Families of men killed in crash win $8.5M in case against methadone clinic


The families of two men will get an $8.5 million payout from the clinic and doctor who prescribed the methadone to the driver who caused their deaths.

In what KBJR says is a "precedent-setting case,"the families of Mitchell Lengren and Zachary Gamache reached an agreement with Pinnacle Recovery Services of Brainerd and Dr. John Stroemer last week.

It follows a civil lawsuit stemming from an October 2012 crash: The pair died after a car driven by Vanessa Brigan crossed the center line and struck their vehicle on Highway 210 in Carlton County, the Moose Lake Star Gazette reported.

It emerged that Brigan, who is serving six years in prison for vehicular homicide, was under the influence of methadone at the time, and it had been prescribed by Dr. Stroemer at the Brainerd clinic.

According to FOX 21, Pinnacle is liable for $5.7 million of the damages and Dr. Stroemer $2.8 million, after they both allowed a judgement to be entered against them in St. Louis County finding them negligent.

KBJR says that as part of the agreement, the families will only attempt to collect judgement money from insurers.

It's thought to be the first successful case in Minnesota where the claim is that members of the public were harmed due to improper treatment given to a patient, FOX 21 notes.

The Lingren family will get 75 percent of the settlement since Lingren left behind a wife and kids.

The Star Tribune reported last year the lawsuit contended that Dr. Stroemer's methadone clinic should have known Brigan was abusing the drug because of needle marks on her arm, and should have stopped her driving the 100 miles home to Cloquet prior to the fatal crash.

The doctor was reprimanded by the Minnesota Board of Medicine in January 2015 after finding he prescribed excessive amounts of controlled substances without assessing the risks to patients, the newspaper notes.

Methadone is one of the chemical treatments for heroin addiction, but is itself addictive and can be abused by addicts, the National Institute on Drug Abuse says.

Next Up

Screen Shot 2019-10-14 at 10.38.01 PM

Worthington settles police brutality lawsuit for $590,000, agrees to reforms

The lawsuit was filed on behalf of Kelvin Francisco Rodriguez, who spent five days in the ICU after being arrested.

Michael Munoz

Rochester superintendent admits he plagiarized letter to staff

Med City Beat broke the story, prompting the superintendent to apologize.

police tape, crime scene

Man and woman, aged 55 and 62, found dead in their home

The St. Louis County Sheriff's Office is investigating.

Gov. Tim Walz

Walz: COVID-19 guidance for Christmas likely to be similar to Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving featured a ban on social gatherings with non-household members.


Mall of America is offering a virtual Santa experience this year

People can virtually tour Santa's Candy Cane Institute.

PD Shimmers 4

Annual guide to finding holiday lights displays in MN is released

More than 80 holiday displays are on this year's list.

duluth police department

Duluth police officer charged in September shooting

The officer, who is a five-year veteran, is charged with two felonies.

Screen Shot 2020-11-30 at 1.31.42 PM

Enbridge gets final approval to start construction on Line 3 replacement

The project has attracted criticism from environmental and tribal groups.

Kirk Cousins

Is it a 4-team race for the final NFC playoff spot?

The key for Minnesota likely requires winning on the road against two top NFC teams.


Duluth methadone clinic getting shut down by state

The Lake Superior Treatment Center uses methadone to treat opiate addictions. A Human Services Department inspection last month found health and safety violations discovered in March had not been corrected. An official with the company that runs the for-profit clinic predicts its clients will die, overdose, or go to jail.

Accrediting agency gave Duluth methadone clinic positive marks

Three months before the Minnesota Department of Human Services recommended a methadone clinic in Duluth be shut down, a nonprofit accrediting agency said the Lake Superior Treatment Center "met or exceeded standards in many areas," the Duluth News Tribune. However, state investigators inspected the clinic in early August and found 56 violations of standards.

Family, friends honor Minnesotans killed in Kansas crash

Five members of the Kerber family from Jordan were killed on April 1 when their motor home veered off a Kansas road. The family requested privacy at the weekend service, which was held in Shakopee.

Felony charges filed against teen in Mayo Clinic pipe bomb case

A 17-year-old St. Charles boy is charged with possession of an incendiary/explosive device and discharge of a firearm or dangerous weapon endangering public safety, Winona Daily News reports. The teen is accused of making a pipe bomb that was discovered in his mother's trunk last week while he was a patient at the hospital in Rochester. Authorities say the 3-foot-long device weighed about 50 pounds with gunpowder and fireworks.

Two Mayo Clinic workers killed in Florida helicopter crash

The Federal Aviation Administration and the National Transportation Safety Board are investigating a helicopter crash that killed two Mayo Clinic employees in Florida. The Star Tribune reports the two Jacksonville hospital employees were flying to the University of Florida Monday to retrieve organs. A spokeswoman with the FAA says neither the employees nor the pilot survived after crashing northeast of Palatka, Florida.