Skip to main content

So what happens if a jury can't come to a decision?

The jury in the Yanez manslaughter trial appears to be deadlocked.

The jury in the officer Jeronimo Yanez manslaughter trial seems to be deadlocked after three days, unable to come to a unanimous agreement on whether the officer was reckless when he fatally shot Philando Castile.

In court Wednesday, Judge William H. Leary III reread part of the jury instructions, saying it's the jury's "goal" to reach a verdict – but only if each person can do so without "violating your individual judgement."

Leary, reading the instructions, said jurors should decide the case for themselves, but only after considering the views of the other jurors. After that, he sent them back to continue deliberating. As of Thursday morning, the jury had deliberated for about 20 hours.

What happens if they can't agree?

If a jury can't come to a unanimous decision – all of them agreeing on the same thing – it's called a hung jury. At that point the judge can declare a mistrial.

How long jury deliberations last before a mistrial is declared is up to the judge.

(Note: The jury can deliver a partial verdict. So if they unanimously agree on at least one of the charges against Yanez, they can deliver that verdict. But Scott Swanson, a professor at the University of St. Thomas School of Law, told GoMN jurors have to express that to the judge.)

Swanson said he thinks the judge will probably have the jury keep deliberating if the vote is close (like 11-1). But if the vote is still tight (say, 7-5), the judge will probably declare a mistrial the next time the jury contacts them saying they're deadlocked.

What if the judge declares a mistrial?

A mistrial pretty much means the trial couldn't finish as normal, so it's void. Like it never happened.

If a judge declares a mistrial, the prosecution gets to decide whether the case will be retried and attempted again. In the Yanez case, that's the Ramsey County Attorney's Office.

If you're really interested in trial procedures, you can read all about it in the Minnesota Court Rules here.

Next Up

walz flanagan lorie shaull flickr

Gov. proposes 'Walz Checks' for most Minnesotans

The governor wants to use $700 million of the state's surplus to fund the payments.

Hutch crash booking photo

Walz, Flanagan call on Hennepin Co. sheriff to resign

"I would say that it is time for him to resign," the Lt. Gov. said.

line 3 enbridge portage lake hubbard county mn tony webster flickr

Months after missing deadline, Enbridge says Line 3 aquifer breach is fixed

The company told Bring Me The News it "successfully stopped the flow of groundwater" at the site.

canada bodies found

Baby, teenager among 4 found dead along MN, Canada border

Authorities believe all four froze to death.

unsplash roller rink skates CROP

Former roller rink, tennis courts will become new sports hub

The Wooddale Fun Zone has been closed since spring of 2020.

hibachi daruma

Popular hibachi food truck opens second Twin Cities restaurant

The much-anticipated Daruma opens for takeout Thursday evening.

20211128_Vikings_49ers_REG12_0144 (1)

What changes are coming to the Vikings' offensive line?

Once again, Minnesota has work to do to figure out its interior spots

Kris Ehresmann

One of Minnesota's key COVID-19 leaders is retiring

Kris Ehresmann has given more than 30 years of her life to public health in Minnesota.

summit beach park orono

Plan to develop Orono park on hold after Daytons object

The Dayton family donated the land to the city for the park in the 1970s.

covid nurse doctor hospital wikimedia commons

Child from Twin Cities, school staff member die from COVID

Both deaths were reported by the Minnesota Department of Health Thursday.

snow

3 clippers will deliver snow to Minnesota through Tuesday

Clippers move through Friday night, Saturday night and again Monday.

Related

Video: What exactly the jury has to decide in the Jeronimo Yanez trial

We spoke with a legal expert to learn more about what the jury has to consider.

Dashcam video from the Philando Castile shooting

The video released Tuesday is graphic. It was shown to the jury during the Jeronimo Yanez trial.

Video: Castile's family talks about the 'landmark decision' to bring charges

Philando Castile's family supports the decision to charge the officer Yanez with second-degree manslaughter.

As Jeronimo Yanez case draws to a close, 3 key points from the trial

The jury is expected to begin deliberations Monday.

Read the letter of support the judge in the Yanez trial wrote to jurors

"You were never asked to decide whether racism continues to exist."

Jurors see dash cam footage of Yanez shooting Castile

Opening arguments in the cop's manslaughter trial included video.