Court: Minnesota cops need warrant before DWI urine tests

Author:
Updated:
Original:

In a followup to an October decision that changes the way police officers enforce drunk driving laws, the Minnesota Court of Appeals on Monday ruled that warrantless urine tests are unconstitutional.

According to KSTP, the case started with the DWI arrest of Owatonna resident Ryan Thompson in 2012; he refused to take either a blood or a urine test and was charged with a count of second-degree test-refusal (on top of impaired driving charges).

The refusal charge stuck, even after the other charges against him were dropped, the station says.

Monday's decision reverses his conviction and clarifies that penalizing suspects for refusing such tests is not constitutional, the Associated Press notes.

This comes just a couple of months after the Minnesota Court of Appeals ruled in a similar case that it is not a crime for a DWI suspect to refuse a warrantless blood test. Criminal charges for such refusals are now also unconstitutional in the state.

But what about breathalyzer tests? You can still be charged for refusing to take one if you're being arrested for impaired driving in Minnesota, per an appeals court ruling from early 2015. This seems to conflict with a 2013 U.S. Supreme Court decision which said police "generally" need a warrant to test the driver if he or she has refused to participate.

But warrantless breathalyzers are still legal under Minnesota's "implied consent" law, which states residents "consent" to such tests when they obtain a driver's license.

So why does Minnesota draw the line at blood and urine?

In the October decision which made warrantless blood tests unconstitutional, Minnesota appellate Judge Jill Flaskamp Halbrooks noted that such tests represent a “serious intrusion into the human body.”

Next Up

Screen Shot 2020-04-17 at 2.58.26 PM

Walz gives vaccine providers 3-day, 7-day deadlines to use doses

Those that don't use their allocation will be given less in the future.

purse

Border officers seize more than $550K in counterfeit designer goods

The shipments of fake goods were seized on Jan. 22.

Landfill plastic bags

4 Twin Cities landfills seek to expand capacity

This comes as the area's waste-to-energy facilities are operating at capacity.

Marcus Carr

3 of 10 finalists for NCAA's top point guard award have MN ties

Not a bad way to represent the State of... Basketball?

Justice, court

Minnesota grants unconditional pardon to grandmother facing deportation

Gov. Tim Walz says it's the first full pardon granted by the state in 35 years.

covid-19, vaccine

Minnesota changes vaccine appointment process, here's what to know

Walz also announced plans for a mass vaccination event at Xcel Energy Center.

covid-19, coronavirus

Here is Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Monday, Jan. 25

The latest figures from MDH have been released.

covid-19, vaccine

Minnesota health leaders say state's vaccine progress better than figures suggest

Minnesota is lagging behind national vaccination rates, but MDH leaders say this is because it's holding 2nd doses in reserve.

target store

Target announces bonuses ranging from $500-$2,000 for 375,000 workers

The bonuses are being provided following a booming holiday sales season.

dale olsen go fund me

Curling community rallies behind man who was shot in Minneapolis

Dale Olsen was shot in an apparent attempted robbery.

Related