Skip to main content

Minnesota's law limiting coal power goes too far, another court says

  • Author:
  • Updated:
    Original:

Supporters of a law Minnesota passed in 2007 say it encourages utility companies to switch to cleaner energy instead of burning coal.

But for the second time a court has said a key part of that law is unconstitutional.

The law called the Next Generation Energy Act bans importing power to Minnesota from any big new plant that adds to carbon dioxide emissions.

So under that law, energy from coal-fired plants that went up in North Dakota since '07 can't be sold to Minnesotans.

North Dakota and three electric co-ops with Minnesota customers filed a federal lawsuit in 2011. They argued that Minnesota is basically trying to regulate utilities in other states. The court agreed with them, saying the Constitution makes it clear that only Congress can make rules about interstate commerce.

Minnesota appealed. On Wednesday the law was shot down again, this time by three judges on the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals.

https://twitter.com/EnergyLawProf/status/743127640018538496

North Dakota Attorney General Wayne Stenehjem applauded the appeals court ruling, saying in a statement: "North Dakota has once again prevailed in its lawsuit against Minnesota’s overreaching regulations.”

Stenehjem noted that Minnesota is also on the hook to cover North Dakota's court costs, which he says are up to about $1 million.

Gov. Mark Dayton says he strongly disagrees with the court's decision to strike down "an essential part" of Minnesota's clean energy law.

Will the case go to the U.S. Supreme Court? Dayton says: “I will need to review this ruling with the Attorney General before further consideration of how to proceed."

Next Up

ambulance

One dead, two injured in wrong-way crash on Hwy. 169

The crash occurred on Highway 169 early Sunday morning.

minneapolis police

Man fatally shot overnight in north Minneapolis

The shooting was reported around 2:20 a.m.

Screen Shot 2022-05-22 at 8.30.08 AM

Campsites closed at Voyageurs National Park due to 'historic' water levels

All backcountry trails and campsites are closed, as well as many frontcountry sites.

state capitol Minnesota

Lawmakers reach agreement on tax cuts ahead of session's end

Lawmakers announced they had reached a deal on a tax bill Saturday ahead of the looming session deadline.

281699116_10226502238438986_800951410789352812_n

Victims of daytime drive-by shooting in Robbinsdale identified

The two men died after a hail of bullets struck a vehicle.

Screen Shot 2022-05-22 at 8.14.37 AM

Source of 'loud explosion' in Brooklyn Park a mystery

The noise was investigated by police, but no source could be determined.

covid, vaccine, booster shots

COVID: All Americans over 50 advised to get a second booster

Cases, hospitalizations and deaths are on the rise again as new COVID variants emerge.

J.W. Peck (left) and Eric Galler.

2 Minnesotans inducted into White Castle's Hall of Fame

White Castle — it's what a man in Minneapolis and another in Woodbury, crave.

Screen Shot 2022-05-21 at 5.46.37 PM

Video shows officers ended pursuit before fatal crash in Anoka

The crash occurred when the driver fled police during an attempted traffic stop in Coon Rapids.

Eli Hart

6-year-old Eli Hart identified as boy found dead in car trunk

The kindergartner's father was trying to get full custody of his son.

IMG_3509

Boy found dead in trunk of car in Mound was kindergartner

"It is horrifying and difficult to process a tragedy of this magnitude, especially in our close-knit community," the superintendent wrote.

Minneapolis police

Man found yelling for help after being shot in Minneapolis

The shooting occurred on the 800 block of Elwood Avenue North at around 9:15 p.m.

Related