Skip to main content

The governor can't just veto House and Senate funding like that, judge rules

Republicans are happy about the judge's decision.

When Gov. Mark Dayton vetoed funding for the Minnesota House and Senate, he violated the state Constitution, a judge ruled.

Dayton used a line item veto (that's when the governor vetoes small pieces of a bill instead of the whole thing) the part of a bill that would provided funding for the House and Senate for the next two years.

He did it as a way to get Republican lawmakers back to the table to renegotiate things he didn't like in other bills – like the size of some tax cuts – that he'd already allowed to become law, Session Daily explained. The reason for the line item veto had nothing to do with funding for the Legislature.

So the Republican-controlled House and Senate sued him. They argued Dayton violated the Separation of Powers clause in the Minnesota Constitution.

And Ramsey County Judge John Guthmann agreed.

Wednesday's ruling

The judge ruled in favor of the House and Senate on Wednesday. In his order, Guthmann said Dayton's vetoes "effectively abolished the Legislature," which just isn't allowed.

"Dayton improperly used his line-item veto authority to gain a repeal or modification of unrelated policy legislation by effectively eliminating a co-equal branch of government," Guthmann wrote.

Because Dayton's vetoes were unconstitutional, funding for Legislature did become law with the rest of the bill, MPR News notes.

You can read the entire 22-page order here.

Dayton will appeal

In a statement Wednesday afternoon, Dayton said he plans to appeal the case to the Minnesota Supreme Court.

"It is unfortunate that Republican legislative leaders are using this ruling to avoid completing their work by correcting their serious errors in the last legislative session. From the beginning of my administration, I have worked hard to restore sound fiscal integrity to our state government. My line-item veto was targeted to achieve this result," Dayton said.

Republicans react

After the ruling was released, Republican leaders cheered the judge's decision, and urged Dayton to accept the ruling.

“Today the court ruled an entire branch of government cannot be eliminated by a stroke of the governor’s pen. The governor should accept this verdict and allow the people of Minnesota to move on, instead of continuing to waste taxpayer dollars on expensive litigation," Senate Majority Leader Paul Gazelka said in a statement.

And here's House Speaker Kurt Daudt:

https://twitter.com/kdaudt/status/887717129692356610

Next Up

Screen Shot 2022-05-21 at 9.56.21 AM

North High principal Mauri Friestleben returning to finish year

The principal said Friday she had been fired from her role over her support of a student protest.

ambulance

One dead, two injured in wrong-way crash on Hwy. 169

The crash occurred on Highway 169 early Sunday morning.

minneapolis police

Man fatally shot overnight in north Minneapolis

The shooting was reported around 2:20 a.m.

Screen Shot 2022-05-22 at 8.30.08 AM

Campsites closed at Voyageurs National Park due to 'historic' water levels

All backcountry trails and campsites are closed, as well as many frontcountry sites.

state capitol Minnesota

Lawmakers reach agreement on tax cuts ahead of session's end

Lawmakers announced they had reached a deal on a tax bill Saturday ahead of the looming session deadline.

281699116_10226502238438986_800951410789352812_n

Victims of daytime drive-by shooting in Robbinsdale identified

The two men died after a hail of bullets struck a vehicle.

Screen Shot 2022-05-22 at 8.14.37 AM

Source of 'loud explosion' in Brooklyn Park a mystery

The noise was investigated by police, but no source could be determined.

covid, vaccine, booster shots

COVID: All Americans over 50 advised to get a second booster

Cases, hospitalizations and deaths are on the rise again as new COVID variants emerge.

J.W. Peck (left) and Eric Galler.

2 Minnesotans inducted into White Castle's Hall of Fame

White Castle — it's what a man in Minneapolis and another in Woodbury, crave.

Screen Shot 2022-05-21 at 5.46.37 PM

Video shows officers ended pursuit before fatal crash in Anoka

The crash occurred when the driver fled police during an attempted traffic stop in Coon Rapids.

Eli Hart

6-year-old Eli Hart identified as boy found dead in car trunk

The kindergartner's father was trying to get full custody of his son.

IMG_3509

Boy found dead in trunk of car in Mound was kindergartner

"It is horrifying and difficult to process a tragedy of this magnitude, especially in our close-knit community," the superintendent wrote.

Related

The governor will let budget bills become law – but the drama isn't over

Dayton is accusing Republican lawmakers of sneaking in a 'poison pill' – and is taking action to force them back to the table.

The governor just noped 5 big budget bills

We explain what it means in the big picture, and why it matters.

Dayton: I'll veto bill stopping cities setting own minimum wage, sick leave rules

The only way it could pass is if the Republicans make some serious budget concessions.

The Senate passed a Sunday liquor sales bill

This is the closest Minnesota has come to having Sunday liquor sales. But there's still work that needs to be done before it's official

The Senate passed a revised Real ID bill – here's what needs to happen next

We might not need a passport to fly domestically next year!

What's in Senate Republicans' health care cost plan – and why Democrats don't like it

It's the first major step to address a problem both parties have acknowledged.

Gov. Dayton and Republican leaders make no progress on their budget veto fight

They spent more than a day in mediation, but got nowhere on the veto battle.