Skip to main content

Here's why some people think electric car owners should pay an extra fee

A bill in the Minnesota House would create a $75 a year surcharge on electric cars.

Republican leaders of the Minnesota House released a plan Tuesday that would spend $2 billion improving the state's roads and bridges over the next two years.

A key selling point in the House GOP transportation bill is that – unlike the approach favored by Gov. Mark Dayton and his fellow DFLers – it would not raise your taxes or fees. Unless you drive an electric vehicle.

As Session Daily reports, the plan includes a $75 annual surcharge for owners of electric cars. That would generate just a small piece of the $2 billion in new money, most of which would come from borrowing or by moving existing tax money from the general fund to roads. DFLers say a gas tax increase would provide a longer-term source of revenue to keep roads in good shape.

Why a fee for electric cars?

A lot of the money that Minnesota uses to build and maintain its roads (45 percent of it, according to one analysis) comes from the state's gas tax.

People who drive electric cars don't buy gas, so they don't pay that tax. A surcharge on electric vehicles is seen as a way for those drivers to share in the cost of maintaining the roads they use.

Other states are doing it. Forbes says there are now 10 states charging electric car owners an annual fee.

The New York Times reports there's some concern that charging those fees will discourage people from buying electric cars, which are sometimes called Zero Emission Vehicles because they don't add to air pollution. Georgia saw electric car sales drop from 1,300 one month to 97 the next when they got rid of a tax break for electric car owners and started charging a $200 registration fee, the Times says.

Study: Electric car owners pay more in taxes

The group Drive Electric Minnesota maintains that electric car owners already pay share of road maintenance through higher taxes on their pricier vehicles.

Their study found that since electric cars cost more than gas-powered vehicles, buyers pay more in sales taxes when they make the purchase. They also spend more when they buy tabs every year because that cost is based on the value of the car (for the first 10 years, anyway).

It's not like there are a whole ton of electric cars on the road. Midwest Energy News says there are fewer than 4,000 in Minnesota.

Sales are increasing, though. Forbes says they were up 37 percent last year. According to Inside EVs.com last month's total set a new record and they're up to 0.9 percent of total vehicle sales in the U.S.

Next Up

Anthony Edwards

Ant's fast start can't snap Grizzlies winning streak

Memphis extended its streak to 11 games with a 116-108 victory over the Timberwolves.

Kirill Kaprizov

Wild have 2 players named to NHL All-Star Game

The Wild could have a third representative through the "Last Man In" ballot.

trattoria mucci facebook

Popular Italian eatery in Uptown to permanently close

The owner of Trattoria Mucci said it "just didn't work out this time."

colbert redmons billboard jan 2022

MN popcorn shop gets Times Square billboard via 'The Late Show'

The last time Redmon's Popcorn got national attention, it shut down two days later.

child parent mask covid pexels

Frey backtracks on dining mandate: Kids age 2-4 won’t need test

The mayor told Chad Hartman the city is already working to change its just-announced regulation.

264 Willmar Ave SE, Willmar, Minnesota - October 2019

11 staff members on leave after refusing Willmar district's COVID policy

The staff members were placed on leave after they "opted not to comply."

TIMOTHY BORRMAN

Man charged with stealing van with dog inside in South St. Paul

He apparently said he didn't realize there was a dog inside.

Screen Shot 2022-01-13 at 12.35.16 PM

Here's where COVID-19 case rates are the highest in Minnesota

The highest rates can be found mainly in southeastern Minnesota and around the Twin Cities metro area.

als breakfast facebook post

After staff got COVID, someone sent Al's Breakfast a letter mocking its vaxx requirement

"So sorry to hear your fully vaccinated staff is sick with Covid and you are forced to close," the letter begins.

snow - 12-10-21 - Joe Nelson - 2

NWS releases snowfall forecast for specific Minnesota cities

Here's how much snow is forecast for more than 50 cities in Minnesota, including the majority of the metro area.

Related

Hear that hybrid comin'? New electric cars will have to make noise

A new rule aimed at improving pedestrian safety says electric cars in the U.S. will have to make a sound

Don't be shocked by the surge of state employees in electric cars

Minnesota's fleet of state-owned cars is getting more electric.

World Car-Free Day is next Thursday, here's why it's important

Thursday, Sept. 23, campaigners are asking you to consider a different way of getting to work.

Yes, you can get a DWI on an electric bike

A bicyclist on an electric bike ran into a pickup truck recently.

Minnesota's first electric school bus could save thousands of dollars

It's a zero-emissions electric bus, the first of its kind in the state.

Minnesota's first electric school bus could save thousands of dollars

It's a zero-emissions electric bus, the first of its kind in the state.

Renewing your license or car tabs? Watch out for the computer shutdown

Computer upgrades mean there will be a dead zone on the calendar.

Would you pay to drive through Wisconsin? You might have to

The state could earn up to $40 billion in 30 years by adding toll booths, new study says.