Can a court force you to unlock a phone with your fingerprint? Yep

If investigators need your fingerprint to access your phone for a case, they can probably get it.
Author:
Updated:
Original:

A court can order a criminal suspect to use their fingerprint to unlock a phone – and it's not a violation of their Constitutional rights.

That's what the Minnesota Supreme Court said Wednesday, in which it ruled on a question that hasn't been touched by the U.S. Supreme Court, or any other state supreme court up to this point.

The case involves Matthew Diamond, who was arrested in 2014 in connection with a burglary. Authorities got a warrant to seize and search his cellphone, and when they needed Diamond's fingerprint to unlock it, a judge ordered him to give it.

The state used texts, phone calls and cellphone ping data during the trial to make its case, and Diamond was found guilty.

But Diamond appealed.

He argued, in part, that being forced to give his fingerprints was essentially the same as making somebody testify against themselves – which they can't do. That's why the whole "plead the 5th" thing exists.

What the ruling says

The Minnesota Court of Appeals didn't see it Diamond's way in its ruling from January 2017. And neither did the state Supreme Court, which upheld the appeals court's decision.

The basic question is: If investigators used data found on Diamond's phone – only unlocked because he was ordered to use his fingerprint – as part of the case, does that amount to Diamond being forced to incriminate himself?

The answer is no, the state Supreme Court said (you can read the full opinion here).

That's because the 5th Amendment only protects a suspect from "testimonial communication," actually offering something up knowledge from their mind.

Providing a fingerprint to unlock a phone is simply presenting a physical characteristic, similar to "standing in a lineup or providing a blood, voice, or handwriting sample."

In addition, the "act of providing a fingerprint to the police was not testimonial because the act did not reveal the contents of Diamond’s mind."

So, no Constitutional violation.

What about a passcode? That's trickier

The Minnesota Supreme Court has said using your fingerprint to unlock a phone isn't forcing you to give up something you know. It's a conclusion other judges around the country have come to also, as The Atlantic wrote about.

But what about your passcode?

As the Consumerist wrote, judges in Michigan and Virginia have ruled suspects can not be required to give phone unlock codes. That's because it's forcing the suspect to communicate knowledge – which is possibly self-incriminating.

A new wrinkle is the facial recognition scanning unlock technology the iPhone X touts so much.

That seems like it would fall into the same category as providing a fingerprint. But no court has actually ruled on it.

According to a Washington Post story from September of 2017, the final answer to that simply isn't known.

“Ultimately, this is the next development in the already existing, open legal question," Susan Hennessey, managing editor of Lawfare, told the paper.

There is a way to quickly disable an iPhone's biometric unlocks. As Wired reports, iOS11 has an "SOS" mode – if someone taps the home button five times in quick succession, it will disable TouchID and/or FaceID (depending on the model) and revert back to a passcode lock screen.

Next Up

Jan and Chris Kruse

'Dateline' episode will explore Minnesota woman's unsolved murder

Jan Pigman-Kruse was fatally shot in her bed in 2015. Her husband was acquitted in the case.

124906958_401361401236047_6293747214536025849_o

Pandemic pushes need for cybersecurity, I.T. management professionals to the forefront

Enroll in a Master's course in one of these increasingly vital disciplines at the University of Wisconsin-Superior.

mike freeman

Hennepin County will eliminate bail system for certain non-violent crimes

The reform is backed by Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison.

Kirk Cousins

Coller: Vikings vs. Jags is a battle of retool vs. rebuild

Matthew Coller writes a weekly Vikings column for BMTN, with more of his work found at Purple Insider.

Screen Shot 2020-11-23 at 8.35.40 AM

More than 230,000 people have downloaded Minnesota's COVID exposure app

The more people who use the app, the more effective it is.

Ext_17

Despite pandemic, Life Time pushes ahead to open downtown co-working space

It was originally planned to open in the fall, but it has been pushed back to April.

shamrocks irish nook

The Nook issues plea, asks people to order from its other restaurant

Shamrocks Irish Nook has the same food as The Nook, the restaurant owners say.

Screen Shot 2020-12-02 at 9.55.05 PM

Small plane lands on northbound I-35W in Twin Cities

A large police presence is at the scene.

Plainview

Judge orders Minnesota gym that defied shutdown to close

Attorney General Keith Ellison sued the gym after it remained open.

montana cutbank

Charges: Man shot victim 'without provocation' using sawed-off shotgun

The incident happened on Nov. 24 in Ten Lake Township, located in Beltrami County.

Governor Tim Walz

Watch live: Walz, first responders address Minnesotans

Some departments have been forced to shift staffing or suspend service due to COVID-19.

Related

You can Boomerang from inside Instagram now

Get some sweet Boomerangs in your Instagram story.

Do you know when Uber is tracking your location?

We know apps collect data about us. But how much, and how is it being used?

Samsung is 'truly sorry' for the whole exploding phone fiasco

Remember the Note7 burns and explosions? Samsung is sorry about that.

Let your Uber driver know where you are without having to awkwardly call them

No more revealing your personal phone number to a stranger.

New proposal: Internet companies should pay you if they use or sell your data

It's your data that's valuable – should you get compensated for it?

Facebook is trying to make fewer crappy links show up on your feed

You know the ones – where the page you go to is full of an absurd number of ads.

Netflix remembers every time you pause a show (and a lot of other info)

It sees you when you're binging. It knows when you hit pause.