'A real tool': Doctor sues over online review

A Duluth doctor was offended when the son of a patient posted in an online review that a nurse supposedly had called him "a real tool," the Associated Press reports. So Dr. David McKee took an unusually aggressive step and is suing for defamation. Now the Minnesota Supreme Court is mulling whether the case should go to trial.
Author:
Publish date:

A Duluth doctor was offended when the son of a patient posted a review on rate-your-doctor websites that a nurse supposedly had called him "a real tool," the Associated Press reports. So Dr. David McKee took an unusually aggressive step and sued for defamation, and now the Minnesota Supreme Court is expected to rule in the next few months if the case should go to trial, the newspaper reports.

The case could be significant because it offers the courts a chance to address an ongoing tension on review websites, such as Yelp and Angie's List, between the free speech rights of consumers (or patients), and the rights of business owners (like doctors) to protect their reputations.

McKee, 50, is one of a small number of doctors who have gone to court to fight online critics, a story in the Jewish World Review notes.

In a few previous similar cases:

In Orlando, a doctor sued last spring after a woman wrote a bad review of her breast augmentation surgery, Business Insider reports.

An Oregon pastor sued a mother and her daughter for $500,000 after the two blogged about the church and described it as "cult-like," Fox News reported last spring.

Next Up

Related

Ritchie introduces online ballot tool

A new online tool unveiled by Secretary of State Mark Ritchie will help voters get informed about candidates in their district. After redistricting in the state this year, Ritchie says the tool will be especially helpful to voters in a new district.

Duluth head shop owner sues feds over store raid

The owner of The Last Place on Earth in Duluth sued the federal government this week stemming from a raid by the Drug Enforcement Agency in July, Agents reportedly seized a large amount of the store's inventory, including two vehicles and $3 million in cash.