Updated:
Original:

Watch: Al Franken loses his mind while quizzing Facebook lawyer about Russian ads

The senator shouted at Facebook's lawyer about ads bought with Russian roubles.

Facebook's general counsel probably doesn't get yelled at very often. Especially by a U.S. senator over the company's technology and Russian roubles.

But he got an earful about just that from a (clearly perturbed) Sen. Al Franken Tuesday.

High-level execs from Facebook, Google and Twitter were in front of the Senate Judiciary Committee for a session on Russian election interference subtitled "Working with Tech to Find Solutions."

When Franken spoke, it was less of a cooperative "working with each other" vibe, and more of a "how the hell did you miss this?" dressing down.

Related: 

Al Franken tears into former Equifax CEO over the data breach

C-SPAN has the full, 3-hour testimony from the subcommittee. Thankfully, some kind YouTubers have pulled Franken's bit specifically, where he mainly questions Facebook lawyer Colin Stretch. (The clip should start at about 0:45, and things really get testy a couple minutes in.)

If you can't watch and listen right now, here's a bit of the transcript:

"Mr. Stretch," Franken asks. "How did Facebook, which prides itself on being able to process billions of data points and instantly transform them into personal connections for its users, somehow not make the connection that electoral ads, paid for in roubles, were coming from Russia?

"Those are two data points: American political ads and Russia money, roubles. How could you not connect those two dots?"

Stretch begins to talk about that as one aspect of the Russian threat, adding that in hindsight, "there are signals we missed."

Franken, voice slowly rising to a yell, cuts him off: 

"OK, people are buying ads on your platform with roubles. They're political ads. You put billions of data points together all the time, that's what i hear that these platforms do. They're the most sophisticated things invented by man, ever. Google has all knowledge that man has ever developed. You can't put together roubles with a political ad and go like, 'Hmmm, those two data points spell out something bad?'"

"Senator, it's a signal we should have been alert to, and in hindsight, it's one we missed," Stretch responds.

"OK, yeah," Franken jumps back in, face buried in his hands. Just look at it – you don't even need the sound of his exasperated sigh to pick up on his frustration. 

The three social media execs are back in front of lawmakers Wednesday, this time the Senate Intelligence Committee.

All of this comes after it was revealed in recent weeks that Russian-connected accounts bought election-related ads on the three social media platforms.

Klobuchar: 'I don't think it's enough'

Franken's fellow Minnesota senator, Amy Klobuchar, also asked questions at the hearing (though with slightly less showmanship than Franken.) She starts at about 1:14 in the C-SPAN video.

Klobuchar said she does "appreciate the efforts" from these companies, "but I don't think it's enough."

Her concern is about enforcement and consistency. Social media companies can apply all the internal rules they want – if there's no authority to ensure they're following through, that's a potentially large hole.

"We're going to have a patchwork of ads from different companies. Some won't be doing anything, some will be doing one thing, another will be doing another thing. We won't have actual enforcement. Management can change and decisions change, and that's why I think it's very important we have the same rules of the road for these issue ads, as well as candidate ads that we have for TV, radio and print. It's that simple," she said.

Klobuchar recently introduced a bill – cosponsored by one Democrat and one Republican – that would bring online political advertising guidelines more in line with what TV or radio broadcasters are required to do.

Read our story with details about her proposal here.

Next Up

Screen Shot 2021-06-04 at 6.30.24 AM

County attorney: Winston Smith killing justified, no charges for deputies

The prosecutor who reviewed the case recommended against any criminal charges for officers involved.

halloween trick or treat

Dr. Fauci says trick-or-treating this year is OK, 'enjoy it'

“Particularly if you’re vaccinated, you can get out there ... and enjoy it," the nation's top infections disease doctor said.

covid

COVID cases growing faster in Minnesota than anywhere else in US

But there's a bit more to the story when also considering hospitalizations and deaths.

wikimedia commons - old country buffet - Snade6

MN company buys Old Country Buffet brand — but will it reopen?

BBQ Holdings acquired the brand as part of a larger deal.

Gregory Ulrich

Charges upped to first-degree murder for accused Buffalo clinic shooter

Gregory Paul Ulrich is accused of shooting killing one person and injuring four others.

244469012_4444193795616476_1433019284179437133_n

Multiple tornadoes confirmed in Minnesota over the weekend

The Park Rapids tornado caused damage to multiple structures, including a church and a car dealership.

Trey Potts

Trey Potts won't return this season after 'really scary' injury

Potts took over the lead back role after Mohamed Ibrahim's season-ending injury against Ohio State.

Ben Simmons

The Ben Simmons situation in Philadelphia continues to evolve

Minnesota opens the regular season on Oct. 20. Will Simmons be traded by then?

minnetonka moccasin

Minnetonka Moccasin apologizes for appropriating Native American culture

The company has laid out a plan to do better and support Native American communities.

ambulance

Girl, 4, dies after falling from trailer being pulled by pickup

The tragic incident happened Saturday afternoon in Wright County.

Related

Update: Franken explains why Russian ads on Facebook bring up 'serious concerns'

Facebook said Russian accounts ran ads specifically about divisive issues in America.

Klobuchar's proposal to hold Facebook, Google and Twitter accountable for shady election ads

Sen. Amy Klobuchar has a proposal that would close the online election ad loophole.

Al Franken has low expectations for Jeff Sessions' testimony

Sessions will publicly testify about the Russia investigation Tuesday. Franken is hoping for answers.

Report of Russian cyberattack days before election has Klobuchar concerned

A leaked NSA document published by The Intercept says Russian intelligence launched a cyberattack days before the election.

Are voters changing their minds on whether they think Al Franken should resign?

A new poll of Minnesota voters found them split on whether the senator should step down.

Al Franken has to change a lot of minds if he wants to win back Minnesotans' trust

The senator vows he'll make amends – but recent polls show serious damage to his public standing.

What Sen. Al Franken said about the choice of Tina Smith as his successor

Smith will take over for Franken in the Senate once he steps down.

What Franken and Klobuchar asked during the Sally Yates hearing

Both of Minnesotas senators were part of the big Russia/2016 election/Mike Flynn hearing Monday.