Headlights need to be on if it's raining or snowing – even lightly – court says

Just turn your headlights on. Even if it's not raining or snowing hard.
Author:
Updated:
Original:

There's no gray area within state law – if you're driving on a highway and it's raining, snowing, sleeting or hailing, your headlights absolutely have to be on.

That's the conclusion from judges with the Minnesota Court of Appeals, which Monday ruled in a case that argued the law allowed for some wiggle room.

A woman, Catherine McCabe, had gotten pulled over in December of 2015 by Minneapolis police while driving in light rain, in part for not having her lights on, the ruling says. Cops found a handgun in her car, which she did not have a permit to carry, and she was charged.

But McCabe wanted evidence from the stop suppressed, saying police had no reasonable suspicion she was violating any traffic laws when they pulled her over. One of the officers said he stopped her because he thought her headlights and taillights weren't lit.

The district court ruled in McCabe's favor, and found the officers didn't have reasonable suspicion of illegal activity to pull McCabe's car over.

The ruling Monday

The Court of Appeals says that was the wrong determination.

Here's the Minnesota statute that lays out when your headlights have to be on:

The district court, Monday's ruling explains, looked at the statute as almost an "either or" law – that if things were still clearly visible 500 feet ahead, then you don't need your headlights on, no matter if it's raining or not.

But the Court of Appeals ruling says combining "the inclement-weather provision ... with the visibility provision," was incorrect. The law includes "unambiguous language," and the inclusion of "at any other time" in the third requirement makes it pretty clear the provisions should be considered independently.

They also considered whether the fact that it was "sprinkling" mattered. But the Court of Appeals determined it doesn't – even if it isn't raining hard, drops of water coming from the sky is still considered "raining."

The ruling sends the case back to the lower court to be considered again.

Next Up

Kyle Rudolph

Rudolph sends farewell to Vikings fans in Players Tribune piece

"Every season I played here, every game I played here — you all believed."

Megan Ryan

Star Tribune's Megan Ryan named new Twins beat reporter

Ryan replaces LaVelle E. Neal who is now in a columnist role.

minnetonka MME

Minnetonka in spotlight after teacher threatened for discussing Black trans woman

Parents and community members are calling on the district to do better and will hold a march prior to the school board meeting on Thursday.

Richard Pitino

Talk grows that this season will be Pitino's last at Gophers

A report says Pitino's tenure could be "down to his final games."

Screen Shot 2021-03-02 at 1.40.17 PM

Two gas trucks collide in Stearns County, neither explodes

The unlikely collision happened Monday afternoon.

unnamed (1)

MSP Airport expecting spring break to be busiest period since pandemic began

Passenger numbers will still be about a third lower than a year ago, though.

Target store

After bumper earnings, Target will accelerate new store openings

The retailer has revealed its plans for the next few years, which includes an investment in Minneapolis.

starbucks wayzata

100% plant-based restaurant coming to Wayzata this spring

The restaurant has plans to add additional locations in Minnesota this summer and franchise nationwide.

Patric Richardson

'Laundry Evangelist' from St. Paul gets his own Discovery+ show

Patric Richardson has built a career around the appreciation and care of clothing.

Related

Reminder: If it's snowing, you need to turn your headlights on

Here's what Minnesota law says about lights while driving in poor weather.

A few inches of snow will hit Minnesota – and driving Thursday could be tough

It's not going to be a ton of snow, but the frigid temps complicate things.

Twin Cities avoids big snow, but road conditions across the state are icy

The Northland got the worst of the snowfall, though all drivers need to watch for icy roads.

Freezing rain, snow cause bad driving conditions this morning

A mix of snow and rain is expected throughout the day.