Conscience wins: Remorseful art thief returns Winona painting


Apparently it's harder to appreciate a work of art when plagued by the knowledge that you stole it.

The Winona Daily News reports a guilt-ridden man contacted police to tell them a stolen portrait of Winona businessman and philanthropist Paul Watkins was in his possession.

The Daily News says the painting – which measures 4 feet by 5 feet and weighs 200 pounds – was sitting in a police department evidence room Wednesday, awaiting a return to its rightful spot in Watkins Manor. It was stolen from the mansion more than two months ago.

Paul Watkins became president of J.R. Watkins Co. in 1911. His uncle's homemade liniment (right) was the foundation of a company that became nationally known for its spices, health remedies, and baking products.

Watkins Manor is now an assisted living center for seniors but the Rochester Post Bulletin reports its great hall is open to the public and functions as a museum of sorts. Portraits of Paul Watkins and his wife Florence had hung opposite each other since the 1920s until a housekeeper discovered Paul's missing one September morning.

The thief's motive?


Police Chief Paul Bostrack told the Daily News investigators are still piecing that together, but it seems to be "a spur-of-the-moment thing."

Winona Radio reported the man who contacted police is "believed to be a college student."

Finally, police described the theft to FOX 9 as a "lapse in judgment due to alcohol."

Police say it will be up to Winona Health whether to press charges in the case.

Paul Watkins' granddaughter, Ruth Watkins Fell, tells the Post Bulletin she's just happy the painting was returned, saying "I'm shocked, first of all, but extremely pleased that they somehow got it back."

Next Up

minneapolis police

Police arrest man in connection to deadly Minneapolis hit-and-run

The victim died the scene in north Minneapolis on Friday.

Jordan Greenway

Wild's fast start vanishes in loss to Coyotes

Arizona scored five unanswered goals in a 5-2 loss.

Screen Shot 2021-03-06 at 4.12.00 PM

Police seeking tips in search for road rage shooting suspect

The incident took place in Maplewood last week.

Paige Bueckers

Paige Bueckers lands on Wooden Award list for women's college basketball

The Hopkins grad is the only freshman on the 15-player ballot.

Jamal Mashburn Jr.

Gophers fall under .500 after OT loss to Rutgers

The Gophers are under .500 for the first time this season.

police tape, crime scene

Man arrested for killing of his father in Wabasha County

The 73-year-old man was found dead at a home in rural Zumbro Falls.

Jake Odorizzi

Report: Jake Odorizzi to sign with Astros

The former Twins pitcher is headed to Houston on a two-year deal.

covid-19, coronavirus

South African COVID-19 variant detected in Wisconsin

There have been no cases of the South African strain found in Minnesota.

Brian Dutcher

Could Brian Dutcher be Gophers target to replace Richard Pitino?

Dutcher's contract has a buyout clause that could lead him to Minnesota.