Skip to main content

Fargo cop won't be charged for shooting a man armed with a BB gun

  • Author:
  • Updated:

The Fargo police officer who shot and wounded a man brandishing a BB gun last month will not be charged in the incident.

After review of the case – which started on Sept. 28 with a late-night car chase and ended with the 31-year-old suspect's shooting – Cass County State's Attorney Birch Burdick has declared Officer Patrick Scott "justified" in his actions, according to the Forum.

After the incident, police said that Patrick had chased Karmen Redshirt – who was on foot at that point – down to a Pizza Hut parking lot, where Karmen is accused of “circling” the officer around his squad car with “what appeared to be a real gun with a laser pointer.”

When the suspect pointed the weapon at Patrick, police noted, the officer fired his gun. The suspect's firearm turned to be a realistic-looking pellet gun.

The incident prompted an investigation, and Patrick was placed on leave per usual policy. It later came out that he had been involved in a prior shooting at his previous police job at North Dakota State University.

According to the Associated Press, he "accidentally shot himself in the arm" in an off-campus apartment about two years ago. He was off duty at the time.

It's not clear what the circumstances of that shooting were, but the news service says Patrick quit the campus police department after the incident.

Meanwhile, Redshirt has since been released from the hospital and charged with terrorizing and refusing police orders, among other crimes, KFGO reports.

The station notes Redshirt had a blood-alcohol level of more than .27 at the time of his confrontation with Patrick. The legal limit in North Dakota for people driving cars – which Redshirt was doing the night of the shooting – is .04.

Next Up


Charges: Minnesota elementary school teacher sexually assaulted 3 boys

The incidents were captured on video taken inside an elementary school classroom.

Police tape

Person shot by police in St. Paul Monday evening

It happened around 6:10 p.m. on the city's East Side.

Kollie Jr.

Woman killed in Moorhead identified as suspect's mother

An appeal has been issued to find the suspect's vehicle, which remains missing.


Ticket details released for 5-week run of 'Hamilton' in Minneapolis

The tour of the production has been delayed twice due to the pandemic.


Minnesota Board of Pharmacy files lawsuit against 3 THC edible retailers

The board has received 46 complaints in the past four months regarding the products.

Screen Shot 2022-12-05 at 2.53.55 PM

ATF now investigating fire at Lyndale Avenue apartment building

It was the second fire at a vacant building owned by the same landlord that was being used by squatters in the past few months.


Let the good times roll

Minnesota Roller Derby is back!


Beloved restaurant in southeastern MN to close after 40 years

A final night of celebrations is scheduled for Dec. 17.


MN town shelves ordinance allowing residents to sue abortion providers

Attorney General Keith Ellison advised the town to not go forward with the ordinance.

Spring Street Tavern

Man shot dead inside Minneapolis tavern is identified

The suspect is being held on probable cause murder.