The governor can't just veto House and Senate funding like that, judge rules

Republicans are happy about the judge's decision.
Author:
Updated:
Original:

When Gov. Mark Dayton vetoed funding for the Minnesota House and Senate, he violated the state Constitution, a judge ruled.

Dayton used a line item veto (that's when the governor vetoes small pieces of a bill instead of the whole thing) the part of a bill that would provided funding for the House and Senate for the next two years.

He did it as a way to get Republican lawmakers back to the table to renegotiate things he didn't like in other bills – like the size of some tax cuts – that he'd already allowed to become law, Session Daily explained. The reason for the line item veto had nothing to do with funding for the Legislature.

So the Republican-controlled House and Senate sued him. They argued Dayton violated the Separation of Powers clause in the Minnesota Constitution.

And Ramsey County Judge John Guthmann agreed.

Wednesday's ruling

The judge ruled in favor of the House and Senate on Wednesday. In his order, Guthmann said Dayton's vetoes "effectively abolished the Legislature," which just isn't allowed.

"Dayton improperly used his line-item veto authority to gain a repeal or modification of unrelated policy legislation by effectively eliminating a co-equal branch of government," Guthmann wrote.

Because Dayton's vetoes were unconstitutional, funding for Legislature did become law with the rest of the bill, MPR News notes.

You can read the entire 22-page order here.

Dayton will appeal

In a statement Wednesday afternoon, Dayton said he plans to appeal the case to the Minnesota Supreme Court.

"It is unfortunate that Republican legislative leaders are using this ruling to avoid completing their work by correcting their serious errors in the last legislative session. From the beginning of my administration, I have worked hard to restore sound fiscal integrity to our state government. My line-item veto was targeted to achieve this result," Dayton said.

Republicans react

After the ruling was released, Republican leaders cheered the judge's decision, and urged Dayton to accept the ruling.

“Today the court ruled an entire branch of government cannot be eliminated by a stroke of the governor’s pen. The governor should accept this verdict and allow the people of Minnesota to move on, instead of continuing to waste taxpayer dollars on expensive litigation," Senate Majority Leader Paul Gazelka said in a statement.

And here's House Speaker Kurt Daudt:

https://twitter.com/kdaudt/status/887717129692356610

Next Up

Flickr - Minnesota state senate chamber - Matt Lewis

Calls for investigation after former DFL staffer details sexual harassment

Cynthia Callais provided her account to the Minnesota Reformer.

Motzko and Schuneman

Driver in Orono crash that killed Motzko, Schuneman is in custody

The 51-year-old reportedly turned himself into police Wednesday.

Miguel Sano

Twins smash 7 homers, still lose to Tigers

It was a wild afternoon at Target Field.

Pixabay - school - classroom

Decision on school mask mandates will be up to local districts

It will not come from the health or education departments, an official said Wednesday.

spices recall

McCormick recalling some spice mixes sold in Minnesota

The company issued the voluntary recall over possible salmonella risk.

the mayo clinic - edit

Mayo Clinic named No. 1 on 'Best Hospitals' list

It's the sixth year in a row the Rochester hospital has been named the best of the best.

36262 Ottertail Rd, Battle Lake, Minnesota - September 2009

Bystander on dock sees teen struggling in water, jumps in to save him

The teen kept going under the surface near a dam on Otter Tail Lake.

castaway club camp

Cluster of COVID-19 cases tied to camp in western Minnesota

Ten cases have been reported among staff, report states.

Screen Shot 2021-07-28 at 12.16.13 PM

Rodgers pummels Packers front office in viral press conference

"The rules are the same for most people, but every now and then there are some outliers."

Pexels - mother child mask covid

MDH urging that all wear face masks, 12+ get vaccinated for upcoming school year

State health officials revealed their COVID-19 recommendations for 2021-22.

sunfish 1

Gallery: Aspen-inspired estate on private lake is yours for $4.95M

Each bedroom has its own bathroom. And there are four laundry rooms.

Flickr - Halloween costumes masks shops - Chuck Falzone

Struggling for staff, Mankato Halloween business will put out-of-town workers up in hotels

The business is trying to attract workers from as far away as Iowa and Wisconsin.

Related

The governor will let budget bills become law – but the drama isn't over

Dayton is accusing Republican lawmakers of sneaking in a 'poison pill' – and is taking action to force them back to the table.

The governor just noped 5 big budget bills

We explain what it means in the big picture, and why it matters.

Dayton: I'll veto bill stopping cities setting own minimum wage, sick leave rules

The only way it could pass is if the Republicans make some serious budget concessions.

The Senate passed a Sunday liquor sales bill

This is the closest Minnesota has come to having Sunday liquor sales. But there's still work that needs to be done before it's official

The Senate passed a revised Real ID bill – here's what needs to happen next

We might not need a passport to fly domestically next year!

House and Senate vote to use reserve fund to pay state debt to schools

Both the House and Senate approved Republican-backed bills to pay off Minnesota's debt to its schools by drawing down the reserve fund. But Governor Dayton is not a fan of the idea. Dayton and other DFLers think it would leave the reserve fund too depleted.

Grand Portage State Park

Senate GOP threatens State Parks, DNR shutdown if 'Clean Cars' rule isn't scrapped

Republicans are willing to hold up the omnibus environment bill to stop the MPCA from enacting Clean Cars rules.