Skip to main content

Comparing the tax cut plans from Republican lawmakers and Gov. Dayton

GOP lawmakers in the House and Senate have offered up big tax cuts. The governor's tax cut plan isn't as large.

Three of the biggest forces that will shape how much money Minnesota spends over the next couple years have now laid out their broad plans for taxes.

The House Republicans announced a large tax relief effort Monday, which comes days after Senate Republicans and Gov. Mark Dayton (a Democrat) put forward their visions.

Here's a look at how each proposal compares.

House Republicans

House Republicans, led by Speaker Kurt Daudt of Crown, unveiled their budget targets Monday. Included is $1.35 billion in tax cuts for Minnesotans.

Daudt in his news release points to the state's budget surplus – projected to be $1.65 billion over the next two years – as a reason to provide "long-overdue tax relief" to the people that "work so hard to generate" that tax revenue for the state.

Daudt, according to Session Daily, said those tax cuts will be focused on "middle-class families, students, elderly residents, agriculture and small businesses."

Senate Republicans

Just like in the House, Republicans have a majority in Minnesota's Senate. And last Friday, the Senate GOP put out a budget plan that includes $900 million in tax cuts.

Unlike the House GOP's more targeted tax cuts (details of which are still to be announced), the Senate's plan includes a permanent reduction in the income tax rate for middle class families. The announcement says it'd be the first such cut since 2000.

That big change would be targeted at families making less than $135,000 per year by making a permanent cut to the lowest income tax rate. The news release says it would benefit 81 percent of all taxpayers.

Here are Minnesota's income tax rates. You pay a smaller percentage on income up to certain amounts, with money you make above those thresholds taxed at higher rates.

The Senate Republicans' plan also includes a tax credit for college graduates paying off loans, a phase-out of Social Security taxes for seniors, plus relief for small businesses and farmers.

Gov. Dayton

The governor's plan includes tax cuts – but at a fraction of the size both the House and Senate Republicans are envisioning.

Dayton in January proposed $300 million in tax cuts, aimed at providing tax relief for working families, and to help lessen the cost of childcare in the state. It would also include property tax cuts for farmers, and bring the state's tax code in line with the federal regulations – a potential boon for middle-class families.

In all, Dayton's office said it would help 450,000 Minnesotans.

Dayton tweaked his overall proposal after last week's budget surplus forecast, but didn't really fiddle with the tax cuts portion.

Why this all matters

All of these tax cuts are part of broader plans to determine the state's budget– something that's done on a two-year cycle by lawmakers, every odd-numbered year.

So the budget the state is currently on was approved in 2015, and lasts through June 30, 2017. The budget lawmakers are grappling with now will kick in July 1, 2017, and be in effect for two years.

Total spending in the budget for fiscal year 2016-17 will come in at $41.816 billion, the state's Management and Budget Office said. The three plans for 2018-19 detailed above come in around $45-$46 billion, give or take.

The three plans right now are just targets – so how much they'd like to spend on each of these areas. How much the state actually ends up spending depends on what House and Senate lawmakers agree on and pass, and Dayton agrees to sign.

And remember, everything is a give and take. So if taxes are cut by $500 million, the state's going to get $500 million less in revenue – which means it can't invest that money in other things, like education or the arts or roads.

But it means people might have more money in their pockets to spend at businesses or on their homes, or whatever else they want.

Lawmakers will now spend the next few weeks hammering out details and moving things forward. Expect more public negotiating and debate between Republican legislators and Dayton.

Next Up

hospital, emergency room

Woman found on side of highway after hit-and-run

The 41-year-old was airlifted to a hospital with life-threatening injuries.

Jorden Nicole Borders

Charges: Minnesota woman tortured her kids, removed boy's blood

Warning: This story contains upsetting content.

first snow

Will narrow band of 6+ inches of snow hit Twin Cities Tuesday?

The NWS says a band of 6+ inches is looking likely. It's now a matter of where.

ambulance

Siblings, ages 19 and 14, killed in crash on icy MN highway

The crash happened around 1:15 a.m. Saturday in Carlton County.

Nicholas Kraus

Man sentenced for fatally striking woman during Uptown protest

Nicholas Kraus, 36, of St. Paul drove into a protest in Uptown last year, killing Deona Marie Knajdek.

Flickr - police lights squad siren - Edward Kimmel

Fleeing suspect crashes into vehicle in Woodbury, 2 injured

The crash occurred Friday afternoon after a pursuit with Woodbury police.

Screen Shot 2022-11-26 at 2.34.44 PM

Yes, that's MN native Jenny Taft in a State Farm commercial

Jenny Taft got her broadcasting career started in Minneapolis in 2011.

crime scene tape - police tape

23-year-old woman critical after shooting in Plymouth

A 23-year-old woman was shot Friday night in Plymouth.

white Christmas

2 MN towns among most 'magical' winter locations in the country

The list was compiled by Trips Discover and published earlier this month.

Screen Shot 2022-11-26 at 8.27.12 AM

St. Olaf football player charged after fatal crash in Chicago

The 18-year-old is accused of speeding and going the wrong way when he crashed into a vehicle that may have been attempting to flee police.

Screen Shot 2022-11-26 at 7.41.18 AM

Woman 34 weeks pregnant injured by drunk driver in Cottage Grove

The 49-year-old suspected of DUI was booked into jail around 1:30 a.m. Saturday.

ambulance

2 dead, 5 injured in Thanksgiving Day crash near Alexandria

The crash involved two people from Alexandria and five from Bloomington.

Related

Gov. Dayton and Republican leaders make no progress on their budget veto fight

They spent more than a day in mediation, but got nowhere on the veto battle.

Minneapolis will try for $15 minimum wage – right after lawmakers moved to block it

The city is starting the new minimum wage process hours after state lawmakers passed a bill to block them from doing just that.

What's in Senate Republicans' health care cost plan – and why Democrats don't like it

It's the first major step to address a problem both parties have acknowledged.

What's in the tax bill agreed by Republican lawmakers?

The House and Senate agreed the bill on Friday.

Republicans propose alternative to Gov. Walz's gas tax plan

They want to cut the tax, and make additional taxation optional.

Update: Help with health insurance costs is on the way

Not in the agreement? A proposal that would have let health insurance that doesn't meet Affordable Care Act requirements be sold in the state.

Frustration with Trump administration brings Dayton and state Republicans together

Both are frustrated with poor communication from the Trump administration over health care funding.

Smoking figures prove a GOP tobacco tax cut a bad idea, Dayton says

Governor Dayton's message to the GOP is as subtle as a Cuban cigar.