Skip to main content

Changes proposed in the way St. Paul handles allegations of police misconduct

  • Author:
  • Updated:

Changes are coming to the civilian-police board that oversees complaints made against St. Paul officers, including the way it handles incidents where police allegedly show "excessive force" or "inappropriate use of firearms."

An independent audit of the Saint Paul Police Internal Affairs Review Commission was ordered in January, amid concern that investigations into officer complaints would not be impartial – due to the fact that the commission's board is made up of police and residents who advised the chief, the Star Tribune reports.

The results of this report, conducted by the University of Minnesota, were released Friday and recommend a series of changes to improve the accountability of city police and the independence of the review board.

Among the recommendations are:

  • Every complaint of excessive force and inappropriate use of firearms against a police officer automatically triggers an independent investigation.
  • The Police-Civilian Internal Affairs Review Commission moves its office outside police headquarters to the Department of Human Rights and Equal Economic Opportunity, and have meetings held in different community locations.
  • Increase the number of civilians on the commission, increasing representation from St. Paul's diverse communities, and "prioritizing participation by neighborhoods/populations most affected by police misconduct and interactions."
  • Removing the two members of the St. Paul Police Federation union who are also voting members of the commission.
  • Investigations by the St. Paul PD's internal affairs department should not make recommendations for action to be taken by the commission, only "findings," allowing the commission to reach its own conclusions.

City Mayor Chris Coleman said in a press release that the recommendations won't be implemented immediately. They instead will be evaluated by the City Attorney, Sammy Clark, who will make a final recommendation to the Mayor's Office early next year.

"We are committed to moving forward in the best and most transparent manner," he added, "and how we do so must be informed by both a robust community conversation and by current law."

In coming up with the recommendations, the audit team from the U of M studied 40 commission "deliberation memos" that covered 310 complaints against city police.

The audit was announced just a short while after the fatal, officer-involved shooting of 24-year-old Marcus Golden in the city, a shooting an investigation found to be justified after Golden drove a car at officers – but which was nonetheless decried by local black leaders.

However, Mayor Chris Coleman at the time said that the audit wasn't in response to Golden's death, and had been planned up to a month beforehand following discussions between the Mayor's Office and members of the Black Ministerial Alliance and the African American Leadership Council.

Next Up

Screen Shot 2022-05-25 at 9.34.43 AM

Video: Plane with blown tire makes emergency landing at MSP Airport

An aviation enthusiast caught the moment on video.

Pixabay - laptop computer dark screen

St. Paul man charged in online 'sextortion' scheme targeting at least 500 girls

Yue Vang, 31, was charged in U.S. District Court Wednesday.

Great Dane Rescue and Sanctuary

Emaciated Great Danes rescued after being found living in minivan

Great Dane Rescue of Minnesota and Wisconsin posted that two of the dogs are in "rough condition" and "barely hanging on."

Screen Shot 2020-05-26 at 10.28.52 AM

2 years since George Floyd's killing, Biden signs exec order on policing

The signing comes on the second anniversary of Floyd's murder by police in south Minneapolis.


Lutsen Mountains owner to buy Michigan ski resort

The Skinner family has operated alpine ski areas in the Midwest for 60 years.


Mayo Clinic, CDC address concerns over monkeypox in the US

The CDC does not currently think there is a significant threat to the general public.

police tape

Charges: Man killed brother, left body in homemade camper for 7 months

James Robert Hess, 48, faces second-degree murder charges for the death of his 52-year-old brother, William Harold Hess Jr.


Minnesota forecast: Hot, humid and severe storm chances

Bring Me The News meteorologist Sven Sundgaard says right now the best chance for storms looks like Sunday/Sunday night.

Thai Cultural Council of Minnesota

Minnesota's biggest Thai festival to be hosted in front of State Capitol

The Thai New Year, or Songkran, is one of the most celebrated holidays in Thailand.

police tape, crime scene

Man dies after being shot in the head in St. Cloud

Investigators believe the suspects fled the scene in a vehicle.


Uvalde school massacre: MN Democrats call for action, Republicans prayers

The tragedy in Texas has sparked different reactions from Minnesota's congressional delegation.


St. Paul mayor turns down police request for 50 more officers

Melvin Carter made his statement on Facebook Friday.

Police kill a bear in St. Paul overnight

Officers were called to the city's Frogtown neighborhood early Sunday morning after a bear was seen roaming the area. WCCO reports the Department of Natural Resources was contacted and advised police to shoot the black bear versus tranquilizing.