Duluth schools removes 2 American classics from required reading due to racial slurs

The Duluth chapter of the NAACP called it a move that was long overdue.

What's happening?

Beginning next school year, high school students in the Duluth school district will no longer be required to read Harper Lee's "To Kill a Mockingbird" and Mark Twain's "The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn." 

Both books, long part of the district's mandatory curriculum, are being removed as required reading due to their use of racial slurs.

The literature will still be available in school libraries as optional reading material. 

Why remove them from required reading?

"Both of these novels make regular use of racial slurs, and we've heard concerns over time from students and community members about the use of these two novels as required reading," Duluth school district's communications coordinator Kathleen Kaufman said in an email to GoMN. 

"While we believe it's important to address race and its impact on society and our community, subjecting students to racial slurs as part of required curriculum is not the approach that we support. As a result, we are planning to find alternatives to these novels for use as required reading."

It's unclear yet what literature the district will insert into its curriculum.

According to the Duluth News Tribune, it's a welcome, but long overdue decision, for the Duluth chapter of the NAACP. 

Chapter president Stephan Witherspoon told the newspaper that while some think the novels are educational literature for students, he says they are "just hurtful" and use "hurtful language that has oppressed the people for over 200 years."

This has happened before

Controversies over one or both of these books rear their heads every few years.

The Washington Post covered a similar attempt to remove the books from the curriculum at a school in Mississippi last October, noting that "Mockingbird" has about 50 references to the n-word while "The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn" displays the n-word more than 200 times. 

Both books are no stranger to controversy. According to the American Literary Association (ACA), Huck Finn was 14th and To Kill a Mockingbird 21st on the most "banned and challenged books" list between 2000 and 2009.

The "Harry Potter" series was first.

Previous efforts to pull the books from school curriculums have led to complaints of censorship, while groups such as Facing History has compiled guidelines on how to discuss sensitively the racial and sexual assault themes in the classroom.

Duluth East, Denfeld, and Academic Excellence Online are the high schools in the Duluth school district.

Next Up


Un-Fair Campaign's anti-racism billboard in Duluth defaced with racial slur

A racial slur has marred an anti-racism billboard by the controversial Un-Fair Campaign in Duluth. The billboard, which reads, "Racism: Ignore it and it won’t go away," was defaced with a painting of the Confederate flag -- along with what is considered a variation of the N-word, says Claudie Washington, president of the local chapter of the NAACP.

Duluth NAACP calls Obama effigy terroristic threat

The Duluth chapter of the NAACP says an effigy of President Barack Obama hung from an electronic billboard should be prosecuted as a "terroristic threat," the News Tribune reports. Police cut down the effigy after residents reported it on Election Day. The scarecrow had a mask of Obama and a noose around its neck.

Duluth teen pulled from water near 'the cribs'

A 13-year-old Duluth who was underwater in Lake Superior for more than 30 minutes was clinging to life in a Duluth hospital late Monday after being rescued just off shore. Jeffrey Carlos Watson Jr. had been swimming with friends near an old concrete structure often called the cribs, or Uncle Harvey’s Mausoleum, just off Duluth’s Lakewalk waterfront trail. The “mausoleum” is a popular spot for teens on warm days. They climb the structure and then jump into Lake Superior.

Duluth schools lay off 29 more teachers

The Duluth School Board voted to cut 29 additional full and part-time teachers to help close a $3.8 million budget gap. Another six teachers were laid off last month. In addition to the cuts, the News Tribune reports 31 teachers retired this year. Some of those positions will be filled.