Skip to main content

Court agrees with Betsy Hodges; tosses out lawsuit over Mpls. budget

Mpls. mayor didn't miss deadline, court rules

A judge has rejected a lawsuit claiming Minneapolis Mayor Betsy Hodges broke the law by missing an August 15 budget deadline. 

Thursday's ruling by Judge Mary Vasaly (read it here) says even though Hodges only turned in the broad outline of her 2018 budget plan by the 15th, that was enough to meet what's required in the city charter.

This month's suit was filed by Carol Becker. She's on the board that will have to set Minneapolis' maximum tax levy by the end of September. 

The argument

In the letter she gave to the city council on August 15, Hodges acknowledged she was not giving them a complete budget proposal. What she did provide was an estimate of total revenue and expenses in the $1.4 billion budget plan, saying the details for each city department would come in September. 

The mayor said she was providing only an outline on the 15th because she'd been attending to other things that popped up unexpectedly in July – especially the police shooting of Justine Damond and the deadly explosion at Minnehaha Academy. 

Becker argued Hodges had violated the charter by missing the budget deadline and wanted the judge to order the mayor to deliver a complete budget proposal ASAP.

What the judge said

The judge noted in her ruling there have been other times when the mayor delivered a slimmed-down budget document in August with the complete plan coming in September. 

Former Mayor R.T. Rybak did it that way in 2007 after the 35W bridge collapse and again in 2011 when there was a state government shutdown and a tornado hit Minneapolis. 

Judge Vasaly said Hodges met the city requirement by turning in a budget document on the 15th. The ruling says it's up to the mayor to decide how detailed that document will be. 

Hodges said in a statement she's glad the lawsuit is over, calling it frivolous and a "politically motivated election year stunt." 

The mayor says she's sticking with her plan to deliver a budget address on September 12

Next Up

hospital, emergency room

Driver, 15 years old, hurt when car collides with SUV

The road was wet at the time, the State Patrol said.

Tyler Wahl

Minnesotans have the Badgers back in the national spotlight

Three of Wisconsin's four leading scorers are from Minnesota.

Francisco Liriano

Liriano retires: Remembering his meteoric rise as a rookie

There was no one better than Liriano from mid-May to late-July in 2006.

kimmel morari screengrab collage

Watch: Jimmy Kimmel mocks men's sex aid made by MN company

"This is an app I won't be [down]loading," Kimmel said.

Screen Shot 2022-01-17 at 8.58.56 AM

Man hospitalized after snowmobile crash in Stearns County

The crash occurred east of State Highway 238 in Albany Township.


Indicators of COVID in wastewater skyrocketing in Twin Cities

Wastewater detection can serve as a predictor for rising and falling case levels.

Flickr - police lights squad siren - Edward Kimmel

Girl arrested for allegedly shooting her mother in northern MN

The incident occurred in Morcom Township Sunday afternoon.

voyageurs trail camera

Video: Voyageurs camera captures remarkable footage of wildlife trail

There were wolves, moose, bears, lynx, a fisher, marten and other animals.


Report: A bunch of campaign staffers have quit on Mayor Betsy Hodges

The news comes just a few weeks before Election Day.

Mayor Betsy Hodges gets this week to lay out a full budget – or explain why she hasn't yet

Betsy Hodges is being sued by a tax official for missing a deadline.

Betsy Hodges' next move? Harvard's Institute of Politics

Here's what she'll be doing at the university's Institute of Politics.

hodges-tweet-frey-1-SQUARE CROP

Hodges accuses Frey of falsely claiming she supports 'strong mayor' amendment

"Please know that if you have been told this, it is a lie: I have no position on the amendment," Hodges tweeted.

The movie that 'literally' saved Betsy Hodges' life

The former mayor says it got her through some very dark times in her childhood.