Skip to main content

A long fight over wearing political buttons at polling places is over – probably

Critics of Minnesota's law said it violated their free speech rights.

Strolling into your polling place with your favorite candidate's face on your t-shirt remains a no-no in Minnesota. And this week's court ruling may be the final word in the long-running court case. Unless it's not.

The Eighth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld Minnesota's law banning political buttons or apparel at polling places (or within 100 feet of them).

Critics of the law said it violates their First Amendment right to free speech.

The Appeals Court said in Tuesday's ruling (read it here) it's OK for states to restrict speech in a place that's not a public forum – like a polling place – as long as it's viewpoint-neutral and there's a good reason for it. The judges say ensuring that a polling place is "neutral and free of influence" qualifies as a reason.

What does the law say?

Under the law no one can wear a political button, badge, or insignia to a polling place. There also can't be any political signs up nor anyone campaigning within 100 feet of the place.

In its ruling the appeals court went over what happens if you do show up with a political button. First an election judge will ask you to take it off or cover it up. If you do, no problem.

If you refuse, you can still vote but your name and address will be taken down and you could be prosecuted for breaking the law – a misdemeanor.

By the way, the law specifically mentions the "I VOTED" stickers that get handed out afterwards and says those are OK.

'Please ID Me' buttons

The court case dates back to 2010, when Minnesotans were voting on a Constitutional amendment that would have required a photo ID to vote.

Supporters of the proposal wanted to wear "Please ID Me" buttons to the polling place.

Groups including Election Integrity Watch, Minnesota Northstar Tea Party Patriots, and Minnesota Majority tried unsuccessfully to get a court to block enforcement of the political button ban.

In 2011 they filed their lawsuit. A federal court threw it out. Then an appeals court told the lower court they'd have to hear part of the case. They did and upheld the law. Now, in 2017, the appeals court has agreed with them.

In a statement applauding the court's ruling, Hennepin County Attorney Mike Freeman said: "Barring a successful appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court ... the six-year court battle is over."

Next Up

Seventh Street Truck Park shooting, St. Paul

St. Paul man pleads guilty in illegal firearms conspiracy

One of the guns Gabriel Lee Young-Duncan obtained was used in a deadly St. Paul shooting last year.

Train Days

Historic locomotives to roll into St. Paul for Train Days

The festival at the Union Depot returns June 4-5.

Dalton tornado

Tornadoes, large hail, damaging wind possible in Sunday/Monday storms

The Twin Cities is among the areas that could get hit.

Redtail Ridge Elementary

Sunbather on the roof triggers shelter-in-place at Savage elementary school

The sunbather told police he was trying to "tan and relax."

Nero

The Raptor Center's ambassador, Nero the turkey vulture, dies at 47

Nero helped save the California condors before taking up his post as an education ambassador.

Ben Leber

Ben Leber named new permanent co-host of 'Twin Cities Live'

The former Minnesota Vikings linebacker was introduced Friday afternoon.

MPR

APM Reports, maker of 'In the Dark' podcast, nixed by Minnesota Public Radio

MPR said "select programming elements" of APM Reports will be incorporated into MPR News.

storm, severe

The latest on holiday weekend severe weather chances for MN

The most significant severe threats are Sunday night and again on Monday.

Arianna Vos

Charges: Driver was drunk, high in head-on crash that killed 19-year-old woman

The young woman killed in the crash was a college student studying zoology.

Related

A 20-point swing in Wisconsin? How Clinton and Trump look in the polls now

A clearer picture of the impact of the Trump tapes and the Clinton Wikileaks release can now be seen through election polls.

In MN, picking presidential candidates at a caucus is so last year

Now that 2017 is here, Minnesota is a presidential primary state

Don't get worked up over instant polls and who 'won' the debate

Have you seen all those "Who won the debate?" instant polls? Yeah, don't put too much stock into them.

A recount confirms it: Republicans control the MN Senate by 1 seat

The hand recount in St. Cloud upheld a Republican Senate candidate's narrow victory.

A Trump election fraud commission wants voter info; will MN deliver it?

A presidential commission on election fraud is asking states for voter information.

Recap and fact-checking from the final presidential debate

GoMN is providing live updates and fact-checking from tonight's final presidential debate.

Yes, Donald Trump's name will be on the ballot, MN Supreme Court orders

Minnesota DFL Chair Ken Martin filed a petition to the Minnesota Supreme Court arguing the Minnesota Republican Party made “clear errors” during the nomination process.