Skip to main content

Early and late-season snowfalls are notoriously complicated to forecast. Temperatures swing wildly between warm and cold, and precipitation amounts are usually much larger than mid-winter storms. The type of precipitation can change quickly, but it also depends when that transition happens.

Let’s take this current storm in Minnesota and the location with the widest range of possible computer model snow outcomes: Marshall, in southwest Minnesota. 

Current model forecasts range from as little as 1 inch by Thursday morning to as much as 10 inches. Right away, most seasoned meteorologists, understanding late-March weather, are going to be very skeptical of 10 inches unless temperatures are already below freezing (and staying subfreezing consistently). 

Weather is sponsored by All Energy Solar: get a free installation quote now!

Marshall was 68 degrees on Monday. The ground is warm and it is not frozen any longer. This is an area that has been snow-free for some time. Temperatures through early Thursday will be in the 30s, at or above freezing with the type of precipitation going back and forth from snow to rain. 

It is VERY difficult to get significant snow to accumulate in these conditions. 

While it’s also overcast, the sun angle is more than twice what it was in December and solar energy does still get through to the ground. This means that snow has a hard time accumulating – except at night – unless it’s very cold.

The essential elements for heavy late-March snowfall in southern Minnesota are:

  • Night time, heavy bursts of snow
  • Below freezing, preferably for hours ahead of the snow
  • Consistency in both temperature and precipitation type

None of these conditions will be met in this storm for southern Minnesota (northeast Minnesota is a different story). That doesn’t mean snow won't fall in southwest Minnesota, it just means that 10 inches is highly unlikely. 

Let’s look at 10 different computer model scenarios:

2AC5952D-F7C8-47F6-A8F3-BB3AC4C5E97E

What’s important is to step back and look at all the models, including the extreme ones. We then look at reality, like radar and surface observations.

What’s clear is that all the models are hinting at a broken line of slightly higher snow totals across western Minnesota into southwest Minnesota (when compared to the east). This is the result of cold air on the west side of the storm system.

Let’s look at the extreme model (in this case the NAM model) which is the one in the middle-right of the graphic above. It’s creating some crazy totals. When we look at what it thinks has already happened through 8am compared with the observations we see a big red flag.

Screen Shot 2022-03-22 at 9.34.30 AM

It "thinks" 1-2 inches has already fallen when it has not. Already this will lead to an exaggerated conclusion. The models cannot account for how warm the ground is, and the mixing of precipitation and surface temperatures above freezing (even though aloft it is below freezing and cold enough to create snow). These are complicating factors limiting snow already Tuesday morning and will continue to do so during the daytime hours, both Tuesday and Wednesday.

Sign up: Subscribe to our BREAKING NEWS newsletters

Looking at all the models together we can see that there is somewhat of a consensus, which helps to eliminate the outliers. Nine of the 10 models are predicting anywhere from 1.3 inches to 4 inches in Marshall, while the NAM is hammering Marshall with 10 inches. 

We can then apply some statistics to narrow in on a most likely range. While the 10-inch model is 1 of 10, it’s not a 10% chance. Statistically, it’s so far out that it’s an outlier that probably is closer to a 1% chance of becoming reality.

Screen Shot 2022-03-22 at 9.29.26 AM

It’s clear without even applying a statistical analysis that most of the models agree on 2-4 inches of snow for the Marshall area.

This example doesn't mean the NAM model is awful and never to be trusted. On the contrary, every model has good and bad times and strengths and weaknesses. It’s just that with this storm, today, the NAM is out to lunch. 

Next Up

best buy

Best Buy makes job cuts weeks after warning of soft sales

The Richfield retailer has been dealing with a shift in consumer trends.

Screen Shot 2022-08-12 at 10.26.20 PM

Police: Man makes Jewish slur at golfer, smashes own car up with club

It happened at a course that was founded as a Jewish country club 100 years ago.

Screen Shot 2022-08-12 at 9.59.07 PM

4 abandoned puppies found in a bucket in Willmar

The puppies were in good health when they were discovered.

Minneapolis police

Suspect of home invasion, murder in Minneapolis arrested in Wisconsin

There have been 57 deaths reported as homicides in Minneapolis this year.

Carson McCoy

Charges: Man stole handgun from house, fired at motorcyclists from car

A chaotic scene that led to a police chase unfolded after an alleged burglary in Ham Lake.

Mounds view 7 - crime scene

BCA's Uniform Crime Report shows violent crime in MN spiked in 2021

The report details violent crime trends in the seven-county metro and Greater Minnesota.

Screen Shot 2022-08-12 at 4.49.22 PM

Search for vulnerable man, 66, missing from Brooklyn Park

Alex Ramirez was last seen in the early hours of Thursday morning.

St. Cloud Times

St. Cloud Times writing staff hit by Gannett budget cuts

Mass layoffs were expected at Gannett-owned outlets across the country.

PoolScammerLawsuitAG

Pool company sued by AG for allegedly scamming homeowners out of $1M-plus

According to the lawsuit, 17 Minnesota homeowners were affected by this scam.

image

Late cancellation of music festival leaves bad blood in Two Harbors

The cancellation announcement says the promoter walked away from the gig after being harassed by some local residents.

Related

Lake Nokomis

Why Minnesota's cool spring is a good indicator for a hot summer

Meteorologist Sven Sundgaard explains why our cool spring means there's a good chance Minnesota has a hot summer.

tornado

Explainer: The ingredients fueling next week's severe weather hype

Photo caption: A tornado in Benton County, Minnesota, in 2014.

Screen Shot 2022-03-02 at 1.10.09 PM

Heavy snow, thunder and lightning could accompany incoming MN storm

The could be a narrow band of heavy snow accumulations, but the storm track will be key.

Screen Shot 2022-04-08 at 2.29.51 PM

Monitoring 'a monster storm' that will impact MN next week

The bigger focus is the big storm for next week that could bring thunderstorms and heavy snow for some.

Lake Minnetonka

The staggering rise of Minnesota's most famous lakes this spring

Imagine dumping Lake Minnetonka into Lake Superior 47 times.

Screen Shot 2019-03-05 at 2.37.44 PM

Snowstorm coming? A look inside the world of computer models

Don't bank on any of the snowfall totals computer models show this far out.

Screen Shot 2022-03-18 at 12.44.42 PM

Rain and snow looks likely next week in Minnesota

Meteorologist Sven Sundgaard shows what 8 different models are suggesting in terms of snowfall.

snow, slush

Messy spring storm to plow through Minnesota this week

Some models are suggesting some hefty snow totals for parts of Minnesota.