Confederate Civil War monuments in a Madison cemetery are being removed

The mayor argued there's a difference between "remembrance of history and reverence of it."
Author:
Updated:
Original:

Calling the Civil War "an act of insurrection and treason and a defense of the deplorable practice of slavery," Madison's mayor has ordered the removal of two Confederate memorials in a city-owned cemetery.

When announcing his decision Thursday, Mayor Paul Soglin said the memorials in Forest Hill Cemetery are "connected" to those actions, "and we do not need them on City property."

The northernmost Confederate cemetery

Confederate Rest, as it's known, is a plot of land within Forest Hill Cemetery where 140 Confederate soldiers are buried. They were among the many Confederate soldiers held prisoner at Camp Randall during the Civil War, the city's website explains

Confederate Rest is referred to as the northernmost Confederate cemetery.

Findagrave.com lists all the soldiers – one was shot by a guard, the other 139 died from disease or injuries. The prisoners held there came from regiments based in Alabama, Arkansas, Louisiana, Mississippi and Tennessee.

The city has allowed volunteers to place Confederate flags there on Memorial Day only, the Wisconsin State Journal reported in 2015.

The monuments being removed

Within Forest Hill there are two monuments dedicated to those soldiers. Both will be removed, Soglin said.

One is a marker labeled as Confederate Rest (you can see a photo here via TripAdvisor), and remembers them as "valiant Confederate soldiers" and "unsung heroes, far from their homes."

That one is already gone. It was taken out Wednesday, Slogin told The Associated Press.

The other is a larger monument listing the names of all the dead soldiers, which Slogin noted "has not garnered as much attention." That one will require some machinery to get out, the AP reported.

Why the mayor made the decision

The monuments – which are owned by the city – "will not erase our shared history," Slogin said, arguing there is a difference between "remembrance of history and reverence of it."

"The Confederacy’s legacy will be with us, whether we memorialize it in marble or not," he said. 

He also emphasized there will be "no disrespect to the dead with the removal of the plaque and stone," and told the AP a proper marker with the soldiers' names will be installed – but without that positive language.

The decision comes after a weekend of violence in Charlottesville, when protesters of a white nationalist demonstration were hit by a car. One person died and 19 others were injured.

The "Unite the Right" rally, which attracted neo-Nazis and Ku Klux Klan members, was organized in part to protest the removal of a statue of Confederate General Robert E. Lee. 

The New York Times reports at least 16 Confederate monuments have been taken down throughout the country in the past week. And there are proposals to remove 18 others.

"In Madison, we join our brothers and sisters around the country to prove that we as a people are able to acknowledge, understand, reconcile, and most importantly, choose a better future for ourselves," Slogin said.

Next Up

Taylor Rogers

Twins Rumors: Taylor Rogers could draw interest despite injury

The left-hander was placed on the injured list on Tuesday.

E7WFMKZUcAIbzNf

Severe storm watch: Apple-sized hail, 75 mph winds possible

A watch has been issued by the National Weather Service.

Screen Shot 2021-07-27 at 7.28.06 PM

Slain Red Lake officer identified as husband, father-of-four

Police say he was shot while responding to a report of a suicidal male who possibly had children the house.

Go Fund Me - Adam Richard Johnson

Remains in Mississippi mark 4th discovery of man's dismembered body parts

Officials on Tuesday confirmed the remains found July 4 are those of Adam Johnson.

Facebook - GoGo dog stolen vehicle -  St. Paul Police Department

Missing dog GoGo found dead in owner's stolen vehicle 3 days later

The vehicle was reported stolen with GoGo inside on July 18

Flickr - face masks covid pole - Ivan Radic

The 14 MN counties with 'substantial or high' COVID-19 transmission

The CDC says everyone in these areas should wear a mask in indoor public places.

Pexels - woman grocery shopping mask covi

CDC: Masks recommended in places with 'substantial or high' transmission

This new guidance applies to everyone, regardless of vaccination status.

Screen Shot 2021-07-27 at 1.10.29 PM

WATCH: Vikings Live with Matthew Coller: Welcome to training camp

Vikings Live with Matthew Coller is a new Vikings show that streams Tuesdays.

YouTube - Minnesota DNR - watering tree

Tips for watering trees during severe drought, sprinkler restrictions

How can you keep your valued trees healthy? Just follow these simple steps.

police tape, crime scene

Minnesota saw record number of murders in 2020, BCA says

The BCA released its annual Uniform Crime Report on Tuesday.

Flickr - Red Lake Nation sign - Ken Lund

Red Lake police officer fatally shot on Tuesday

The officer was reportedly shot near Redby.

Related

Minn. soldier's Civil War grave to be re-dedicated

The grave of a St. Paul solider who died in the Battle of Antietam during the Civil War will be re-dedicated Saturday at at Calvary Cemetery in St. Paul. Pvt. Edmund Sampare of St. Paul died during the battle on Sept. 17, 1862. The re-dedication of the grave will mark the last Civil War remembrance event in Minnesota this year to mark the 150th anniversary of the war.

Family sues after being detained for 10 hours at U.S.-Canada border

The Minnesota couple say they were stopped at gunpoint trying to cross into North Dakota.

World War I monument defaced with graffiti

Police are still looking for the person responsible for vandalizing a Minneapolis landmark honoring more than 550 soldiers that lost their lives during World War One. KARE 11 reports the Victory Memorial Drive granite monument was sprayed with red spray paint Friday night.

'Nah': Supreme Court on maybe reopening the Walker investigation

The "John Doe investigations" date back years, and dove into whether the Walker campaign violated finance laws.

Map Kong was shot and killed by police – now his family is suing

The lawsuit argues officers essentially escalated the situation. A lawyer for the officers say that's untrue.

A look at veterans in Minnesota

There are 369,149 veterans living in Minnesota.