Former Wisconsin deputy found not guilty in killing of MN wife, sister-in-law


A former Wisconsin deputy, charged last year with killing his wife and sister-in-law, was found not guilty due to a mental disease or defect, multiple outlets report.

The Chippewa Daily Herald reports the jury decided early Thursday morning Andrew Steele was not legally responsible for the shooting death of Ashley Steele and Kacee Tollefsbol.

Ashley Steele (Andrew Steele's wife) and her sister, Tollefsbol, were both from Lake Elmo, Minnesota. They were killed at Steele’s home in Fitchburg, Wisconsin, where Ashley lived at the time.

Andrew Steele admitted he killed the women, WKOW reports.

This embed is invalid

But during the trial, the defense team argued the 40-year-old suffered from a major brain disorder at the time of their deaths, caused by his battle with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), the Wisconsin State Journal reports.

Two experts, a psychologist and a neurologist, testified that Steele's behavior leading up to and after the womens' deaths were not indicative of an ongoing, progressive mental disease, the State Journal reported, and even showed some amount of planning.

The jury sided with the defense, in essence agreeing that the mental disease kept Steele from understanding he was breaking the law at the time.

Following the verdict, Andrew Steele's attorney said she believes the decision sets a precedent that "we need to take brain damage seriously," WKOW reports.

The Wisconsin Department of Health Services will now conduct an investigation, and the judge from the trial will decide whether Steele can be released back into the public, or if he needs care at an institution, the Chippewa Daily Herald says.

Next Up

Kyle Rudolph

Watch: Vikings create tribute video for Kyle Rudolph

Rudolph's 10-year tenure with the Vikings ended when he was released on Tuesday.

Zach Parise

Wild scratch Zach Parise for Wednesday's game vs. Vegas

Parise will be a healthy scratch for the second time in his 16-year career.

shawn myers 1

Charges: Windham hospital patient threatened to kill staff, spit on them

Shawn Myers is charged with felony terroristic threats.

kaplans tiktok

Minnesota grandparents go viral for 'distancing duo' songs on TikTok

Their most recent duet about getting their second dose of the COVID-19 vaccine has gotten more than 67,000 likes.

CHS Field

Start of St. Paul Saints season delayed to May

Major League Baseball says it's being 'prudent' in delaying the minor league season.

caribou beyond meat sandwich

Caribou Coffee is the latest to add plant-based meat to its menu

The plant-based protein market is exploding, expected to reach $74.2 billion in the next six years.

One-dollar bill, cash, money

Former MN bank CEO sentenced to 18 months in prison for falsifying records

Robert Hager was the CEO of Border State Bank in Northern Minnesota.


As golf season approaches, book your round now at Dacotah Ridge GC

The stunning course is designed by world-renowned architect Rees Jones.