.7

January

21.8

6.8

6.8

February

21.2

4.5

39.0

March

37.2

19.8

10.5

The Old Farmer's Almanac had it right in terms of it being drier than normal the first half of winter, but it got it wrong – outside of December – for predicting a mild winter. 

Remember the wicked visit from the polar vortex Jan. 29-31 that kept temps well below zero (wind chills were horrible) for 72+ hours? That actually helped January's temperature average fall below normal after the first half of the month had nine days above freezing.

The Old Farmer's Almanac deserves some credit for that, because without the historic Arctic blast, December and January might've trended warmer than normal.  

The Farmers' Almanac got the "teeth-chattering cold" part right and wound up looking smart with a wetter than normal forecast despite a drier than normal November, December and January. 

The metro only had 17.5 inches of snow by the end of January and wound up with 67 inches by the end of March – and a total of 77.1 if you count the 0.3 inches from October and the 9.8 inches so far in April. 

The average annual snowfall in the Twin Cities is 55 inches, so it was definitely wetter. 

Parts of far southern Minnesota (Marshall got 88 inches) got even more snow, which agin favors the Farmers' Almanac. 

It still confuses us why these farmers can't get along, but annual bragging are currently in the hands of the Farmers' Almanac. 

Next Up

turtinen two harbors

MN mayor in hot water for hawking $400M underwater hotel plan

The city council called a special meeting to discuss the mayor's public comments.

police lights

Woman in critical condition after attempted murder, authorities say

A 33-year-old woman is in custody and facing possible charges.

Flickr - police lights squad siren - Edward Kimmel

Charges: Driver threw 'large rocks' at police car during highway chase

Authorities say the suspect had used methamphetamine earlier in the day.

covid, coronavirus

Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Friday, January 21

Hospitalizations dipped from 1,629 Jan. 19 to 1,571 on Jan. 20.

minneapolis police

Shooting near University of Minnesota kills 1, injures 2

The victims were all in a parked car when the shooting happened, police said.

canada bodies found 2

Florida man charged with human smuggling after 4 die, 5 rescued near border

A baby and an teenage boy were among those who were found dead feet from the U.S. border.

Screen Shot 2022-01-21 at 8.42.40 AM

Man shot while driving on I-394 in St. Louis Park

The driver and his bullet-riddled SUV wound up outside the DoubleTree hotel in St. Louis Park.

Mall of America

Mall of America to celebrate 30 years with events, giveaways throughout 2022

The festivities will kick off Friday with a '90s-themed drag show.

Screen Shot 2022-01-21 at 7.29.00 AM

Victim of 1994 Michigan cold case murder ID'd as missing Minnesotan

Shelley Rae Kephart went missing from Hennepin County more than 28 years ago.

walz flanagan lorie shaull flickr

Gov. proposes 'Walz Checks' for most Minnesotans

The governor wants to use $700 million of the state's surplus to fund the payments.

Related

Old Farmer's Almanac releases winter forecast for Minnesota

They also believe El Niño will play a role in our weather.

snow

The Farmers' Almanac unveils 2020-21 winter forecast for Minnesota

There appear to be a lot of farmers who enjoy predicting weather and writing almanacs.

Farmers' Almanac predicts brutal winter for Minnesota

The Old Farmer's Almanac and Farmers' Almanac are butting heads about the forecast.

snow, snowplow

'Frigid & Snowy': The Farmers' Almanac releases winter forecast

Fun fact: It last snowed in the Twin Cities 110 days ago (as of Aug. 26).