Free to speak? Protesters shout down Israeli academic at U of M, rekindle debate


Protesters who disrupted a speech at the University of Minnesota this week also revived a campus debate about freedom of expression.

Moshe Halbertal, a law professor at both Hebrew University in Jerusalem and at New York University, was invited to deliver a lecture Tuesday at the U of M law school's Mondale Hall.

Demonstrators with groups including Students for Justice in Palestine and the Anti-War Committee disrupted Halbertal's speech, the Minnesota Daily reports. One member of the Anti-War Committee told the Daily the university should not have hired a speaker with Halbertal's views on war crimes and civilian casualties.

The Star Tribune reports that after 30 minutes of delays – and the arrests of three protesters – Halbertal proceeded with his speech.

The disruption prompted a U of M professor of civil rights law who was at the lecture to post a commentary on a Washington Post blog. Dale Carpenter writes, in part:

"That the freedom to present a lecture is threatened in this way at a public university is appalling, calling not only for punishment of violations but for a clear statement by university officials defending the free exchange of ideas."

A university spokesman tells the Star Tribune the three people arrested and cited for trespassing were not students.

They missed a speech that Carpenter describes in the Post as careful and nuanced, "...far more dovish and human-rights oriented than caricatures of Halbertal as a 'war crimes apologist' by protesters suggested."

To Carpenter, Tuesday's event was not isolated, but part of a larger issue involving freedom of speech on campus. He told the Star Tribune that last year's efforts by some U of M faculty and staff to revoke an invitation to Condoleezza Rice were another example of it, citing people who "...think it’s appropriate to prevent speakers from speaking about topics they’re sensitive about.”

For its part, the U of M chapter of Students for Justice in Palestine tells Mint Press the group has received abusive and threatening messages but plans to continue its activism.

Next Up

Michael Edmund Richmond

Charges: MN man recorded himself sexually assaulting toddler

The 33-year-old man is facing decades in prison if convicted.

FLickr - minneapolis police - Tony Webster - Feb 2020 - crop

Minneapolis cop charged in crash that killed innocent man during pursuit

Charges say he was traveling nearly 90 mph when he slammed into an innocent man's vehicle.

Case Keenum

Matthew Coller: Case vs Teddy is a reminder of Vikings’ 2018 decision

Matthew Coller's work can be found daily at Purple Insider.

snow in May

It's here! Minnesota sees its first snow flurries of the season

Also, watch out for water spouts on Lake Superior.

Wikimedia Commons - COVID vaccine, pfizer, shot - Martin G

Pfizer to seek emergency use authorization to vaccinate kids ages 5 to 11

Pfizer says clinical trials have revealed positive results.

champlin car prowlers

Police remind people to lock car doors after prowlers spotted on camera

These thieves checked the car doors, which were all locked, and were gone within a minute.

Screen Shot 2021-10-21 at 5.14.36 PM

Mayor Carter announces COVID vaccine mandate for St. Paul city workers

It comes after Minneapolis announced the requirement for vaccines or regular testing for city workers in September.

two twelve medical center chaska GSV

Ridgeview cutting hours at 2 Minnesota urgent care locations

Hours of operation at a third location are also being shifted earlier.

Flickr - QFamily - Ben Jerrys

Latest to wade into Mpls. Question 2 debate is ... Ben & Jerry's?

The ice cream business said it supports the creation of a Department of Public Safety.

mickey moore driver's license shared

Mpls. candidate tries to 'set the record straight' about where he lives

Questions about Ward 9 candidate Mickey Moore's residency are quickly piling up.