Faribault man charged with killing Ohio woman indicted on first-degree murder


A Faribault man who was charged with killing an Ohio woman he met online has been indicted on first-degree murder.

Jason Robert Nisbit, 39, was charged with second-degree murder last month, accused of killing 26-year-old Chelsea Elizabeth Martinez on Aug. 1.

And on Wednesday, a grand jury indicted him on first-degree intentional premeditated murder, the criminal complaint says. He also still faces the second-degree murder charge.

If convicted on the elevated charge, Nisbit could face life in prison. (In Minnesota, any crimes that carry a potential life sentence must be brought by a grand jury through an indictment.)

Rice County Attorney John Fossum told the Faribault Daily News says he was pleased with the indictment.

According to the criminal complaint, Martinez traveled to Minnesota from Columbus, Ohio, to meet Nisbit after the two had connected online.

After meeting at a local motel, they agreed to meet again at Shager Park, west of Faribault, the morning of Aug. 1. That's when they walked to a wooded area and Nisbit, using items he brought with him in a backpack, tied Martinez's hands and feet, strangled her with a paracord until she lost consciousness, and then used a knife to cut her throat, charges say.

When law enforcement questioned Nisbit, he admitted to killing her and led police to where he put her body, charges note.

Nisbit was arraigned on the first-degree murder charge Thursday and was held on $1 million bail, KSTP says.

He remains in Rice County Jail. He is expected to make his next court appearance in late October, the Faribault Daily News says.

Next Up

betty danger's

Betty Danger's reopens with new Orwellian theme

Betty Danger's Country Club is now Betty Danger's Animal Farm.

Kevin Fiala

Minnesota Wild have 3 possible playoff scenarios

Colorado controls its destiny, and that plays a big role in Minnesota's fate.

Screen Shot 2021-05-11 at 7.54.49 AM

Minnesotans arrested after 100 mph police chase in Nebraska

The pair were arrested for driving and drug offenses.

orono high school

Swastika painted on rock at Orono High School

The rock was repainted "within minutes," the superintendent said.

covid, vaccine

Walz: COVID-19 vaccines for young teens expected to open this week

Gov. Walz said parents should be able to make appointments for their kids later this week.

Both Gach

Report: Both Gach becomes 10th Gopher to enter transfer portal

Head coach Ben Johnson will have an entirely new roster next season.

Wikimedia Commons - COVID vaccine, pfizer, shot - Martin G

FDA authorizes Pfizer COVID vaccine for young teens

None of the trial participants that received the vaccine were diagnosed with the virus.

flickr - shopping basket covid

Secret shoppers rate the most COVID-safe stores

Two of Minnesota's largest companies topped the list.

Minneapolis police

Woman found shot dead in Minneapolis parking ramp identified

Police have arrested two suspects in connection with the incident.

ambulance, crash

Victims of triple-fatal Maple Grove crash ID'd as woman, 2 toddlers

The single-vehicle crash happened just before 7 a.m. Saturday, May 8.

Ray McNeary

Charges: St. Cloud bank robber wanted to 'go viral,' become 'a martyr'

Police were in a standoff with him at the Wells Fargo bank for more than 8 hours.

MSU-Mankato hockey, Minnesota State, Mavericks

Minnesota State to host St. Thomas at Hockey Day Minnesota 2022

The newly-formed CCHA will have a marquee matchup in its inaugural season