Flipped off the ballot: Coin toss settles Rosemount city council primary


Democracy was in action at Rosemount City Hall Friday. And it came up tails.

After Tuesday night's primary ballot count showed two city council candidates with identical vote totals, a coin flip settled which of them would move on to the November election, Sun Thisweek reports.

The outcome was a victory for Alba Nowlin (seen at right). But the candidate who had heads, Jamal Abdulahi, has five days to request a recount of the primary result.

Two seats on the city council are up for election in November, meaning the top four finishers in the primary would move on. Nowlin and Abdulahi finished tied for fourth in the results that council members certified Friday morning.

Dakota County's manager of elections told the Pioneer Press this week that Minnesota law calls for breaking a tie by using a random method.

Rosemount Town Pages reports Mayor Bill Droste handled the coin flip and assigned the sides of the coin to the candidates in alphabetical order – heads to Abdulahi, tails to Nowlin. Town Pages says Droste let the coin fall to the floor, both candidates saw that it landed tails up, and Abdulahi shook Nowlin's hand, Town Pages says.

Abdulahi had no comment for the newspaper on whether he would seek a recount, which would be paid for with city funds.

Coin flips

A political campaign decided by a coin flip?

"It's not as rare as you might think," elections manager Andy Lokken told the Pioneer Press.

Since the state law says a tie vote shall be settled "by lot," Rosemount could have opted to draw a name from a hat or cards from a deck. But the coin is an experienced arbiter of tied political contests.

A couple of years ago an article in the Atlantic listed nine states where ties were settled by coins (Minnesota was already on the that list). South Dakota and Arizona had used cards and Virginia went with the hat, the magazine says.

Next Up


Women killed in ATV crash in Paul Bunyan State Forest

She wasn't wearing a helmet and alcohol was involved, officials say.


As golf season approaches, book your round now at Dacotah Ridge GC

The stunning course is designed by world-renowned architect Rees Jones.


Aggressive police response on third night of Daunte Wright protests

Law enforcement used armored vehicles, tear gas, and fired rubber bullets, but say officers were targeted with bricks and other projectiles.

st. paul police homicide april 13 2021

Woman found suffering from 'fatal wound' in St. Paul apartment

Her death marks the 10th homicide in the city this year.

Screen Shot 2021-04-14 at 6.40.37 AM

15-vehicle pileup closes Hwy. 169 near Maple Grove

The incident happened shortly before 5 a.m.

Grand casino

Grand Casino celebrates 30th anniversary with more than cake

Hundreds of thousands of winning dollars are on the table.

Brodd defense witness

As defense starts, expert argues Chauvin's use of force was reasonable

Use-of-force expert Barry Brodd testified on behalf of the defense.

Chet Holmgren

Chet Holmgren named Minnesota's Mr. Basketball

Minnehaha Academy produces back-to-back award winners for the second time in state history.

Byron Buxton

Red Sox out-slug Twins in chilly matinee

Bobby Dalbec hit two RBI doubles to hand the Twins their third straight loss.


Watch: Coin flip decides MN council race that ended in a tie

The Maplewood City Council race might go to a recount.