Skip to main content

Comments insulting miners lead to an apology from Save the Boundary Waters

'They want somebody to just give them a job so they can all drink beer.'

In northeastern Minnesota it's not unusual for people who live close together to be miles apart on the hot-button topic in the region. 

And an article published this week by The New York Times Magazine quickly deepened the rift between those who disagree on whether a proposed copper and nickel mine would be good for the region.

The story includes quotes from two leaders of the Ely-based group Save the Boundary Waters who said some not-very-nice things about their neighbors who are miners and the "pro-mining crowd."

What they said

Reid Carron told the reporter the mining crowd is driven by resentment.

"(T)hey are resentful that other people have come here and been successful while they were sitting around waiting for a big mining company,” he said. “They want somebody to just give them a job so they can all drink beer with their buddies and go four-wheeling and snowmobiling with their buddies, not have to think about anything except punching a clock.”

The article portrays the division in the community and features a miner, Dan Forstman, who said he thinks part of the problem is a condescension from those who oppose a new mine – specifically Becky Rom, who's the national campaign chair for Save the Boundary Waters. 

Rom, who spoke to the reporter along the South Kawishiwi River, fired back: “Danny Forsman drivesto the mine in his truck, comes home and watches TV, and he doesn’t know this world exists.”


Dave Lislegard, a former steelworker who serves on the Aurora city council told WDIO the remarks are disheartening for Iron Rangers. 

"We can agree to disagree. But attacking our way of life, for the Range, it's very disappointing," Lislegard said.

Republican and DFL political officials were on the same side of this issue, with denouncements of the remarks coming from both parties.

U.S. Rep. Tom Emmer, a Republican, said in a statement: "I am embarrassed to hear fellow Minnesotans speak so disparagingly about our neighbors," adding “I urge my fellow Minnesota colleagues to join me in condemning these unnecessary mean-spirted attacks on our hardworking citizens.”

Ken Martin, who chairs Minnesota's DFL party, says people on each side of the copper mining issue want better lives for their families and a better future for the state. Martin says: “Here in Minnesota, we value civility. We treat each other with respect. We must keep this debate healthy, productive, and focused on the issue at hand." 

 The apology

Later Friday Save the Boundary Waters issued its own statement, saying they can be advocates for their cause without denigrating those who disagree with them. 

The statements in the New York Times Magazine "fell far short of that standard. And for that we truly apologize."

They also said miners are some of the hardest workers in Minnesota. "That is a not a life to be mocked or derided," they said. "For any comments that did so, we are truly sorry."

Next Up

D'Angelo Russell

D'Lo's late takeover helps Timberwolves win double-OT thriller

Russell caught fire to help the Timberwolves get back to .500.

Gopher Football

Gophers suffocate Badgers, reclaim Paul Bunyan's Axe

Minnesota picked up its first home win over the Badgers since 2003.

Meeker County Sheriff's Office

Boy, 6, run over after falling off trailer in Meeker Co. tree farm accident

He was airlifted to Hennepin County Medical Center with internal injuries.

Target store

Target unveils deals for 2-day 'Cyber Monday' event

The promotion kicks off Sunday, November 28.

Screen Shot 2021-11-27 at 9.59.30 AM

Edina police warn of recent burglary trend targeting garages and vehicles

The Edina Police Department is increasing patrols in affected neighborhoods in response to the trend.

Screen Shot 2021-11-27 at 9.03.06 AM

Charges: Man shot Uber Eats driver making a delivery in Cottage Grove

Otis Donnell Shipp was charged with second-degree attempted murder after turning himself in on Wednesday.

Screen Shot 2021-11-27 at 7.36.14 AM

Waterfront hotel in Duluth sustains damage in kitchen fire

Authorities estimate the damage at around $75,000.

Screen Shot 2021-11-27 at 7.15.18 AM

Large groups of thieves target 2 Twin Cities Best Buys on Black Friday

It bears similarities to the flash-mob style thefts seen recently in California.

Karl-Anthony Towns

Timberwolves' winning streak snapped at five games

The Wolves' bid for their longest winning streak since 2014 came up short.

Screen Shot 2020-08-14 at 6.45.53 PM

Teen arrested over fatal shooting of 5-year-old boy in Brooklyn Park

Police say the teen was filming a social media video while handling a gun.

Joe Biden

President Biden coming to Minnesota to promote Bipartisan Infrastructure Law

Tuesday's trip follows passage of the $1.2 trillion Bipartisan Infrastructure Deal.


Tom Landwehr

Ex-DNR commissioner is new Save The Boundary Waters director

Tom Landwehr will continue the fight against the Twin Metals mining project.

Twin Metals formally submits plans for mine near Boundary Waters

Environmental groups have urged Gov. Tim Walz to reject it.

Screen Shot 2019-05-15 at 1.51.39 PM

Trump Admin. renews leases for mining project near Boundary Waters

Two Minnesota congressmen were on hand for the signing.

Betty McCollum slams government 'report' on Boundary Waters pollution

The State Department's response was only 8 paragraphs long.

Harvard study: Protecting BWCA is better for economy than mining

The area would make more money from tourism in the long-term, it says.