Skip to main content

Conscience wins: Remorseful art thief returns Winona painting


Apparently it's harder to appreciate a work of art when plagued by the knowledge that you stole it.

The Winona Daily News reports a guilt-ridden man contacted police to tell them a stolen portrait of Winona businessman and philanthropist Paul Watkins was in his possession.

The Daily News says the painting – which measures 4 feet by 5 feet and weighs 200 pounds – was sitting in a police department evidence room Wednesday, awaiting a return to its rightful spot in Watkins Manor. It was stolen from the mansion more than two months ago.

Paul Watkins became president of J.R. Watkins Co. in 1911. His uncle's homemade liniment (right) was the foundation of a company that became nationally known for its spices, health remedies, and baking products.

Watkins Manor is now an assisted living center for seniors but the Rochester Post Bulletin reports its great hall is open to the public and functions as a museum of sorts. Portraits of Paul Watkins and his wife Florence had hung opposite each other since the 1920s until a housekeeper discovered Paul's missing one September morning.

The thief's motive?


Police Chief Paul Bostrack told the Daily News investigators are still piecing that together, but it seems to be "a spur-of-the-moment thing."

Winona Radio reported the man who contacted police is "believed to be a college student."

Finally, police described the theft to FOX 9 as a "lapse in judgment due to alcohol."

Police say it will be up to Winona Health whether to press charges in the case.

Paul Watkins' granddaughter, Ruth Watkins Fell, tells the Post Bulletin she's just happy the painting was returned, saying "I'm shocked, first of all, but extremely pleased that they somehow got it back."

Next Up

Gopher Basketball

Michigan State hands Gophers first loss

The 19th ranked Spartans knocked Minnesota from the ranks of the unbeaten.

Karl-Anthony Towns, Chris Finch

Patrick Beverley returns but Jazz rout Timberwolves

The Jazz avenged last season's 0-3 record with a blowout victory.

Eric Kendricks

Vikings-Steelers: 5 things you can count on

After an embarrassing loss to the Lions, can the Vikings get it together?

snow, snowing

Winter storm watch expands north, includes parts of Twin Cities

Everyone in southern Minnesota will want to keep an eye on forecast changes.

Screen Shot 2020-08-14 at 6.45.53 PM

5-year-old boy fatally shot on Thanksgiving identified

Police said a few juveniles at the home were making a social media video when the gun went off.

PAMP travail 1

Pig Ate My Pizza will close at the end of the year.

Its leaders plan to relaunch and "get back to the humble beginnings of Travail."

flickr - criticla care nurses nov 2021

Allina parts ways with 53 of 27,000 employees over vaccine mandate

That's about 0.2% of the health care system's workforce.

US Bank Stadium, Vikings fans

Matthew Coller: How will Vikings fans react on Thursday night?

Will years of disappointment be revealed if the Vikings struggle against the Steelers?

dinner party holidays gathering celebration 1

Health officials encourage getting vaccinated and tested before the holidays

The state has launched a "Celebrate Safely, Minnesota" campaign to make it easier to get tested and vaccinated.

Kjellberg booking photo crop

Charges: Parking dispute, scuffle preceded fatal stabbing

The suspect said he was upset about neighbors and their friends regularly parking on his property.

Dave Hutchinson

Hennepin Co. Sheriff injured in rollover, admits to drinking beforehand

The sheriff, in a statement, called it an "inexcusable decision."

CDC - vaccine band aid

COVID cases, hospitalizations, and deaths in MN dominated by unvaccinated

The latest figures from October show a disproportionate number of deaths among the unvaccinated.