Casino dispute: Fond du Lac band not required to pay Duluth $10M in back payments - Bring Me The News

Casino dispute: Fond du Lac band not required to pay Duluth $10M in back payments

Author:
Updated:
Original:

In what the Duluth News Tribune calls "a major victory for the band," a judge ruled Tuesday that the Fond du Lac Band of Lake Superior Chippewa is not required to pay the city of Duluth more than $10 million in back payments.

The dispute is over proceeds from its downtown casino operations.

WDIO explained that the ruling by U.S. District Judge Susan Richard Nelson addresses casino revenue that the city says should have been made from 2009 to 2011. She held that the 1986 Fond-du-Luth Casino revenue-sharing agreement violated the federal law that requires tribes to be the "primary beneficiary" of gambling profits.

Fond du Lac Chairwoman Karen Diver said she was pleased with the ruling. In a written statement Diver said, "The Band continues to hope that the whole matter can be put to rest."

But the ruling is a blow to the city, which had used casino profits as a source for paying for street repairs until 2009, when the band stopped payments. Under the agreement, the band had contributed about $6 million a year. Between 1994 to 2009, the band paid 19 percent of gross revenue, totaling $75 million, to the city.

The city sued, seeking back payments; city officials maintained the band owed more than $13.5 million.

The Northland's News Center added that Judge Nelson originally ruled in favor of the city, but the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled she should have taken into account the intent of the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act.

Duluth City Attorney Gunnar Johnson indicated the city was "reviewing its options" and would not rule out an appeal.

Next Up

Related

Fond du Lac band and city of Duluth file appeals in casino profit-sharing ruling

Both sides are filing appeals after a judge declared that the band does not need to share profits from its Fond-du-Luth casino with the city of Duluth. But the band, which declared victory in the case, wants to reverse a decision that would still require it to pay $14 million in back payments to the city. The band stopped making the payments in 2009, which sparked the legal battle.

Fond du Lac Band to choose leader Tuesday

Voting members of the Fond du Lac Band of Lake Superior Chippewa will choose the next chair of their Reservation Business Committee. The position oversees a budget of about $180 million and businesses, including a casino amid a legal battle with the city of Duluth. Pete DeFoe is challenging incumbent Karen Diver for the four-year term.