Skip to main content

DNA, fingerprint evidence leads to arrest of Minnesota man in Texas cold case


DNA and fingerprint evidence led to the arrest of a Minnesota man in connection with a 31-year-old fatal stabbing long considered a cold case.

Robert A. Otteson was taken into custody at his Lakeville home Monday by authorities from both Minnesota and Texas – the state in which he's accused of stabbing a man 35 times in a hotel room in 1983, according to the Minnesota criminal complaint.

The 53-year-old Otteson appeared in Dakota County court Thursday. WCCO reports he will not fight extradition to Texas, where he was indicted by a grand jury last week.

FOX 9 reported the man had been living in the metro suburb with his wife and children since the 1990s.

Otteson's attorney told the Star Tribune the family is in "a really difficult situation," describing Otteson's wife as "gobsmacked" and requesting privacy.

Otteson was described by nearby residents as a good neighbor, the Star Tribune adds.

According to the Pioneer Press, he works as a mechanic for Xcel Energy, and doesn't have a significant criminal history – just traffic citations.

Authorities in Denton County, Texas – just outside of Dallas – have 10 days to collect him, FOX 9 reports.

Blood, fingerprint evidence credited for breakthrough

Francisco Narvaez, 42, (pictured above) was stabbed to death in a motel room in Denton on Sept. 30, 1983, Oklahoma’s NewsOn6 reported. According to the criminal complaint, he was struck 35 times, in the chest, neck, face, hands and back. The suspect then fled in Narvaez's car.

The station said the vehicle was later found northeast of Oklahoma City. A police sketch, seen above, was issued at the time.

The San Antonio businessman's murder was long considered a cold case. The Denton Police Department investigated Narvaez’s death when it happened, “but as time went on the tips and leads went cold,” the department said in a statement Wednesday.

But a new lieutenant and new technology changed things.

According to the criminal complaint:

Blood samples and other evidence were obtained from the murder scene when it happened, as were fingerprints.

In 2010, a Denton County lieutenant was assigned to the case. He obtained the stored evidence and brought it to the North Texas Health Science Lab in Fort Worth for testing. A year later, the lab notified authorities they discovered two profiles in the evidence, which included a blood stain located in the shower of the crime scene: one was the victim, the other an unidentified male.

In 2013, "recent enhancements" led the lab to match fingerprints at the scene with Otteson.

Evidence was taken from garbage at Otteson's home, and his DNA profile was found to be a "major contributor" to nail clippings and blood stains found at the crime scene.

Otteson was indicted on Aug. 7, and a warrant was issued for his arrest. Denton County authorities say they will extradite him.

Next Up

police lights

Two St. Cloud area schools locked down as a 'precaution'

The move was precautionary, authorities stressed.

Brian O'Neill

Matthew Coller: What if the Vikings didn't have Detroit?

The Lions have been like two freebies on the Vikings' schedule the past three seasons.

water drain

MN will get $116M for water projects as part of infrastructure package

Nationwide, $7.4 billion will be distributed for projects next year.


3rd teenage death from COVID-19 reported in Minnesota

All three of the teenage deaths have occurred in the past three months.

crowne plaza hotel minneapolis mn

Former downtown Minneapolis Crowne Plaza to become boutique hotel

The hotel closed at the start of the COVID-19 pandemic and never reopened.

covid-19, coronavirus

Minnesota's COVID-19 update for Friday, December 3

The latest from the health department. The next update comes Monday.

Flickr - police lights squad siren - Edward Kimmel

Man who threatened suicide by cop detained, hospitalized

Officers responded to the incident at around 1:40 a.m. Friday.

northbound remodel facebook

Northbound brewpub reopens with new look, revamped menu

It had been closed since October for the big remodel.

Snow, Hanley Falls

Latest storm track, snow forecast for weekend winter storm

The National Weather Service has issued a winter storm watch.


DNA links man to 1993 cold case

Billy Diamond Bailey has been linked to the 1993 murder case through a DNA sample. Bailey is currently incarcerated in a federal prison for another crime. After that, he will serve time for yet another murder in 1984 before serving any possible time for the 1993 case.