Skip to main content

Cop killer Brian Fitch appeals to Supreme Court over conviction

  • Author:
  • Updated:

Brian Fitch, the man convicted of murdering Mendota Heights cop Scott Patrick, is the subject of an appeal in the Minnesota Supreme Court.

The Forum News Services reports the court has been hearing oral arguments from the 41-year-old's lawyers objecting to the way his trial was handled.

The main point of argument is that Fitch was tried and convicted of two crimes together – the killing of Officer Patrick and a shootout with the cops who tracked him down – which they argue should have been handled as two separate cases.

If the court finds in Fitch's favor, it could mean he has the right to new trials.

According to FOX 9, the Supreme Court is not likely to make a decision for several months, and Dakota County Attorney Jim Backstrom is adamant his conviction should stand.

"We believe we tried him in accordance with the constitutional rights he has in this state," he told the TV station. "He was convicted, he got a fair trial, and he got the penalty he deserves."

Fitch was sentenced to life without parole after being convicted of the first-degree murder of Officer Patrick, who he killed during a traffic stop in West St. Paul in July 2014, and three counts each of attempted murder and assault following the shootout with officers, WCCO notes.

The Forum News Services says these events were separated by eight hours, five miles and a county line, hence the appeal from Fitch's attorneys.

Next Up

raiaing canes brooklyn park crop

After 3-month delay, newest Twin Cities Raising Cane's opens

The restaurant was originally scheduled to open in October.

st anthony armed robbery screengrab

Armed man robs Twin Cities thrift store, flees in carjacked pickup

He pulled out a handgun shortly after chatting with the cashier about his scarf.

red wing 6

Gallery: Pagoda-inspired home on Lake Pepin for sale for $2M

The home has 425 feet of private shoreline on the Mississippi River.

Walz, Flanagan

Walz proposes legalizing marijuana in massive supplemental budget

It's among the provisions in his "Budget to Move Minnesota Forward."

Plow 2 (1)

Photos reveal damage from gunshots to Minneapolis snowplow

A hydraulic line and three tires were damaged in the shooting.

unsplash - school classroom students

Minneapolis schools confirm return to in-person teaching Monday

The school district shifted to online learning almost two weeks ago as rising COVID cases led to staff and bus driver shortages.

Flickr - Superior National Forest Boundary Waters

Mineral leases for proposed Twin Metals mine near Boundary Waters canceled

A review by the DOI found "significant legal deficiencies" with the leases' 2019 renewal.


Reward to find person who left kittens to die in freezing WI cold

The cats were thrown from a vehicle, according to a witness.

metro mobility bus

Charges: Man led police on multi-city pursuit in stolen Metro Mobility bus

The bus had been left unattended with the keys inside when it was stolen.

Bell Ramsey Co. Jan 22 - crop

Charges: Man fatally shot mother of his child during argument

Officers found her on the ground outside the couple's home.


Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Wednesday, January 26

More than 15,000 new cases in today's update.