Skip to main content

In the 'Happy Holidays' v 'Merry Christmas' debate – the Midwest prefers to be merry

Midwesterners prefer their stores to say "Merry Christmas."
  • Author:
  • Updated:

'Merry Christmas' v 'Happy Holidays,' it's the debate that will probably never end.

But a poll that was analyzed by FiveThirtyEight shows that preference for seasonal greetings isn't just a matter of religious v secular, but it is also regional and political too.

After a poll carried out the Public Religion Research Institute asked people whether American retailers should greet customers with "Happy Holidays" or "Season's Greetings" rather than "Merry Christmas," FiveThirtyEight broke down the results by region.

In doing this, it found the Midwest exhibits the biggest preference for "Merry Christmas," with a net 11 percent in favor of the traditional, religious greeting. The western U.S. preferred this too, while the east coast and southern U.S. favor "Happy Holidays."

The analysis found that evangelicals heavily prefer "Merry Christmas," so it's not surprising that some of the more religious states in so-called "flyover country" prefer this greeting.

It's surprising that the Bible Belt south leans toward the secular greeting, though FiveThirtyEight says this is because the southern black population tend to prefer "Happy Holidays" despite being highly religious.

Political lines separate too, with Republicans preferring Merry Christmas at a higher rate than even evangelical Christians (70 percent to 62 percent).

Another interesting finding is that non-religious people in less religious states such as Oregon actually prefer to say "Merry Christmas," and this is because "social stakes are low."

"Christmas is not an entre to conversations about what church you attend, but more about presents, ugly sweaters and Santa," the website says.

During his campaign, Donald Trump said: "If I become president, we’re gonna be saying Merry Christmas at every store … You can leave happy holidays at the corner."

FiveThirtyEight however concludes that based on the data the "War on Christmas" is not a national one, but rather a series of "local skirmishes."

Next Up

Dean Evason

Tempers flare as Wild hammer Canadiens

Montreal was anything but polite after the Wild picked up an 8-2 victory.

Blaine VFW video screengrab crop N West Twitter

Authorities now looking into MN lawmaker's report of assault

Video shows Rep. Nolan West being grabbed and pushed out of a public event.

TajPharmaImages WIkimedia Commons ivermectin

COVID treatments: Essentia Health to help test 3 existing meds

The clinical trial includes the much-discussed drug ivermectin.

Screen Shot 2022-01-24 at 3.48.57 PM

Suspect crashes into Minneapolis snow plow, fires shots at plow driver

The plow driver was pulled to the side of the road when the incident happened.

cold Minneapolis

Coldest day of the winter is possible this week in Minnesota

An air temp of -30F isn't out of the question too far from the metro.

polley freeborn county jail roster jan 2022 resize

District fires school counselor accused of sexually assaulting student

He's been charged with felony criminal sexual conduct.

Moorhead family

Authorities pinpoint source of CO that killed family of 7

The victims, all members of Hernandez-Pinto family, were found dead in a Moorhead home.

polymet mining

Court issues mixed ruling on PolyMet, orders more analysis on water permit

The court, however, overruled several challenges to the permit.

SPPD Kua person of interest 01-24-2022

Police release images of woman driving stolen Audi that had puppy inside

It's not clear whether she was involved in the vehicle theft.

J R Jones - Anoka County Jail 2021.10.16 - Resize crop

Fatal hit-and-run driver can avoid prison time with plea deal

He was charged with striking and killing a 56-year-old who was walking her dog.

Screen Shot 2022-01-24 at 11.21.49 AM

Alex Rodriguez: 'I'm not a Packers fan'

He was at Lambeau screaming "Cheese!" and "Let's go!" during the playoff game against the 49ers.


After thousands March for Life in St. Paul, what will happen to Roe v. Wade?

Will a Trump presidency and GOP-led Congress put the landmark Supreme Court ruling at risk?

Fringe MN governor candidate refuses to acknowledge Islam as a faith

"It sends a message to his supporters that Minnesota is only for a certain population, and that excludes Muslims," one woman says.

What Minnesota's U.S. lawmakers have said about Trump's immigration order

What Minnesota' U.S. lawmakers have said about Donald Trump's executive order restricting travel and refugees.

No happy holidays for Target, with stores not selling as much as hoped

Slumping electronics and entertainment sales hit Target in the pocket this past Christmas.

WTH is NSEERS and why are people talking about it?

NSEERS was used post-9/11 to track male visitors from certain countries – mainly in the Middle East.

President Donald Trump says recent anti-Semitic threats are 'horrible'

Two of Minnesota's Jewish Community Centers have been targeted by bomb threats recently.

Nordstrom is selling rocks for $85 ... and of course they sold out

"A paperweight? A conversation piece? A work of art? It's up to you ... "

Thunderstorms, sleet, snow: Merry Christmas everyone!

The song goes "I'm dreaming of a thunderstorm for Christmas," right?